The centenary of the alleged ‘discovery’ of the electron prompted some vigorous revisionism, epitomized by Jed Buchwald and Andrew Warwick's edited collection Histories of the Electron: The Birth of Microphysics (Cambridge, MA, 2001). In his contribution to that volume, Theodore Arabatzis argued that the Dutch physicist Pieter Zeeman's determination of an extraordinarily low mass-to-charge ratio in 1896 was more important as well as earlier than J. J. Thomson's crude but later much fetishized experiments of spring 1897. While in a sense Representing Electrons is an expansion of that persuasive argument, Arabatizis's book offers more than a broadening of the timescale, geography and personnel involved in the arrival of the electron in modern science. In certain respects the book amounts to a pulling-back from the revisionist spirit of the earlier piece. This is not only because Arabatzis seeks to reintegrate the historical and philosophical debates on the electron so carefully disentangled by Buchwald and Warwick. Nor is it just that he presents an old-fashioned internalist account, concentrating on Popperian ‘problem-situations’ that, as he depicts them, developed exclusively in response to debates within physics and chemistry, with such fashionably complicating factors as technologies, institutions and wider social formations ignored. Ironically, Arabatzis's conservatism is most apparent in what he sees as his major innovation: his attempt to narrate electron history in the genre of biography. To this reviewer's knowledge, this has not been tried in print since Charles R. Gibson's Autobiography of an Electron (1911), an uncited precedent. Unsurprisingly, Arabatzis does not address a traditional concern about biography, namely that a unifying narrative of a self-contained entity comes at the cost of omitting or hiding inconvenient evidential messiness.
He implicitly challenges the pluralism explicit even in the title of Histories of the Electron by insisting that he can rewrite the story in more monolithic terms. Cannily, he does not attempt to write a biography of the electron per se but rather of representations of it. He concedes that the former task would be impossible for such an elusive entity (as distinct from the thing-like objects and artefacts biographied in the recent work of Lorraine Daston et al.). Some might be puzzled, of course, by the suggestion that a series of changing representations can be anthropomorphized into the tale of a single entity. Arabatzis invites us to see that the electron has had a life of its own, manifest in behaviour that has recurrently strained beyond the representational harnesses that theorist puppet-masters have sought to impose upon it. By forcing its scientists to change their representational practices, the electron, writes Arabatzis, expresses ‘a point of view’, and this is evidenced in the ‘writings’ it has left for them in cathode ray tubes and cloud chamber trails (pp. 46–52).
Readers will have to judge for themselves whether this classic trope of ‘realist’ empiricism is interpretative sophistication or intemperate sophistry, or indeed whether it helps the author to amalgamate the diverse lives of candidate electrons explored here. Apart from Thomson's curious and uncompelling ‘corpuscle’, Arabatzis informs us in great depth about Lorentz and Zeeman's ‘ion’, the respectively solid and ethereal electrons of Stoney and Larmor and the much stranger quantum varieties of electron due to Bohr and Pauli. Less sober historians might have been tempted to respond to this extraordinary menagerie by trying the historical psychiatry of dissociative identity disorder, the prosopography of electron impersonators or the family history of rather peculiarly variant microparticle siblings. Such postmodernist mischief is clearly not for Arabatzis, any more than is the old (if inaccurate) joke that J. J. Thomson got the Nobel Prize for physics for discovering that the electron was a particle while his son G. P. Thomson got the same prize three decades later for discovering that the electron was a wave.
Rather revealingly, Arabatzis's question-begging presumption of the appropriateness of biographical narrative is mirrored in his concluding chapter. There he conveniently moves to the claim that all the representations of the electrons discussed unambiguously refer to the same entity because all share such common characteristics as a unique mass–charge ratio (p. 262). Arabatzis is only able to make this claim, however, by deploying a rather loose notion of ‘sameness’ – avoiding any discussion of the prolonged problems experienced by Thomson and others in establishing anything better than an order-of-magnitude similarity among discrepant results until Millikan's (controversial) work in the 1910s. Indeed, apparently indifferent to fin de siècle sensitivities about precision, Arabatzis claims that such discrepancies were sufficiently small to establish the electron's stability of identity (p. 263). But if that inference is unpalatable to historians, one can only imagine the alarm with which philosophical colleagues will read the final sentence of the book. Notwithstanding the case he makes for the stable transhistorical identity of the electron, Arabatzis avers that the elements of continuity thereby evinced ‘do not sufficiently establish the electron's existence’. While biographers need to be fussy about many things, the existential authenticity of their subject need not, apparently, be one of them.
All that aside, if readers averse to philosophical and biographical meditations skip over the relevant chapters (One, Two and Nine), they are likely to find much of interest and little to offend in the intervening material. After recapitulating the case against the Thomson-centred ‘Received view’ in Chapter Three, Arabatzis goes on to consider the ‘Birth and infancy’ of the representations of the electron in Chapter Four, then the ‘genesis’ of the quantum electron, considerations of relativity theory and then a drily amusing chapter on the chemists’ perspective – ‘How the electrons spend their leisure time’ – before the little creatures are forced to spin in Chapter Eight by Uhlenbeck and Goudsmit. While technically demanding in places, and rigorously non-contextualist in its approach, these seven scholarly chapters of this affordable book might at least help it find its way to a deserved place as a graduate textbook in the field.
