Edward Said, the famed critic of Orientalism, found that “exile is strangely compelling to think about but terrible to experience”. (p. 71) For those who experienced it at the hands of European colonial regimes in Asia between the 17th and 20th centuries, and particularly native elites, Said's observation was certainly accurate. Separation from kith-and-kin, familiar cultural and geographical surroundings, and even beloved local foods, drove many exiles to deep anguish. However for others, particularly non-elite convicts, exile provided new economic opportunities, escape from stifling social hierarchies, and unique avenues for advancement within the colonial world. It is this competing duality, between aristocratic and commoner exile, and its remembrance which Exile in Colonial Asia explores.
The volume grew out of an interdisciplinary workshop at Australian National University (Canberra) in July 2013 and addresses three central themes which are conveniently listed in the subtitle: “Kings, Convicts, and Commemoration”. In regards to kings, the volume examines the exile of elite ‘political prisoners’, including their retinues and regalia. Convicts, or generally non-elite exiles, are explored in terms of their “utilitarian aspect . . . for the sake of empire building”. (p. 5) Lastly, the theme of commemoration is analyzed in the remembrance of the exiled by those left behind and their descendents, as well as broader post-colonial national memory. These themes are pursued largely within the parameters of the Indian Ocean World, and particularly within the imperium of the British and Dutch charter companies of the region.
Various reasons arose for the exile of indigenous elites by the British East India Company (EIC) and the Dutch Vereenigde Oost-Indische Compagnie (VOC). Leading an open rebellion, conspiring against a European-allied leader, or inflaming ethno-religious tensions, could all result in indefinite exile for native power brokers. Such varied causations are also reflected in the diverse experiences which leaders faced during their exile. In the case of the famous Sikh “bhai and guru” Nihal Singh, revolutionary against the British in Punjab, Anand A. Yang shows that exile undermined a resistance movement far more effectively than execution. (p. 73) Singh was robbed of the opportunity for martyrdom and banished to Singapore, suffering deep mental anguish from which he never recovered. Sri Margana further demonstrates through an analysis of early nineteenth century “Babads”, Javanese chronicles, the transcolonial exile of Sultan Hamengkubuwana II by both British and Dutch authorities. The Sultan's rebellion against the British during their occupation of Java (1811-1814) was enough to ensure that the Dutch would take no chances on allowing his return even after his release from British imprisonment.
Rebelling against European-allied native rulers could just as easily end in exile. Ronit Ricci examines the case of the Sri Lankan Malays, Islamic Javanese elites led by King Amangkurat III who were “Ceyloned” by the Dutch during the eighteenth century. (p. 110) Only decades later were the king's family and retainers allowed to return to Java. However, despite his rebellion and exile, Amangkurat was still given a royal burial and his family restored to the aristocracy by the Dutch-backed native regime.
Robert Aldrich further demonstrates that colonial powers were ready to exile indigenous elites to mitigate civil unrest in neighbouring indigenous kingdoms. In the case of Sri Vikrama Rajasinha, the last King of Kandy, the British joined the native Buddhist aristocracy in opposing the king's Hinduification policies. The king was captured and exiled to Madras in 1816 before Buddhist agitation exploded into civil war, while the British subsequently established themselves within the pre-existing political hierarchy as Kandy's new rulers and royal patrons of Buddhism.
But not all exiles ended in controlled confinement. Penny Edwards’ contribution on the life of Prince Myngoon of Burma illustrates the ability of shrewd aristocrats to move about a network of “stateless elites”, defying colonial control. (p. 249) Able to play the competing rivalries of Britain and France, Myngoon continued to intrigue throughout Southeast Asia for sixty years and remained a perennial thorn-in-the-side of British authorities in Burma.
Although isolated from their homeland, most elites received sizable pensions from their colonial wardens and lived out their days in relative luxury. The same cannot be said of the exiled commoner. As Clare Anderson shows, the exile of convicts was “more than a penal sanction”, it was part of a larger agenda of “forced migration and labour extraction for the purpose of colonization”. (pp. 20–21)
But these transfers, if one survived the arduous labour of their sentence, also provided unique opportunities for social advancement as Jean Gelman Taylor demonstrates. Many non-Muslim Indonesians were imported to Dutch Cape Colony as domestic slaves. Manumission or marriage to Dutch settlers allowed many former slaves to acquire property and legal protections within the Dutch system. Lorraine M. Paterson's contribution further highlights the opportunities for Indochinese convicts exiled by the French. Despite the immense pain caused by the physical separation from ancestral grave sites, many Indochinese became successful French colonials in places like New Caledonia and Gabon following their indentured service. And perhaps nowhere did penal labourers experience more opportunity than British convicts in Australia. Carol Liston's contribution on convict experiences in New South Wales shows that “greater material prosperity” accompanied the high emotional price of exile. (p. 194) Working either on government projects or private property, most convicts were able to better their social position after serving their sentence.
Colonial authorities even utilised population transfers to maintain their commercial monopolies. Timo Kaartinen demonstrates that the VOC in Maluku mobilised allied native groups to force indigenous economic competitors to abandon their prime agricultural land. However, groups like the Bandanese were able to reconstitute their societies outside of VOC-controlled regions and, in doing so, maintain unique cultural identities based on this shared memory of resistance.
Although these excellent contributions are transnational, the work remains a primarily Anglo-Dutch affair. Only Paterson's essay on exile from French Indochina, expands outside of this bi-national focus. The work further narrows its purview primarily to the mid-seventeenth to nineteenth centuries and does not extend far outside the Indian Ocean World. These parameters limit the applicability of the work to “colonial Asia” writ large. There are no contributions on the Spanish Philippines, the Russian Far East, the various Portuguese colonies, or Concession China. No doubt, any work seeking to address exile across the entirety of colonial Asia would need to take these, as well as contemporary indigenous traditions, into account.
Despite its somewhat narrow focus, Exile in Colonial Asia succeeds admirably in bringing attention to the “global dimensions of colonial exile”. (2) The volume further excels in synthesising the experience and memory of exile through the eyes of both colonial authorities and the exiles themselves. The deep sense of separation felt by exiles was complimented by new opportunities for social advancement, while exiled leaders who failed in their resistance against colonial regimes are now commemorated as national heroes in their post-colonial homelands.
Furthermore, the work demonstrates the value in assessing European colonialism through the lens of exile, both prince and pauper. The ever-present “labour question”, which confounded colonial regimes in their efforts to economically develop their territories, highlights the role played by imported convict labour and non-collaborating elite exile in developing colonial economies. Whether by infrastructure improvement, settlement, or the creation of plantation-based societies, exile was integral in the formation of the colonial world and the shaping of post-colonial socioeconomic relationships. For those seeking novel historiographical approaches to transnational history, Exile in Colonial Asia offers excellent insights on the role of forced migration in imperial endeavour.
