Satu Riutta takes up an important and neglected question in this book: Is civic education effective in the rural parts of those Tanzania and Zambia? I commend Riutta for investigating the topic because while civic education programs are very common in both countries, we possess little knowledge about their impact. Considering that well-designed civic education programs can create more engaged citizens, and hence a more participatory democracy, it is useful to consider whether programs in rural Tanzania and Zambia are achieving this worthwhile objective. The author's answer is a qualified yes. Specifically, he finds that while civic education in those two countries improves knowledge of rights and raises interest in politics, it does not increase political efficacy. He also discovers that the impact of civic education is stronger on women than on men. This is a particularly important finding given that women tend to be more politically marginalized than men in most parts of rural sub-Saharan Africa.
The book has some considerable strengths. First, Riutta's exclusive focus on rural areas in both countries (Mtwara Region in Tanzania and Luapula Province in Zambia) is particularly welcome given that research tends to pay more attention to urban and/or national issues than to focus only on rural ones. Second, the author collected an extensive amount of useful information in the two research sites through his use of in-depth surveys and interviews, and he provides an extensive analysis of it. Third, the book sheds light on an important area of donor funding that has received less attention than it deserves. Since civil society has not been as active in helping to consolidate democracy in sub-Saharan Africa as many hoped it would be, and since many governments in the region have rolled back previous democratic concessions, donors have turned their attention to the important role that active and engaged citizens can play in pushing for more accountable and representative government. It is important to know what is working, what is not, and why in civic education, as Riutta attempts to establish.
Democratic Participation in Rural Tanzania and Zambia has a few shortcomings that are important to highlight. First, Riutta does not spend much time discussing civic education efforts in Tanzania and Zambia. I was somewhat surprised by this because it is the book's subject matter. He only reviews some donor-funded programs in the sites where he conducted his surveys. This leaves out many other potentially important sources of civic education, such as through schools and the government. It would be very useful to know if such sources of civic education were occurring in the research sites, as well as the nature of their content. Equally, it would be useful to know if survey respondents listened to popular entertainment shows (like Makutano Junction) that take a more subtle approach to civic education because viewers/listeners may be learning civic content without, perhaps, realizing it.
Second, there are a few methodological concerns to note. These are potentially serious problems because the book relies almost exclusively on quantitative analysis of the survey data collected by Riutta. The most important issue that he does not discuss is selection bias, and it points to the aforementioned lack of information on how respondents obtained their civic education. For example, compulsory civic education for all students in school is very different than donor-funded programs that people must actively seek out if they want to participate in them. There would be no problems of selection bias in the former, but there could be potentially large ones in the latter if people who were interested in politics were more likely to seek out these programs than those that were not. Finally, selection bias could arise because the survey respondents were not a random sample, but chosen by the chiefs or other leaders in each village. It is thus not clear whether the respondents form a representative sample.
This relates to a second methodological concern not addressed by the book—the potential for reverse causality. Riutta finds that civic education improves one's knowledge of rights and interest in politics. This is a reasonable argument. However, it is equally as reasonable to claim that those who know their rights and are most interested in politics are the ones most likely to seek out civic education programs. At a minimum, I would like to have see a more thorough discussion of how people obtained their civic education in order to rule out the potential for reverse causality.
The final methodological concern is that explanatory variables along with civic education in some regressions become dependent variables in others. For example, Riutta uses civic education as an explanatory variable for knowledge of rights. In turn, he employs both civic education and knowledge of rights in regressions on various measures of political participation. Yet since part of people's knowledge of their rights derives from exposure to civic education, the inclusion of both in a regression on political participation potentially reduces the impact of civic education in these models. Riutta could have created a variable to address this potential problem: knowledge of rights that derives from sources other than civic education. These types of fixes would allow for a fuller account of the effect of civic education on the variable of interest. More generally, considering that the book relies exclusively on quantitative findings, it would have been easier to accept the validity of the conclusions had Riutta paid a bit more attention to methodological concerns.
One general shortcoming of the book is the exclusive use of survey data to address the question of the impact of civic education on political knowledge and participation. Although Riutta provides a wealth of data, the book would have benefited from a more qualitative assessment of people's perceptions of what they learned through civic education. Did learning about rights make them feel more empowered? Did it lead to actions other than those his regressions seek to uncover? For example, perhaps civic education does not lead to political participation more broadly, but it might make people feel that they can hold government officials more accountable for their actions, or, at a minimum, teach them how to do so. Including such information would also have improved the book's readability, as at times it is difficult to retain the dense presentation of large amounts of quantitative information in a relatively small amount of space. Moreover, qualitative support that corroborates the book's quantitative findings could have allayed some of the aforementioned methodological weakness. Finally, more qualitative analysis would have made the book somewhat livelier. Its largely quantitative analysis gives it a rather clinical feel, and at times one can lose sight of the fact that the author is examining real people dealing with difficult political challenges.
Overall, I commend Riutta for researching an important project. The book examines a subject—the impact of civic education on political knowledge and participation—that receives less attention than it deserves. It reaches a number of plausible conclusions, although it would be easier to accept their validity had the author paid more attention to some important methodological issues and/or corroborated his findings with qualitative support. Nevertheless, this is a useful undertaking and reaches plausible conclusions (subject to the aforementioned qualifications). I hope it encourages others to focus on the issue.
