It is a pleasure and an honor to comment on the work of David Armitage, a historian of unparalleled reach and impact. His topic could not be more important. “Civil war has gradually become the most widespread, the most destructive, and the most characteristic form of organized human violence,” he writes in his elegant and masterful recent book Civil Wars: A History in Ideas.Footnote 1 Examining the history of the idea of “civil war” is not simply an academic enterprise. Understanding its history, he explains, “reveals the contingency of the phenomenon, contradicting those who claim its permanence and durability.”Footnote 2 Armitage's purpose is “to show that what humans have invented, they may yet dismantle … what intellectual will has enshrined, an equal effort of imaginative determination can dethrone.”Footnote 3
Armitage's illuminating Grotius Lecture generates a set of questions about the relationship between armed conflict and what we conceptualize as “civil” in war. He also critically reflects on how to think about civil war in time.Footnote 4 A conventional starting point for temporal analysis of war is the idea that war breaks time into the categories of “wartime” and “peacetime.” The initiation of war thereby launches a society into a time period during which a normal rule of law is suspended.Footnote 5 In practice, however, starting and ending points are fluid, and forms of time overlap. From this temporal perspective, the importance of civil war's time relates to when international humanitarian law might apply. Civil war has another temporality: its periodization. Armitage traces the way international law initially excluded civil wars, but then incorporated them through the concept of noninternational armed conflict.Footnote 6
In this comment, I will expand on the idea of the “civil” in civil war, focusing on the American Civil War experience and its implications for later American wars. I will also consider the idea of peace—usually imagined as existing outside of war—to understand what peace might be in a world torn by violence.
The very idea of “civil war” breaks war into categories. Civil war is interesting as a matter of intellectual history, as Armitage shows, because it was an aberration from what were thought of as “normal” or classic wars: interstate wars.Footnote 7 Recognizing civil wars enables Armitage to examine violence in the world during the post-1945 years—an era that some have called “the long peace.”Footnote 8 George Orwell anticipated that this era, shaped by the introduction of nuclear arms, might be framed as peace.Footnote 9 He argued that it would be “a peace that is no peace,” a peace in name only.Footnote 10 It is curious that persistent, post-1945 violence might end up in categories that are other than “real war.” In that way peace may exist not through the absence of violence but from the emptiness of one category: war's ideal type, or big, interstate war.
All violence in the world is not contained within these categories, of course. The emergence of these categories in law enables certain kinds of conflicts to be recognized, legitimized, and subject to rules, making them appear to be contained within a rule of law, rather than outside of law. If civil war was a new operative category of legitimized war, what does the category leave out, and what are the consequences? To think about this, I would like to take you back to the 1860s when U.S. armed forces fought “the” Civil War and also fought wars against Native Americans.
In the history of American wars, the Civil War is treated as legitimate war not just because civil wars can be categorized as “real war.” In American legal scholarship it instead became, in essence, the classic American war—the war against which to compare all others. In scholarship examining American war powers, the Civil War is not treated as different from interstate wars but instead as one of the most important examples of how American war powers work in any context called war.Footnote 11 It has received more attention in the legal literature than has the Cold War, in spite of the fact that the Cold War was the occasion for development of the modern national security state—a governmental framework that continues to structure the U.S. government's war and security work.Footnote 12 Structural differences between a war within a polity and an international war are sometimes lost in the process.
The history of the American Civil War illuminates the nature of the “civil” in civil war. “To call a war ‘civil’ is to acknowledge the familiarity of the enemies as members of the same community,” Armitage writes.Footnote 13 They are “not foreigners but fellow citizens.”Footnote 14 The principal character of the American Civil War's civil-ness was its constitutive character. It was not just that at the end of the war the United States was preserved as a single country through defeat of the Confederacy, and it was not just the abolition of slavery—though both results were of great importance.Footnote 15 The violence itself constituted the polity in a new way. That idea is at the heart of an especially important work on the American Civil War: Drew Gilpin Faust's “This Republic of Suffering:” Death and the American Civil War. Footnote 16 Enduring divisions survived the war, of course, but Faust argues that the war's carnage generated a shared cultural experience and produced a broader public.Footnote 17 The war's carnage was so great—over six hundred thousand military deaths—that the state and society had to respond to it.Footnote 18 Names had to be attached to the bodies and then recorded and remembered. Families searched battlefields for remains, disinterring the bones of others along the way.Footnote 19
The idea of a republic constituted through war death is perhaps best illustrated by the quote in Faust's title. It is from Frederick Law Olmstead, who is most well known for his path-breaking landscape architecture.Footnote 20 Olmstead was still in search of a satisfying career path when the Civil War broke out, and he was working on a hospital transport ship. He noticed a sense of community among injured and dying soldiers. They called out to each other and supported each other, telling the staff to go and help another soldier who needed them more urgently. The Civil War's civil-ness—its constitutive character—was on display on the hospital ship, though all around were broken bones, open wounds, the dead and the dying.Footnote 21 Suffering produced a community, and in the nation as a whole Civil War death was central to constituting a polity.Footnote 22
The dead do cultural work for the living, historian Thomas Laqueur argues.Footnote 23 Politics exist within cultural contexts, so if the dead do cultural work, they must also do political work. The political work of the dead and their role in constituting a polity were on display when Lincoln commemorated civil war dead at Gettysburg, urging that the living were to be dedicated to uphold the principles for which soldiers had given their lives.Footnote 24
During the Civil War, Lincoln commissioned Francis Lieber to draft a code of war to set the legal boundaries of armed conflict.Footnote 25 As John Fabian Witt shows, the Lieber Code was intended not just as a means to constrain war, but also as a tool to achieve Union aims.Footnote 26 Armitage emphasizes Lieber's ambivalence about how the American conflict was best defined and how well it fit the new Code's terms.Footnote 27 Ultimately its political objective was most important. Lieber wrote: “To save the country … is paramount to all other considerations.”Footnote 28 All forms of political community were not protected by the Code, however. It was intended as a code of civilized men, and its rule of law was in service of civilization.Footnote 29
Every political community has an outside. We can better understand the nature of the Civil War's civil-ness by examining the outside of the Civil War–era polity.Footnote 30 There was death and suffering at the hands of American military forces in the 1860s that fell outside of Faust's republic of suffering.Footnote 31 It helped to constitute that republic nevertheless by showing its outside, and a border of “civilization” between the deaths widely mourned and the others forgotten.Footnote 32
This is illustrated by a rather brutal story from armed conflict in Colorado in 1864. Norms were shifting regarding the protection or the elimination of peaceful communities of Native Americans.Footnote 33 Colorado Governor John Evans first told the Cheyenne and Arapahoe that if they were loyal and peaceful, and if they registered with his government, they would not be attacked but would be protected.Footnote 34 A Cheyenne village at Sand Creek took him up on his offer. Two months later, however, Governor Evans changed his mind.Footnote 35 How, after all, could one tell between loyal and disloyal Indians? As human beings, they were thought to be of a different character than the white Northerners and Southerners fighting the Civil War.Footnote 36 They were the kind of barbarians that, thanks to the Lieber Code, the Union Army could distinguish itself from through honorable combat.Footnote 37 The Code's limits did not apply to conflict with people thought of as savages. The Indian Wars were not treated like the Civil War as battles between peoples for sovereignty—although that is what, in part, they were. They were conceptualized by U.S. military leaders as battles on behalf of civilization against the savage threat.Footnote 38 Lieber himself wrote in 1863: “Protection was, and still is, with uncivilized peoples, the exception.”Footnote 39
Before American troops descended on the peaceful village at Sand Creek, Colonel John Chivington told his men to “‘kill and scalp all, little and big,’ for ‘nits make lice.’”Footnote 40 The result was an orgy of violence. Women were not spared but were raped and chopped into pieces. Babies were shot at point blank range. The Cheyenne at Sand Creek were brutally eliminated in the name of upholding civilization.Footnote 41
There was no Gettysburg address delivered at Sand Creek. This was not only because the casualties were Native Americans rather than U.S. military. This was not a sacrifice shared through mourning that transcended political boundaries.Footnote 42 The entire point was an exclusion from the polity, after all. The logic of murdering babies was to perpetuate the excision across generations.Footnote 43 Sand Creek is remembered and mourned by Native Americans.Footnote 44 Otherwise, it remains at the boundary of American memory.Footnote 45 Unlike the Civil War's generative political character, the Indian Wars more often constitute American political identity through their exclusion.
The point of telling this story is not to show that the code of war the Civil War produced did not end atrocity, for of course it could not do that. Instead, the story shows the borders of the civic community and civil society that the Civil War's fighters and commanders thought the war was about. Community was borne out of the war's carnage, as Faust argues, but the republic of suffering had an outside, a border between the deaths to be mourned and those to be forgotten.Footnote 46 This brings a ragged edge to the civil-ness of the American Civil War. It also sheds an important light on the character of the kind of “peace” we might find in its aftermath.
If—drawing from Faust and Laqueur—death in war has a politics, and if the polity has been shaped by the shared experience of suffering and death, what happens to the polity when war is far away and a warring people do not themselves suffer? Can Kant's peace, which Professor Armitage hopes for, exist in a world where the United States can go to war without most Americans experiencing any suffering?Footnote 47
If there has been a “long peace” since 1945, as some have argued, for whom has this “peace” existed? Not for those killed in battles between armed troops, those living in carpet-bombed territory, or those whose farms and villages were napalmed.Footnote 48 Nowadays, the precision of contemporary weapons does not produce more peace simply because the blast radius from a drone strike can be smaller. The sound of the drone has become part of the ambient environment in some parts of the world—a world now shaped by the watchful eye of surveillance and, in some regimes, an ever-present threat of annihilation.Footnote 49 When military ordinance encounters the human body, the categorization of resulting death as lawful “collateral damage” matters only to those left to categorize. The dead body can be argued about but cannot itself complain.
We might, along with Armitage, long for Kant's idea of a perpetual peace, but in the twenty-first century world, peace is not a time. There is no widely shared “peacetime,” especially for the United States, which is engaged in endless armed conflict.Footnote 50 Instead, peace is an identity for those peoples privileged to experience it.Footnote 51
For most Americans, peace exists as an absence of conceptualization. Leaving war fighting to others, and far from the battlefield, it rarely crosses their mindsFootnote 52—unless a particularly disturbing photograph of dead children appears in their social media. They might tweet in outrage and be satisfied to have had their say.Footnote 53 There is an absence of the collective suffering that Olmsted encountered on the hospital transport ship and that Faust argued helped shape the United States in war's aftermath.
The American Civil War would become “the test case for the legitimacy of secessionist civil war everywhere,” Professor Armitage writes.Footnote 54 It would not, however, be the defining model for other conflicts between the American whole and its parts, like the Filipinos who sought independence after the Spanish-American War, but instead fought American occupiers.Footnote 55 The Philippine-American War was a conflict not only excluded from the panoply of great wars but also from American memory itself, as wartime for Filipinos came to be remembered as an American “peacetime.”Footnote 56 This shows that peace, at its core, is not a time, but a failure of memory.
Perhaps the peace we seek should be experienced more expansively, as the suffering of the Civil War was. We know that violence and its aftereffects can draw people together. If only a political community could be constituted in relation to peacefulness rather than violence.
