Heather Fowler-Salamini has given us a rich and satisfying book on the social and economic contours of coffee processing in the Córdoba district of Veracruz. Situated along the road leading from the coastal port of Veracruz to Mexico City, just east of the Orizaba textile district, at the end of the nineteenth century Córdoba became one of the three centres of coffee production in Mexico, along with Xalapa, just to the north, and the Soconusco region of Chiapas, far to the south. Coffee, rising to become a classic global commodity in the nineteenth century, tied the lives of landowners, rural and urban workers, local and immigrant entrepreneurs, and Mexican officials to the Atlantic economy.
Fowler-Salamini constructs a portrait of Córdoba for the period between the rise of the coffee economy in the last decades of the nineteenth century and the full mechanisation of coffee processing in the 1950s. The book's first chapter provides a masterful overview of Córdoba's coffee economy over the century between 1850 and 1950. Immigrant entrepreneurs take centre stage, beginning with five Spanish families who had emerged by the turn of the century to build and dominate the processing and exporting business in the city. They had to negotiate not only with the competing interests of local planters and workers, but also with global firms like the Arbuckle Coffee Company based in New York.
But the book's primary focus rests on the thousands of women who sat for hours at long tables to sort coffee beans by grade, one step in the long processing chain that linked coffee trees on hillside fincas to the exporting firms that bought and shipped Mexican beans to fill rising demand in Europe and the United States. Nearly all workers in the labour-intensive cleaning and sorting departments were women, and their working lives and culture constitute the subject of chapters 2 to 6. Men staffed nearly all other positions in the large-scale beneficios, or processing plants, built within the city limits of Córdoba. As a result, successful efforts by women sorters to organise unions after the revolution of 1910–20 created a powerful voice for labour in the region. While these chapters focus on the lives of coffee sorters within the beneficios, the activities of the sorters’ union and its leadership take centre stage. Here Fowler-Salamini offers a nicely detailed portrait of the internal dynamics of union activities and politics. Her story of this female union and its leaders roughly matches histories of men's unions around the middle of the century: organising successes supported by the legal and cultural legacy of the revolution, a mediating role for the state labour boards, co-optive efforts by the state, and an aggressive, often self-aggrandising leadership that too often placed its own interests above those of the workers. In Córdoba, several powerful caciquas dominated union politics and monopolised mediation with management and the state. Fowler-Salamini complements this political story with oral histories of women who worked in the beneficios around mid-century. Their testimony allows her to explore the ‘everyday experiences’ and cultures of women as they navigated the equally demanding worlds of the workplace, the home and the street. Between the mid-1950s and 1960s, however, a protracted struggle between the processing firms and the sorters’ union ended with the introduction of fully mechanised sorting machines. Thousands of Córdoban women lost the opportunities that coffee sorting had provided for nearly four generations.
As an urban, essentially industrial and often regular source of employment, coffee sorting, in Fowler-Salamini's account, offered women new opportunities ‘to find more secure employment, guaranteed wage work, and better working conditions than ever before’ (p. 281). The story told here is primarily one of new opportunities that demand for coffee in the North Atlantic offered to Mexican labourers, and especially to women. Although Fowler-Salamini acknowledges the challenges that women faced on the shop floor and in navigating the new social demands of work and home, her tone throughout is one of opportunity and empowerment. Tellingly, she locates forces working against sorters’ interests not in the impersonal and implacable structures of global capitalism, not in the foreign purchasing firms like Arbuckle Coffee, or among the local owners of the beneficios, or in state officials and politicians, but rather within the small handful of women who emerged to lead the sorters’ union from the 1930s to the 1960s. Assessing their story is complicated, and Fowler-Salamini traces their success in building union strength as well as their failure consistently to represent the best interests of their rank and file.
The rich portrait offered by Fowler-Salamini in this book satisfies, but its success serves also to beg further questions. She argues, for example, that although coffee sorting provided a decent livelihood for thousands of women, and crucial support for their families, it did not provide a venue for upward mobility. Half a century later, well after manual coffee sorting had been replaced by machines, these women worked as ‘street vendors, waitresses, owners of small stores, and food preparers’ (p. 287). Some of their children got an education and joined the ranks of the middle classes, from shop owners to professionals, but these experiences were exceptional. Most, by implication, remained among Mexico's working poor at the end of the twentieth century. Was coffee sorting, like so many once manual operations in an increasingly industrial economy, a dead end for most of its workers? If sorting represented a real opportunity for working women to improve their material and social positions in the first half of the twentieth century, as Fowler-Salamini implies, why were they not able to translate this opportunity into some kind of intergenerational upward mobility? One large part of the answer certainly lies with the state, and the kinds of public goods and services (like education) that were or were not provided by municipal, state and national authorities. But such questions would require another book altogether. This fine study adds to an increasingly deep literature on three topics: coffee economies and cultures in Latin America (and agricultural exports generally); the history of women's labour and lives during the critical transition from rural to urban societies; and increasingly diverse and regionally situated studies of a modernising Mexico.
