Arab Muslims have traveled through Southeast Asian waters since the 8th century and played a role in the waves of Islamic conversion that swept the region from the 14th century on. Abiding by a different migratory logic, Southeast Asians who had studied in Mecca and Cairo played a major role in the reform movements that arose in urban Southeast Asia in the late 19th century. Notwithstanding these and other examples of extended contacts, Southeast Asian ties to the Middle East have been the subject of little sustained historical research. Originating from papers first presented at a conference in 2004 at the Asia Research Institute at the National University of Singapore, this edited volume confirms that the state of scholarship on this important topic is rapidly improving.
The book consists of the editor's introduction followed by thirteen chapters grouped into sections according to historical period: the first centuries of contact, the colonial age, the early 20th century, and contemporary trends. The editor's thoughtful introduction explains the book's background and ambitions, noting that the book's chapters focus on one of two themes: religious contacts between the two regions, or the manner in which changes in each region's political-economic infrastructure altered existing cultural flows. In the 20th century, Tagliacozzo concludes, many Southeast Asians have looked to the Middle East as demonstrating an “alternative modernity” (p. 11) to models offered by the West and postcolonial nationalism.
In the first chapter of the book's section on precolonial contacts, Michael Laffan provides a richly documented account of the terms used by Arab writers and travelers for insular Southeast Asia. He points out that during the first centuries of contact, Arab images of insular Southeast Asia were informed more by Greek sources and Malay toponyms than by firsthand accounts. However, these early tales gave rise to detailed awareness with the pilgrimage of Jâwa Muslims (i.e., Muslims from insular Southeast Asia) to Arabia in the 19th century. In Chapter 3, Timothy Barnard offers an analysis of ties between the Middle East and the Malayo-Indonesia world from the perspective of the Buginese lords who conquered Malay populations in the Riau archipelago (to the south of what is today Singapore). As their power waned due to the 19th-century Dutch colonial advance, the Buginese rulers recruited Arab scholars from the Middle East and pointed to the ruling elites' piety to legitimate their rule over Malay subjects. In Chapter 4, the Malay historian Mohammad Redzuan Othman provides an overview of the role of Arab scholars and merchants in the shaping of Malay Islam.
The historian M. C. Ricklefs opens the book's second section, on the colonial era, with a fine-grained analysis of the way in which pilgrims and scholars returning from the Middle East in the 19th century undermined the traditional “mystic synthesis” on which Javanese Islam had long been grounded. This subtly argued chapter provides one of the finest short summaries available on the rise of late 19th-century Islamic reform in Java. In Chapter 6, Tagliacozzo provides a nuanced yet gripping portrait of the most important colonial scholar of Indonesian Islam, C. Snouck Hurgronje. Drawing on personal letters as well as administrative and scholarly publications, Tagliacozzo demonstrates that Snouck was dedicated to the colonial project but also displayed “an almost ethnographic desire to get as close as possible to his subject” (p. 147).
In Chapter 7, the Malaysia-based historian Sumit K. Mandal examines the early 20th-century rise of the Arab-Indonesian reformist organization, al-Irsyad. Deeply influenced by non-Arab social movements challenging Dutch rule, al-Irsyad linked its critique of rank and privilege within the Arab-Indonesian community to a broader aspiration for social justice and equality. In Chapter 8, the Dutch scholar Nico Kaptein uses the optic of Minangkabau debates (in Sumatra) over the appropriateness of European dress as a point of entry to the larger process whereby “New Group” (Kaum Muda) reformists came to challenge “Old Group” (Kaum Tua) traditionalists. The outcome of the controversy showed that, by the early 20th century, “the traditional hegemony of Mecca as the foremost intellectual center in Southeast Asian Islam had come to an end” (p. 191).
The three chapters in the book's next section, on the late colonial period, all provide perspectives on different aspects of Arab immigrant life. The anthropologist Michael Gilsenan (a leading scholar of Egyptian Islam) traces the connections between property, state authority, and elite social reproduction in Singapore and Java. The German scholar Ulrike Freitag draws on the personal correspondence of a powerful Arab business family to shed light on how Yemeni Muslims organized their business affairs across the vast expanse of the Indian Ocean. The Egyptian sociologist Mona Abaza provides an engaging biographical account of a Jakartan-born Hadrami intellectual to show how Arab-Indonesian authors mediated Indonesian efforts to understand new cultural trends in the Muslim Middle East.
The book's last three chapters all focus on contemporary developments. They also differ from the preceding chapters in focusing on Muslim rebellions and radical social movements. In Chapter 12, the London-based political scientist John T. Sidel takes exception to the findings of organizations like the International Crisis Group to suggest that the rash of radical Islamist violence in Indonesia in the early 2000s occurred largely in response to “a sudden, sharp decline for Islam under conditions of democratization” (p. 310). Also presented in Sidel's other published works, this thesis has proved highly controversial. In Chapter 13, the Jerusalem-based historian of Southeast Asia Moshe Yegar compares Muslim-based conflicts in southern Thailand, the southern Phillipines, and Burma. Rather too darkly, I fear, he concludes that “there is no chance that various development programs in the areas of education, or in economic and social spheres, will be crowned with the results that the governments . . . would like” (p. 343). In the book's last chapter, the Jakartan-based political observer M. Syafi'i Anwar summarizes the bitter contest in Indonesia since 1998 between the proponents of “radical-conservative Islam” and “progressive-liberal Islam” (p. 349). Although some readers might suggest that the core current in Indonesian Muslim politics is made up of moderately conservative Muslim democrats, Anwar's richly detailed essay provides an excellent summary of the liberal–radical standoff.
No book can possibly cover all aspects of migration, commerce, and cultural exchange between the Middle East and Southeast Asia over the past 1000 years. However, this edited collection comes as close as any other text, addressing a broad range of topics and issues with both historical detail and explanatory depth. For anyone interested in state-of-the-field scholarship on ties between these two regions, Tagliacozzo's volume is a welcome and important contribution.
