Eugen E. Slutsky (1880–1948) was a Ukrainian/Russian/Soviet mathematician and statistician who was also interested in economic theory, to which he made two noteworthy contributions: “On the Theory of the Budget of the Consumer” (1915), originally published in Italian in the Giornale degli Economisti as an unnoticed contribution to the Paretian ordinal tradition until it was rediscovered in the 1930s by Dominedò, Schultz, and Allen; and “The Summation of Random Causes as the Source of Cyclic Processes” (1927), originally published in Russian with an extended English summary, and subsequently published, as a contribution to the modern mathematical theory of business cycles, in Econometrica in 1937. Besides these two isolated contributions, Slutsky is likely to have published more on economics had Stalinist policies not taken the liberty and life of most of his colleagues at Kondratiev’s Conjuncture Institute in Moscow. Slutsky, recognizing that economics was a politically exposed area of research, turned away from economics at the end of the 1920s, and pursued his career in pure mathematics and statistics, with applications to apparently less at-risk disciplines, such as geophysics.
This conventional history of Slutsky is outdated. In the last decade, historians of economic thought and historians of mathematics have revisited Slutsky’s legacy. Notably, the knowledge of his economic contributions was enhanced in many respects through the work of scholars Chipman, Rauscher, Sheynin, and Wittich, who translated into English two of Slutsky’s unknown papers: “A Critique of Böhm-Bawerk’s Concept of Value and His Theory of the Measurability of Value” (1927) and “An Enquiry into the Formal Praxeological Foundations of Economics” (1926). This enlarges the scope of economic interventions traditionally attributed to Slutsky. The publication of Slutsky’s two, short, posthumous autobiographies, as well as his letters to Ladislaus von Bortkiewicz and to Ragnar Frisch, also shed fresh light on Slutsky.
In this respect, Vincent Barnett’s latest book, based on several years of research, constitutes a great step forward. It not only establishes the first intellectual biography of Slutsky in English (or in any other language, for that matter), but it is also the first comprehensive account of his works in both economics and mathematics. Barnett’s book aims to evaluate Slutsky’s legacy by exploring the less-known aspects of his work, and by building ties between his apparently disparate pieces of work. This implies a study of the various disciplines, besides economics, in which Slutsky was involved: mathematics, probability theory, statistics, and geophysics. Barnett also questions Slutsky’s motivations for switching from one discipline to another. He is interested in determining the influence that Slutsky may have had on the development of science in the Soviet Union and in Western countries, particularly at the frontier of economics and mathematics. This includes not only the development of econometrics and the mathematical formalization of economics in the 1940s to the 1950s, but also the axiomatization of mathematics and of probability theory in the mid-twentieth century. Given the wide scope of disciplines involved, and Slutsky’s careful discretion regarding his motivations and achievements, the task is challenging.
In fact, Barnett invites his readers on an investigative quest for clues to help reconstruct the course of Slutsky’s life, his networks, and his spheres of influence. This research led him not only to Slutsky’s and his colleagues’ writings, and to the archives of the institutions where Slutsky worked, but also to various information encountered in the histories of the multiple disciplines involved. Therefore, besides his native history of economic thought, Barnett relies on the history of mathematics, statistics, and astronomy, and on general histories of science. Although it is difficult for the present reviewer to assess Barnett’s views on the history of mathematics and astronomy, it is easy to recognize that, while potentially a perilous exercise, it was a fruitful one.
After an introduction that sets out the Russian scientific background, Part I of the book retraces Slutsky’s intellectual biography in four chronological chapters (Ch. 1, Before the Bolshevik Revolution 1880–1917; Ch. 2, From War Communism to NEP 1917–26; Ch. 3, At the Conjuncture Institute 1926–30; Ch. 4, The Impact of Stalinism 1930–48). Part II of the book contains three less-known articles by Slutsky, each translated into English and introduced by Barnett. It contains the translation of Slutsky’s very interesting single contribution as an historian of economic thought: “An Essay on the Economic Views of Sir William Petty” (1914); the translation of an influential paper on probability: “On the Question of the Logical Foundations of the Calculus of Probabilities” (1922); and an extended summary of one of Slutsky’s two papers on monetary theory: “On the Question of the Calculation of the Income Received by the State from Currency Emission” (1923). Part III concludes. The appendices contain the English summary of Slutsky’s 1927 article on cyclical processes (a document that was in the possession of a few Western scholars such as Schultz, Mitchell, and Frisch up to ten years before the Econometrica edition), and the translation of the extended table of contents of Slutsky’s Reference Slutsky1910 student dissertation on the theory of marginal utility.
What do we learn on Slutsky and his work from this investigation? The man had a complex personality, and, besides an addiction to mathematics, his centers of interest were remarkably wide, including translating Tagore and composing poetry. Temporarily expelled from Kiev University in 1901 for political unreliability, he took advantage of his stay abroad in Munich at an engineering institute to read Marx. As a scientist, Slutsky was very talented at initiating new ideas, but preferred to let them be developed by others. He had almost no followers (except perhaps Chetverikov), but some people undoubtedly came after his traces. He was cosmopolitan, corresponding with European and American scholars, publishing in foreign journals, and attending international conferences even during the Soviet period. He did not seek public responsibilities, but found himself heading a Soviet commission on the application of mathematics and statistics to industry in the 1930s. As an economist too, his scope of interest was large, and was not restricted to mathematical economics. He worked on cooperatives, on William Petty, on monetary circulation, on demand theory, the Austrian theory of value, fluctuations, and on his “praxeological foundations of economics,” and he applied much of his developments on correlation—he introduced the least square regression method in Russia—to economic examples. As a mathematician and a statistician, his versatility no longer needs to be proven, given his contributions to the solar constant, probability and random functions, sunspot periodicity, extrapolation, and the analysis of time series.
The objective of introducing unknown aspects of Slutsky’s work, as well as the description of his physical (Kiev, Moscow) and epistolary networks, have been more than achieved in this book. Besides, Barnett convincingly argues that one finds an overall consistency in the methodology adopted by Slutsky in both economics and mathematics, in his ubiquitous will to define sciences on proper probabilistic foundations, and without psychological hypotheses. Some of the propositions launched by Slutsky, such as his praxeological foundation of economics, have hardly been followed at all. Others received more attention, such as his reformulation of probabilities, which was eventually considered by the Soviet mathematician Kolmogorov as a first step in his own direction of research. The same can be said of his theory of consumer budget and his business cycle analysis. Barnett’s characterization of Slutsky as a “key nodal point” (p. 18) of the numerous conceptual changes that occurred at his time in mathematics and economics is a most interesting insight. Instead of speaking of direct and indirect influence, Slutsky’s significance in the history of these disciplines is better characterized as follows: in many fields, Slutsky captured the spirit of his time—indeed, he was sometimes ahead of his time. He made several first steps, which were later to be rediscovered and expanded upon by other scholars.
Among such hypothetical “first steps” advanced by Barnett, three caught our attention. First is the possible influence of Slutsky’s consumer budget theory on the Russian and Soviet studies on peasant household budget (Chayanov, Popov, Prokopovich). This line of thought is interesting, but would require the discovery of new written material in order to be confirmed or rejected. The second is Slutsky’s role in the development of econometrics, in view of his Frisch–Schultz connection. The third is Slutsky’s role in the mathematical impetus given to economic science by the Cowles Commission, and not only through his former student in Kiev, Marschak. As regards to the second and third points, as subtly suggested by Barnett, the influence that Slutsky did not have is even more important in understanding the path that was followed by mathematical economics and econometrics between the 1930s to the 1950s. This explains why, given the scarcity of available material clues, this book is a reliable source of novelties for historians of mathematical economics and of econometrics.
We will finish this review by mentioning what we saw as two shortcomings of this very stimulating book. First, the figure of Bortkiewicz—almost absent in this book—could have played a larger role in this story, since most Russian émigré mathematical economists first spent several years in Germany, in contact with Bortkiewicz, before arriving in the US—as the cases of Marschak and Leontief testify. In this regard, the book could have made use of the recently published correspondence between Slutsky and Bortkiewicz (Rauscher et al. Reference Rauscher, Sheynin and Wittich2007). Second, the book takes no account of the importance of Slutsky’s Reference Slutsky1910 dissertation, The Theory of Marginal Utility. Some of Slutsky’s subsequent works were already in progress in this 300-page, well-informed student work. That being said, this voyage into the history of economics and mathematics made worthwhile reading.
