European societies are known to face two challenges: labour markets have become more flexible in competitive economies and pension systems are being reformed due to aging societies. However, public debates often focus on each issue separately, although both worry the public. Similarly, research is often concerned with either the immediate consequences of flexibilisation or the politics of pension reforms. Although the ‘flexicurity’ model has been mainly hailed for combining employment flexibility and social security for the current working population, rarely do proponents consider its long-term consequences for later retirement. Yet this uncertainty about the future should be a concern for any one working today and it certainly warrants further research.
Bridging these gaps, this edited volume asks whether labour market flexibility today will imply (in)security tomorrow. Given ongoing employment flexibilisation and recent pension marketisation, what are the effects on income security in old age? Under the editorship of Karl Hinrichs and Matteo Jessoula, this book brings together experts who participated in the EU-funded project RECWOWE. This collaborative study, published in Palgrave's Series ‘Work and Welfare in Europe’, maps the degree to which seven European pension systems adapted to flexible employment. It covers two clusters of countries: single-pillar pension systems (Germany, Italy and Poland), known for their Bismarckian social insurance, and multi-pillar systems which combine Beveridge-type basic security and early development of private funded pensions (Britain, Denmark, the Netherlands and Switzerland). Besides a discussion of employment trends, the reader finds up-to-date accounts of the national pension system and its recent reforms, focusing on those aspects that impact on pensioners with non-standard employment. As for many edited volumes, the country chapters differ, thereby making a comparison more difficult: some provide detailed tables and graphs on employment and pension indicators, while others remain more descriptive in their narrative.
As micro-simulations were beyond the scope of this project, the assessment of the potential impact for future pensioners with non-standard employment remains necessarily speculative. The conclusion provides an overview of cross-national differences, though it does not provide any systematic comparison of particular features (like child credits, minimum income or private pension coverage). Instead, the editors sum up the results in a linear ranking of the seven countries. They present the differences in employment flexibilisation by grouping Italy, Poland and Germany as ‘segmented’ labour markets, while the other four tend towards ‘homogenous labour markets’, that is, employment conditions do not differ as much. While the segmented cluster follows the common view, one might quibble about whether Britain and Denmark have more homogenous labour markets compared to the Netherlands and Switzerland, which they place in between due to their higher levels of part-time and fixed term contracts.
The ultimate ranking, however, is based on classifying the adaptability of pension systems to these flexible employment conditions. The editors juxtapose the Dutch and Danish pension systems as ‘integrated’ systems and the three Bismarckian systems as ‘dis-integrating’, while the British and Swiss cases are placed in the middle as ‘integrating’ systems. While this presentation along a continuum is suggestive, unfortunately it mimics cross-national rankings. A multi-dimensional approach would be more appropriate to the intricate interactions between labour market and pension features reported in the county case studies.
Given the flexicurity debate, it may not be surprising that the best performers are the Danish and Dutch cases. These countries have not only adapted their basic pensions to integrate all residents, but also have wide coverage of occupational pensions, thanks to broad collective agreements. Moreover, non-standard employment in the flexicurity models are more protected than in any of the other countries. However, Karen Anderson is more restrained in her evaluation of the Dutch integrated multi-pillar model. Although it has a stellar record in avoiding old age poverty (except for first generation migrants), the Dutch face some challenges. While the flexicurity model is largely based on the largest and gendered part-time economy of the world, the generous basic pensions may not be sustainable forever, and the funded occupational pensions have come under pressure from the financial market crisis.
To pick another example, Britain is instructive as an intermediate case of a flexible, largely deregulated labour market with little flexicurity and a fragmented multi-pillar pension system that does not live up to Beveridge's ideal. The chapter by David Natali maps the pension reforms under New Labour, which aimed at making the basic and state second pension reduce poverty risks, while planning to increase private pension coverage through auto-enrolment. Reported simulations show that those, both men and women, with standard and non-standard contracts will have converging retirement incomes in the future. However, this will depend on political decisions yet to come, setting the basic pension at levels that effectively will reduce poverty in old age.
For Hinrichs, Germany's flexible labour market and pension reform ‘means’ poverty, a fate it shares with the two other Bismarckian systems. Segmented flexibility and austere pension reforms entail a shift away from maintaining status in old age. The sequence of pension reforms lowered earnings-related state pensions and left an income gap to be filled by voluntary supplementary pensions. The extension of child credits, the subsidies for voluntary Riester pensions and the introduction of a means-tested minimum-income have been rather insufficient steps to avoid long-term poverty for those with less than standard employment careers. For lack of a more integrated success story, one wonders whether these Bismarckian systems, despite having moved toward multi-pillar features more recently, have any real possibility to adapt to flexible labour markets. The conclusion does not reveal whether the editors see in a minimum income system the only possible response, and whether this choice has not been passed for Bismarckian countries in contrast to the early multi-pillar systems. When concluding the Germany chapter, Hinrichs more explicitly rules out an adaptation as unlikely, while Jessolua in his Italy chapter hopes for a post-Bismarckian compromise.
