This book is a somewhat expanded English version of the author's Le Jihad: Origines, Interpretations, Combats (2005). It traces the historical development of the doctrine and practice of jihad and discusses the ideological and practical settings within which this occurred, stressing the diversity of both the sources and the forms of jihad. It provides a detailed overview but does not attempt an in-depth study.
The author regularly engages with the major scholarly work in the field, both by older scholars such as Wellhausen, Goldziher, Schacht, and Montgomery Watt and by more recent scholars such as John Wansbrough, Albrecht Noth, Patricia Crone, and Michael Cook but usually without committing himself to their positions. Although he accepts that we have little certain knowledge about the earliest period of Islam, this does not seem very important for his purpose. What is important and incontrovertible is that “something new happened in early seventh-century Arabia. . .that brought about a transformation of social and spiritual life, in part through participation in combat” (p. 70). Out of this, jihad developed and coalesced as a recognizable doctrine in the 8th century, with earlier Islamic and non-Islamic roots.
In Chapter 1 the author states that jihad is “first of all” a body of legal doctrine but involves much more. He discusses its relation to the Western “just war” doctrines and notes other ways of thinking about war, distinct but often related, in the pre-Islamic and Islamic environment. He also introduces some areas of juridical debate, such as who is the enemy and who leads jihad.
Chapter 2 deals with the Qurʾan, where the word “jihad” appears but is not the main term in connection with fighting. Various related Qurʾanic themes are discussed (see following). Chapter 3 deals with the sīra, maghazi, and hadith literature, from which the doctrine of jihad begins to emerge. The author summarizes the account of early Islamic history given by these and the main themes in the hadith. He also deals with the views of Western scholars on the historical value and nature of this literature. Chapter 4 sketches the early conquests and contrasts the futūḥ (conquest) and maghazi literature, noting contrasting Western evaluations of this literature and presenting the thesis of Cook and Crone in Hagarism and the criticisms of it.
Chapter 5 deals with martyrdom. The Qurʾan speaks of reward for those who die in battle but does not use the term martyr (shahīd) for them—the hadith and later scholars do. Martyrdom is primarily related to death in battle, but other types of martyrdom are also mentioned. The contrast with Christian martyrdom is also discussed. Chapter 6 deals with the Muslims' relation with dhimmīs and outside unbelievers (dār al-ḥarb). Chapter 7 deals with scholars who also engaged in fighting, an important group for the idea of jihad. It also deals with such concepts as ribāṭ (defensive war or related fortifications) and fard kifāya (an obligation to be fulfilled by part of the community).
Chapter 8 discusses the practice of jihad by the Umayyads and Abbasids and their opponents and by later “frontier states,” including the early Ottomans and figures such as Salah al-Din. It refers to “ghazi-caliphs” and “ghazi sultans,” who both ruled and personally went to war. Chapter 9 deals briefly and selectively with the modern period. It notes some of the earlier responses to European imperialism, then Islamists such as Sayyid Qutb, and then “global” Islamist fighters such as Osama bin Laden. Although I recognize that this chapter is intentionally limited, I am disappointed that it does not acknowledge the breadth of the current use of the term jihad, referring, as it can, to revolution, resistance to imperialism, and economic development; it is used by secularists as well as by Islamists. The concluding chapter begins with a summary of the early part of the book and ends with some thoughtful comments on contemporary radicals.
As mentioned previously, this book is a survey, not an in-depth study, and so some readers may be disappointed that one topic or another is not treated more thoroughly. I would have liked to see a more unified and complete treatment of the “internal jihad,” or jihād akbar, given its importance in current discussions. The author mentions it in a number of places and states that it was part of the doctrine of jihad from the very beginning but does not say much about its actual content and the authority of its sources.
This book is written very concisely. Major matters are often dealt with in a page or two. This has the advantage of brevity but sometimes is too brief for easy understanding and usually too brief to be convincing. In addition, although the overall organization of the book is reasonably clear, the line of argument within particular chapters is sometimes harder to follow. I found this to be the case, for example, with the chapter on the Qurʾan, which begins with a discussion of terms for fighting, moves on to Reuven Firestone's themes (Jihad: The Origin of Holy War in Islam, 1999), and then ends with the author's own not so clearly related themes.
The author describes his intended reader as “someone who may or may not have basic knowledge of the political and religious history of the Islamic world, but who wishes to find a way through this particular terrain” (p. xv). I think this book is too concise and at the same time too detailed for someone with no basic knowledge of the field, in spite of the simple summaries of relevant historical background at various points. For someone who does have a basic knowledge, however, and especially for someone who has considerable knowledge of Islamic matters but not in this particular area and who wants a good overview of the history of jihad and the Western scholarly discussions, this book will be very helpful.
