The European crisis of the late thirteenth and early fourteenth centuries continues to fascinate scholars. Once conceived as either a Malthusian “crisis of subsistence” or a Marxist “crisis of feudalism,” it is now regarded as a complex and multilayered event influenced by commercial forces and rapid environmental change. In particular, the interaction between extreme climatic events, and catastrophic harvest failures and disease of cattle, has attracted most recent attention. This book offers a refreshing new perspective upon the crisis, not least by exploring its impact upon the solvency of certain English landlords and their innovative attempts to solve their own crises of credit through novel financial agreements with the leading merchants of Europe. The authors explore the use of “advance contracts” in the English wool market, which were financial instruments combining an element of loan and forward contract. A major flock master of sheep, such as a monastery, contracted to supply wool of a certain quantity and quantity to a specified buyer, such as a body of Flemish or Italian merchants, for a specified price for, say, twenty years. In return for this consideration, the seller received welcome financial advances. This mechanism was more akin to an option arrangement based on forward contracts, rather than an early form of “futures” market, but nevertheless it represents a sophisticated development in financial instruments at an early date. Such contracts survive mainly from the period 1216 to 1326, and their number—and the litigation over defaults upon them—increase markedly at the height of the crisis, between c.1270 and 1325. They then disappear as dramatically as they had appeared: they were therefore a specific feature of, and response to, the wider economic crisis.
Towards the end of the thirteenth century, English monastic institutions in general, and the Cistercians in particular, were increasingly dependent upon advance contracts, and they increasingly defaulted upon them. The use of this financial instrument was therefore part symptom and part cause of a growing crisis of indebtedness among English monasteries, as their attempts to restructure their debt in order to survive the short-term created even greater difficulties in the longer-term. Their motives for entering into such binding agreements to sell their most saleable commodity were worthy enough. The monks sought secure financial commitments, and committed buyers for their wool, in a risky business. The merchants sought to secure their supplies of English wool for the looms of the luxury textiles industry in the Low Countries and Italy, and they could afford to bear and diversify the financial risks of advance contracts. The devastating experience of sheep disease in 1270, and the consequent disruption to the wool trade, probably convinced both sellers and buyers of the need to protect their own interests in this manner. Yet Pipewell Abbey exemplified the pitfalls of the arrangement, because its recurrent default upon the terms of its contract with the Lombards resulted in its spiraling indebtedness and the sacking of its abbot as CEO in 1323.
The book is sensibly structured, dealing first with the sources and the type of information they reveal; then undertaking a case study of Pipewell abbey, which used these contracts extensively to sell its wool; and, finally, an analysis of the structure of the agreements, including pricing, terms of repayments, and implied interest rates. The latter section includes the use of valuation techniques derived from modern finance theory to evaluate the instruments, which is one of the most novel aspects of the research. The authors conclude that interest rates were charged at between 10 percent and 40 percent per annum, and that the financial structures were efficient, well-functioning and orderly. They bring modern financial expertise to bear upon medieval sources, and their analysis is interesting, novel, persuasive and commendably clear.
The advance contracts reveal a good deal of interesting information about the English wool trade, at the time when it dominated the economy and its exports. The importance of Lincolnshire as a major area of production emerges strongly, together with the role of fairs in clinching and renegotiating deals, and the personal involvement of monastic heads of houses in leading those negotiations. They also reveal the spirit of partnership between monastery and financiers, with the latter seeking supportive strategies to ease the plight of the former after successive defaults, including supplying more sheep for their flocks. These contracts represent an imaginative response to help solve the solvency issues of major landlords at the peak of the agrarian crisis. After the 1320s they disappear, as the crisis passed, the quality of English wool declined, and exports fell.
The book focuses strongly upon the wool market and its dynamics, and it is conspicuously successful and innovative in elucidating its subject. It reveals that the instruments for expanding credit in one sector of the English wool market were novel and impressive, although they ultimately created as many problems as they solved. The authors suggest that the changing internal dynamics of the wool trade explain the development of these financial structures. Yet it is also possible that the escalating indebtedness of English institutions was a significant precondition, a point which the authors acknowledge in passing. This remains an underexplored characteristic of the agrarian crisis, but its potential significance is enhanced by this study. After c.1270 many landlords were caught in a financial squeeze of runaway costs and sticky incomes: their expenditure on active building programs and sizeable households during a period of rapid price inflation and crippling taxation was not covered by increases in seigniorial income, which was especially dependent upon rents that were largely fixed rather than commercially renegotiable. The canny merchants might well have been offering a financial fix to those institutions that were already in real financial difficulties, but which had a valuable and saleable asset—wool—upon which to base a restructuring package. The extent of the credit crisis among European landlords in c.1300 has yet to be revealed.
