Stemming from the Performing Precarity: Refugee Representation, Determination and Discourses conference (University of Otago, 2016), this edited collection goes beyond the immediacy of conference proceedings and offers a thoughtful exploration of performances of and in Australia's refugee politics and infamous border regime. It specifically looks at aesthetic and performative forms of resistance, and modalities of refugee representation and agency.
The book is concisely edited into what feels like two compact and interconnected parts (entitled ‘On Stage’ and ‘Off Stage’), each with five chapters. This structure allows the editors to present contributions in two (plus one) analytical frames: the first part focusing on performance responses to refugee politics and border control, the second using performance as a lens to investigate Australia's treatment of refugees – the culture, canons, laws and politics underpinning it. The third, underlining, analytical frame is Australia itself.
One of the main contributions of this volume is precisely that it brings to the fore the very context of its investigation. The editors reflect on Australia as a ‘settler-colonial state’, a ‘majority migrant country’ with ‘neo-colonial ambitions’ (p. 4), defining features that run across the individual chapters while mapping the performative responses to the country's refugee policies. For instance, Caroline Wake's engaging chapter ‘Offshore Onstage: Refugee Policies, Media Ecologies and Migrant Dramaturgies in Australia, 2001–2021’ in the first part of the book provides a comprehensive survey of theatre works in response to a set of asylum policies, Pacific Solution (2001) and Operation Sovereign Borders (2013), focusing on interception, removal and offshore processing of refugees. Wake shows the twinning of artistic and activist communities in opposing refugee detention. She then provides an assessment of the major shifts since 2013 regarding the dehumanizing treatment of asylum seekers, and the government's weaponization of artists in anti-refugee propaganda, especially considering the explicit ban on publishing humanizing images of refugees.
Wake's analysis of the theatre's role to ‘speak the public secret’ (p. 95) is then organically expanded on in Suvendrini Perera's chapter (‘Trouble on the Horizon’) opening Part Two of the volume. Via a critical examination of Tracey Moffatt's My Horizon, Australia's official entry at the Venice Biennale in 2017, Perera looks at artistic interventions as sites that ‘unsettle the destructive relation between the spectacle and the secret of refugee policy in Australia’ (p. 101, original emphasis). By doing so, artists are challenging categories of citizenship and nation, ultimately countering state narratives.
Crossings and intersections between disciplines, creative practices and approaches, as above, are important assets of the book as they build on perspectives from theatre, performance and migration studies, art history, media studies and cultural and literary studies, among others. As such, the volume can be positioned alongside recent edited collections including Refugee Genres: Essays on the Culture of Flight and Refuge (ed. M.C. Frangos and S. Ghose, 2022), and Refugee Imaginaries: Research across the Humanities (ed. Emma Cox, Sam Durrant, David Farrier, Lyndsey Stonebridge and Agnes Woolley, 2020), contributing to the expansion of refugee studies led by growing scholarship from within the arts and humanities.
Besides its interdisciplinary reach utilizing performance as subject and viewpoint of investigation, the book's originality also lies in demonstrating the plurality of the Australian border as it ‘continues to multiply across sites and colonize various states’ (p. 8). In this respect, the editors’ choice of terminology – using refugee instead of migrant – is fitting and significant. It reflects the experience of asylum seekers, and resists the invisibility and voicelessness of refugees in Australia.
Given the ‘ethical proximity and the physical distance of asylum seekers’ (p. 35), as Anna Szörényi puts it in her chapter, the book can also be read as a form of activism tuned towards challenging public narratives amidst ongoing censorship of media reporting and whistle-blowing.
With this stance, the volume puts forward a critical re-examination of the histories, philosophies and politics that contribute to the control and exclusion of refugees. While this comes through convincingly in the Introduction and in individual chapters, a conclusion by the editors might have been beneficial to fold individual critical strands back into an overall reflection on refugee positions in Australian society. This would have also helped position the book more firmly for a non-Australian readership.
Performance, Resistance and Refugees is an engaging and topical collection primarily situated within theatre and performance studies, but it would certainly appeal to scholars of migration and border studies as well as academics with a background in cultural studies. Indeed, a key merit of this collection is facilitating new and much-needed connections between the arts and humanities and the social sciences.
