One of the most complex and important issues in the study of contemporary Brazil is the link between historic practices of state and non-state violence and the tremendous spike in urban conflict and tensions in rural areas of the country in the generation since the transition to democracy. In The Unpast: Elite Violence and Social Control in Brazil, 1954–2000, R. S. Rose attempts to tackle this issue through a close look at growing political tensions and police violence since the 1950s. Starting with an examination of the political issues that led to the collapse of the populist Second Republic (1945–1964), Rose takes the reader on a detailed historical tour of the history of conflict and violence during the dictatorship and in the years since in an effort to show the persistent role of elite social control efforts in the Brazilian political system. However, in terms of its wider goal of explaining the role of contemporary elite violence and social control in urban and rural Brazil the book comes up somewhat short, failing either to effectively analyse conflict in contemporary Brazil or explain its relationship to the past.
The book begins with an all too brief theoretical introduction in which Rose defines his terms and offers a very broad outline of the history of violence and social control since the colonial period. Of particular interest in this tightly written section is his definition of the elite as a group that controls wealth and power and the relationship between that group and what the author terms ‘sub-elites,’ those members of lower classes who serve within state and private formal and informal security services and repress other members of the middle class and the poor. This concept has some potential to hold together the author's argument. Unfortunately it is only briefly developed here, and there is little discussion of it later in the book.
Rose picks up steam over the next two chapters as he offers a fascinating discussion of politics in Brazil in the 1950s. He begins this section with a discussion of the suicide of Getúlio Vargas and the instability that followed as different groups competed to secure control of the federal government and the military increasingly asserted its power on the national political stage. The longer part of this section deals with politics during the Goulart presidency from 1961 to 1964. Here Rose writes engagingly about the numerous efforts to assassinate Goulart and destabilise his government, offering insights into the relationship between US government operatives and the Brazilian right during this period and the fear of rural elites of the moderate land reform programmes that Goulart pursued. The tension and pace of this chapter is skilfully built, analysing the growing conflict between Lacerda and Goulart and Leonel Brizola's efforts to form Grupos de Onze (left wing paramilitary groups) in response to the right. The chapter ends with a moving scene of Goulart fleeing Brazil, with the author arguing that the 1964 coup was a turning point in which Brazil ceased to be the ‘country of the future.’
The next two chapters roll along discussing repression and reaction during the dictatorship. Rose details the Institutional Acts imposed by the military to set up and develop their regime in the 1960s, the various purges, abuses, reactions and counter-reactions that took place throughout the dictatorship, and the growing opening of the political system in the 1980s, as the country moved towards democracy. These chapters provide an accessible narrative of the experience of the dictatorship and begin the process of providing a bridge to the discussion of contemporary violence in the last two chapters of the book. The final part of the book focuses on rural and urban violence in Brazil and attempts to draw connections between historic and political violence in Brazil and the contemporary experience of violence in the country today. Chapter five discusses ongoing rural violence and abuse ranging from the use of death squads against the MST, to the ongoing practice of debt peonage and shows not just the existence of persistent rural violence but something of its structure (Rose does a good job of highlighting the role of the political elite in this process). Chapter six shifts focus to the tremendous problem of urban crime and abuse, discussing the emergence and persistence of death squad activities in urban Brazil with a special focus on Rio and São Paulo.
These last two chapters are key to the book's argument about the role of the Brazilian elite in propagating and tolerating violence in that the author attempts to draw a fairly straight line between the shift to the right in 1960s Brazil, abuses under the dictatorship, and violence today. Rose is right to signal this relationship. However, overall the project comes up short in not making clear the ways in which historic violence and discrimination in Brazil contribute to violence today. The problem is not that this link does not exist, but that the author attempts to draw too direct a line between who is in power and the abuses that occur in Brazil. Chapter six, with its focus on death squads, is symptomatic of this. Death squads are one of many sources of violence in urban Brazil, but to focus almost exclusively on them in describing this problem in Brazilian cities in the 1990s ignores the role of drug gangs and petty crime in promoting both violence and fear in cities and a tolerance among many segments of the population for increasingly repressive policing policies that only tend to produce more violence. The link between elite social control and violence in Brazil today needs to be further developed. Much of the problem facing Brazil has to do not so much with elite violence (though the author and others have shown this is an important issue), but rather the violence of the poor against other members of the poor. Rio and São Paulo have been awash in criminal violence for over twenty years, due to the weapons and drugs trades. While police corruption clearly contributes to this, much of the problem facing Brazilian cities stems not from elite social control or even the sub-elites that are employed to maintain order. Violence, in many ways, comes from the poor who are either not effectively policed by a corrupt law enforcement structure or whose violence, for one reason or another, is tolerated by elites. There is a strong case to be made that the tolerance for drug trafficking and gangs in major Brazilian urban areas is a form of social control of the poor by a state uninterested in their well being, yet the broader question of criminal violence, which serves as the justification for state violence, is side-stepped by Rose. In other words, the problem in urban Brazil is not (just) that the police are out of control as a result of a tolerance for violence during the dictatorship, but that there are conditions that lead to violence in Brazil today that cause citizens to call for and tolerate more state violence. Certainly the dictatorship, the history of slavery, and the policies of the elite all play a role, but they are just some among many contributing factors to a wider cycle of violence that has social, historic, economic, global, and contemporary political sources.
Rose fails to analyse these dynamics in part because of his wider lack of engagement with the vigorous debate on violence in Brazil today. While he appears to be deeply engaged with historical sources he is much less concerned with the political scientists, anthropologists and sociologists writing on policing, violence and conflict in Brazil today. For example, he cites Zuenir Ventura's book 1968 on events in Brazil during the dictatorship yet never mentions Ventura's 1993 Cidade Partida which focused on violence in Rio in the 1990s. While he mentions Nancy Cardia and Paul Chevigny's work he does not cite Paulo Sérgio Pinheiro, Alba Zaluar, Donna Goldstein, Jorge Zaverucha, Leigh Payne, Claudio Beato or Anthony Pereira. All of these authors – and others still – have contributed in substantial ways to this debate and the book would be richer if they were included. The most egregious omission is Martha Huggins work on policing, including her 1998 book Political Policing and her articles on death squads, which deal with many of the same topics than Rose's book, often in a much more nuanced fashion. A close reading of Huggins would have saved Rose some work and would have enhanced his book. Despite these omissions, this remains an important work that will help advance the discussion of politics and violence in Latin America.
