With the ever-increasing proliferation of dictionaries and general resources in biblical and theological studies, it is difficult for any one work to stand out from the rest. Add to this the slick packaging and impressive array of scholars corralled by publishers to endorse the volume(s) and one may be forgiven for becoming more than a bit sceptical that a new release can make much of an actual contribution while avoiding the typical pitfalls of unevenness and oversimplification. With this situation in view, the present volume is, to greatly understate the matter, a very pleasant surprise.
It has been well documented – and readers of this journal are well aware – that the last two centuries of biblical interpretation have been dominated by historical-critical concerns, and the mutual regard between theologians and biblical scholars has amounted to a sort of bemused indifference. Not only is the gulf between biblical studies and theology in the academy a wide one, but too often the concerns of the academy in general do not seem at all relevant to the churches. Thankfully, as Kevin Vanhoozer notes in his introductory essay on theological interpretation, various impulses are coming together to apply pressure for readings of scripture that nourish and sustain the life of Christian communities. He states that this volume ‘provides a Christian theological evaluation of the contemporary issues and approaches pertaining to biblical interpretation with a view to assessing how they enable the church better to hear what God is saying to church and world today’ (p. 22).
The essays that follow cover well-chosen and strategic topics and are written by an impressive roster of scholars. Instead of enlisting post-graduates – an acceptable practice to which few would have objected – to fill in the content of the volume, we have Christopher Seitz writing on a canonical approach to scripture, John Webster on Karl Barth, and Joel Green on narrative theology. Marva Dawn writes an excellent essay on the nature of the principalities and powers, expertly summing up the contributions from both biblical studies and theology, most notably that of J. H. Yoder.
There are a few entries with titles so broad – ‘History’, ‘Philosophy’, ‘Postmodernism and Biblical Interpretation’ – that one imagines that they can hardly say anything helpful, an expectation that is proved wrong time and again. Each of these is incisive and informative, however concise. Daniel Treier's essay, ‘Doctrine of Jesus Christ’, one of the longer pieces that anchors the volume, is simply masterful.
To continue to make special mention of specific entries would either be endless, or an injustice to those excluded – just to note that after extensive perusal through the volume, it is difficult to run across an essay that disappoints. Nearly every entry is presented by a highly regarded scholar working on the cutting edge of her/his field, which places the essays above the standard introductory level and makes them reports on the current state of play as well as authoritative accounts of the history of the discussion.
The essays are also quite varied, covering topics that range from philosophy through to theology and on to technical issues in biblical studies. Each canonical biblical book is covered, with particular attention to the theological contribution each book makes to Christian theological reflection and dogmatic formulation.
As many have come to expect from Baker Academic, this volume is very well edited and attractively presented. The only potential glitch detected is the absence of an attribution to the essay on the ‘Pauline Epistles’, which is somewhat uneven and appears to have been heavily edited. While it covers some strategic points in the history of Pauline interpretation and Pauline theology, some may object to the ham-fisted manner in which the discussion of competing perspectives on Paul is presented. Of course, this may be to quibble unnecessarily, and, in light of the overall excellence of the volume, this is certainly forgivable.
The DTIB does indeed live up to its billing as a vital new resource for biblical and theological studies, greatly repaying careful reading at point after point. It will prove to be immensely useful for scholars working in the field of theological interpretation as well as for students needing an introduction to a more robust and life-giving way of reading scripture after the period in which historical-critical approaches held hegemonic status. It is no overstatement to say that students and scholars for years to come will be grateful to Vanhoozer and his colleagues that, at least in this instance, the attractive packaging and glowing endorsements are matched by remarkable substance.
