Although the question of defining Hinduism has occupied the minds and writings of scholars of Hinduism for some time, Alexander Rocklin brings a fresh perspective in The Regulation of Religion and the Making of Hinduism in Colonial Trinidad. Here the question is less about defining Hinduism and more about how Hinduism comes to be made through the interactions between the colonized and the colonial state, between Muslims and Hindus, and between Afro- and Indo-Trinidadians. Rocklin's focus is an important one, as academics were formulating ideas about religion at the same as Indian indentured laborers were being transported to various British colonies. Using mostly archival sources, Rocklin argues that the notion of “religion” and laws regulating its practice developed as a way of controlling laborers even as the narrative centered on “religious freedom.” Modeling their practices after Christianity and in defense of their “religion,” Indo-Trinidadians constructed a “Hinduism” that both worked within and challenged colonial categories. While Rocklin's argument may initially seem to be another iteration of the literature centered on the “the invention of Hinduism,” by taking the discussion out of India to argue that the formation of “Hinduism” does not happen solely in the single origin point of India, he revitalizes the debate, sending it into a novel direction.
Following Rocklin's introduction (“Crossing the Dark Water,”) the book is organized into two parts: Religion and Hinduism. The first part contains three chapters: “Converting Religion (chapter 2),” “Regulating Religion (chapter 3),” and “Outlawing Religion (chapter 4).” Here Rocklin is concerned with exemplifying what he describes as a “constellation of (at times contradictory) colonial policies and institutions” of colonial secularism (10). As Rocklin explains, the term “Hindu” in Trinidad was initially an ethno-racial term used to describe the practices of Indians without necessarily distinguishing the practices of “Hindus” from those of Muslims. He begins with the petition concerning the Hosay festival, the history of which is the focus of his third chapter, “Regulating Religion.” To increase support for indentureship during a time of antislavery sentiments, the British framed religious freedom as a feature that distinguished indentureship from slavery. As a result, the colonial regime took an interest in defining what practices of the Indian laborers counted as “religious.” Religious freedom and tolerance was part of indentured contracts as a way to ensure the continued flow of laborers from India, but it also offered the laborers a loophole through which they could assert their own power. Rocklin's main argument is that the adoption of the category of religion allowed for the laborers to construct social groups and experiment with the boundaries of those groups under the confines of the colonial regime. The irony, of course, is that this adoption also allowed for the continued power of these categories. Rocklin writes: “In the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, as a consequence of coming under the discipline of colonial institutions such as plantations, schools, orphanages, courts, and jails, Indian Trinidadians incorporated and began to gain a mastery over the category religion and its attendant norms, at the same time that, through the discipline of colonial institutions, they were mastered by them” (4). What becomes clear throughout the book is that the dialogue between the colonizer and the colonized is never a simple exercise in hegemonic or counter-hegemonic practice. As Indo-Trinidadians learned and adopted the categories of “religion” and “Hinduism,” they both challenged and were constrained by those labels. Learning the rules of the game and playing it well affords the colonized—in this case, the Indian indentured laborers—some capacity for social agency, but it does not mean that they can fully invert the power of the labels and completely avoid their reuse.
Chapter 4, “Outlawing Religion,” might be Rocklin's most compelling. In it, he analyzes the ambiguous category of obeah and the laws created to control this elusive practice. Rocklin's discussion of obeah centers it as a “race-making term” that colonialists used to distinguish between the “primitive” and “civilized” (115).Footnote 1 Although the topic of law and the disciplining mechanism of the plantation is addressed throughout the book, in this chapter readers will most clearly see how laws such as those centered on vagabondage were intertwined with ideas about religion and worked together to control the Indian population. Rocklin expertly delves into a discussion of zombies (and their many iterations), jumbies, healing practices, and Indo-Trinidadians’ ideas on death and the afterlife to outline the arguments Indians made to differentiate their practices from obeah which was constructed as “not-religion.” Rocklin is careful to observe, however, that obeah “was not just not-religion, but often stood in for disqualified (and ‘mixed’) subaltern knowledges of various kinds” (134). To support this observation, he notes that subaltern groups experimenting with various types of healing practices that challenged the category of science were arrested and charged with practicing obeah while white and creole upper- and middle-class people performing similar practices were understood to be engaging in medico-science or entertainment. While there is some overlap here with Brent Crosson's recently published work Experiments with Power,Footnote 2 Rocklin is careful to center his analysis on the creation of “Hinduism” and the specifics of the Indo-Trinidadian experience, which sets it apart and indeed complements Crosson's own excellent study.
If the first part of the book makes the argument that “religion” in colonial Trinidad had to be created as a category through law and disciplinary mechanisms, the second part focuses on how the law partly necessitated the creation of “Hinduism.” Rocklin argues that it was colonial law that led Trinidadians to begin dividing their worlds into religion and not-religion and to create “Hinduism” in a way that would be recognized by this division in order to receive governmental support and financing (152). In the second part of the book, Rocklin moves away from indentureship and more popular practices to focus on the post-indenture period, specifically the 1930s–1940s. Centering his attention on the Hindu-identified Indo-Trinidadian middle class, Rocklin examines the ways in which Hindu leaders organized Hindu institutional bodies to construct a more unified Hindu identity on the island. Perhaps in deference to works already published detailing the development of Hinduism in Trinidad such as Steven Vertovec's Hindu Trinidad and Paul Younger's New Homelands,Footnote 3 Rocklin does not provide a comprehensive or detailed history of Hinduism on the island. Instead, he picks and chooses relevant examples to illustrate the tension over who could and was allowed to speak for Hinduism before moving to a discussion of the transition from simply creating “Hinduism” to understanding it to be part of the category of “world religion.” Importantly, Rocklin does not treat Hinduism, even middle-class Hinduism, in Trinidad as monolithic and takes care to highlight tensions between groups as they clamor to become the voice for Hindu Indo-Trinidadians.
The final and shortest of his chapters, “Making World Religions,” has the most untapped potential. Rocklin only scratches the surface in his sections on performing masculinity, but perhaps it is because further examination would take him away from his focus on law and the regulation of religion. Despite including a relatively short discussion on masculinity, there is little on gender and the laws that regulated the lives of Hindu women in particular. He notes the violence against Indian women a few times, including in his discussion on suicide (113–18), but a thorough discussion on the relationship between laws and religion in the construction of the ideal Hindu woman is missing. Perhaps this is because scholars like Rhoda Reddock, Gaiutra Bahadur, and Verene ShepherdFootnote 4 have written extensively on these topics, but it would have been interesting to see how Rocklin conceives of this element and the relationship it has with others in the greater “constellation of colonial policies” (10) that he illustrates.
Rocklin offers much more than a discussion of the development of some “Hindu” identity. He investigates the category of religion and the ways in which laws concerning religion and religious freedom worked to construct both an understanding of religion and of Hinduism in Trinidad. Rocklin is careful not to present these categories as an imposition of the British elite, instead highlighting the interplay between the colonizers and the colonized who used the colonizer's own rules and definitions to carve out their own ideas about their beliefs and practices. Although the book may be difficult for some undergraduates who are unfamiliar with the history and the context of the Caribbean and the theories of some thinkers such as Michel Foucault, Homi Bhabha, and Judith Butler, Rocklin's attention to law and the regulation of religion is worthy of consideration and discussion. The focus on prisons and schools in chapter 3, “Converting Religion,” may be particularly helpful for comparisons with the United States. For those scholars working on the category of religion and the boarder field of cultural classification, Rocklin's focus on the Caribbean is an important case study, as the Caribbean is often left out of these discussions despite its interesting and complex history. Because Rocklin's sources are mostly archival, what is missing is a sense of the continued development of these ideas in present-day Trinidad, an objective that is left for future scholars, who can use his book as a launching point.
