Harriet Fertik's book began as a doctoral dissertation and broadly concerns matters of authority, security and privacy, both in relation to Rome's first imperial dynasty and to those subjects who stood closest in proximity to the throne. For F., ‘Roman houses, both literary representations and material environments, reveal the central role of intimacy and interdependence in Roman conceptions of power’ (17). Accordingly, F.'s volume examines the reciprocal nature — the double-edged quality — of the symbolism, conflicts and paradoxes that emanated from and surrounded the imperial domus or ‘ruler's house’, and is perhaps best described as a collection of interrelated case studies.
Ch. 1 focuses on Lucan's treatment of family in his Neronian-era Bellum civile. Whereas past scholarship has traditionally characterised the epic by its themes of destruction, F. argues for a generative reading via Lucan's treatment of the intimate relationships that the commanders Caesar, Pompey and Cato forge between themselves and their troops. In representing the rise of one-man rule, Lucan allegorises the past for the present by envisioning the prior creation of ‘a seductive new political order, in which ruler and ruled learn to play the role of family members for one another’ (21), but at the expense of the familial intimacy and devotion typically shared between members of an ideal Roman household. Under the ruler, F. writes, ‘all bonds between the ruled are equivalent’ (37). Ch. 2 focuses on representations of the imperial domus as a household. It argues that ‘[i]mages of the emperor's family on municipal monuments show that the membership and hierarchy of the emperor's family was subject to negotiation between multiple players’ (18). The chapter closes with one of the book's sharpest readings, an analysis of Tacitus’ Annals in which ‘the women of the imperial family become indicators of the fragility and contingency of one-man rule’ (18).
Ch. 3 considers the literary and archaeological evidence for the house complexes built by Augustus and Nero at Rome and the narrative descriptions of Tiberius in his secluded dwelling on the island of Capri. For F., these physical houses ‘were sites for experimenting with imperial visibility’ (61). In Tiberius’ particular case, the narratives of Tacitus and Suetonius reveal ‘the impossibility of imperial retreat, as the stories that spread about his doings continue to expose him to public view’ (75). Ch. 4 segues easily into analysis of anxieties surrounding the visibility of monarchs in three works by Seneca. The De clementia, F. argues, frames the ruler's inability to retreat from public life as a double threat, both to himself and to the cohesion of the polity. The work also meditates upon the active complicity of the ruled in their own subjection. Shifts between power and powerlessness in spectatorship and self-exposure are further explored in readings of Agamemnon and Thyestes, where the interdependence of the ruler and ruled functions to destabilise the hierarchy of their relationship.
The volume's last two chapters are related in their focus upon the daily lives of wealthy householders, and again draw our attention to the inherent fragility of rule. Ch. 5 turns to domestic frescoes in the houses of Pompeii and representations of domestic space in Roman literature. Ch. 6 focuses on banqueting and bodily functions in Petronius’ Satyricon and Seneca's De ira, and how performances of dominance in the acts of eating, drinking and elimination give way to revelations of human equality between dominants and subordinates.
It is worth noting that it often takes some effort to determine whether F. is using her analytical categories literally or figuratively throughout the discussion. For instance, ‘house’ — the central topic and organising principle of the book — is often referred to as a ‘space’ or ‘site’, which produces readerly disorientation when F. uses the same language when writing about the house as ‘household’, the family that lives within and beyond a structure's physical site and spaces. ‘House’ is even used once in a way that seems to mean ‘dynasty’ (22).
That said, F.'s study is both multi-faceted and economical in its clever and effective use of the available primary evidence. For example, the book uses mostly Neronian texts (Lucan, Petronius, much Seneca) and Flavian archaeological remains (Pompeii) as representative examples for the ‘Julio-Claudian’ era as a whole. F. specifically justifies this strategy — first by adopting a reading of Nero as ‘both the culmination and the nadir of the first domus Caesarum’ (180 n. 54; see K. Milnor, Gender, Domesticity, and the Age of Augustus (2005), 286), and second by her informed references to several recent scholarly arguments for the early emergence of an ‘elite koine’ of shared visual and architectural forms and literary texts during the two centuries prior to the period of Rome's first imperial dynasty.
The broader concerns framing F.'s study are informed by an array of contemporary thinkers anchored in different disciplines. Much of the work takes its cues from past social and cultural histories of Augustan and early imperial Rome that aim to recover ‘history from below’, but also from studies of post-modern theory and ancient sexuality and gender, modern security and privacy studies (including social histories of privacy), affect studies, and — last but not least — several important studies on the sociology and philosophy of political power (Arendt, Habermas, Bourdieu, Giddens). With The Ruler's House, F. has produced a thoughtful and stimulating volume that stands as a solid contribution to studies of Roman political culture.
