Isabella Cosse's book on Argentina's most famous comic strip, Mafalda, created by Quino (Joaquín Salvador Lavado), is an impressively researched study of the social life of a cultural product. Recounting the history of the strip and its eponymous protagonist from their first appearance in the mid-1960s right up to Mafalda's presence as a huge inflatable doll celebrating the election of Cristina Fernández de Kirchner in 2011, Cosse looks at the comic both on and beyond the page.
The book is divided into five chapters. The first two chapters recount the history of the strip during the period of its publication from the mid-1960s until 1973, when Quino stopped drawing Mafalda at a time when the political situation in Argentina was becoming increasingly divided between the revolutionary Left and the authoritarian Right. As Cosse points out, by the mid-1970s Mafalda's politics had become anachronistic. Using close analysis of a selection of strips (many of which are helpfully reproduced), Cosse successfully demonstrates how, up until that point, Mafalda engaged in highly contemporaneous and sharply humorous fashion with Argentine current affairs. In particular, Cosse stresses, during this period Mafalda both interpellated and acted as a voice for the Argentine middle class. The third chapter turns its attention to the globalisation of the strip during the same period, with particular focus on Italy, Spain and Mexico. Cosse argues that Quino's transnational success was a result of the way that his humour surpassed ‘national, social and generational’ boundaries to ‘illuminate the human condition’ (19). Chapter 4 returns to the Argentine context but looks at the life of Mafalda during the 1976–83 dictatorship and the subsequent return to democracy. Cosse recounts the intriguing post-dictatorship speculations about what would have happened to Mafalda had she grown up. Quino's own polemic suggestion that she would have been one of the disappeared only fuelled the perception that Mafalda was representative of the combative younger generations of the 1960s and 1970s (222). In the final chapter, Cosse looks further at the more recent trends in the globalisation of the strip and the manner in which Mafalda has become a myth, open to ongoing historical resignifications.
In the first half of the book, Cosse's analysis is very effective at demonstrating the generational tensions evident in the specificities of Argentine middle-class politics during the 1960s and 1970s. As she points out, there is a ‘lack of studies that explain the contradictory stance’ between, on the one hand, the middle class as being located on the side of ‘moral crusades and the “antisubversive” struggle’ and, on the other, its contribution to the political ‘radicalisation of the young’ during the 1960s and 1970s (p. 35). Likewise, she draws attention to the intriguing ways that Mafalda has been used, and reworked, by both Left and Right for the promotion of particular ideological positions. In the second half of the book Cosse is slightly less focused in terms of her argument about Mafalda and the middle class. According to Cosse, Mafalda offered a focal point of nostalgia and resistance ‘for the middle classes in different countries, whose material conditions of existence and whose identities, forged thirty years earlier, were becoming fractured’ (p. 228). Mafalda, she adds, came to represent ‘a sensibility that tied together ideology, aesthetics and subjectivity in the face of the neoliberal drive’ (p. 245). Perhaps, however, Cosse could have explored in more depth the precise nature of the nostalgia and resistance she suggests the Argentine middle classes found in Malfalda during post-dictatorship neoliberalism. Did that nostalgia for that earlier period, one expressed by Quino himself (p. 251), include a longing for the armed struggle that so divided the middle class? And how, moreover, do the tensions between pre- and post-dictatorship generations play out in terms of Mafalda when remembering the 1960s and the 1970s? In that sense, Cosse highlights how, in France, Mafalda was caught between those who criticised an overly romantic portrait of the 1960s and those who wanted to ‘reclaim the “spirit” of 1968 with the celebration of collective action, the libertarian ideal and the utopian imagination’ (p. 299). More of such observations could have been helpful in unpacking the differences between expressions of collective action in the 1960s and the 1990s, and the differences between resistance and middle-class nostalgia in Europe and in Latin America.
Nevertheless, Cosse's study of Mafalda does, as she sets out to do, throw light on the highly contentious nature of Argentine culture, society and politics over the past thirty years, particularly in terms of the country's middle classes. She is also very convincing in demonstrating some of the ways that a highly Argentine creation was able to transcend national boundaries and speak to people around the globe, not least as a result of the portable nature of Quino's humour and perceptivity. As a result, Cosse's highly readable book makes an extremely valuable contribution to the growing fields of scholarship on both the middle class and comics.
