During the coldest months of 1909, Crow Creek tribal members met in council to select delegates to send to Washington, DC. The tribal council had discussed unfulfilled promises of their historic treaties and wanted to “consult with the Commissioner of Indian Affairs on matters of interest” to their community. They chose Thomas Tuttle, Bear Ghost (Mato Wanaġi) and Levi Big Eagle (Wamdi Tanka) as their representatives to meet with Commissioner Francis C. Leupp about their concerns. The Crow Creek superintendent had informed them that their treaty concerns should be “taken up in the usual way in writing,” but they insisted on going to “see the Great Father face to face.” Building on previous initiatives, over one hundred people (about 10 percent of the reservation population) either attended the meetings or agreed by their signature to the deliberations and strategy of sending delegates on a political mission. Before the end of March, federal officials had authorized over three hundred dollars for the three delegates to travel to the nation's capital.Footnote 1
These Crow Creek activists represented a cross-section of the population. They included members of several Lower Yanktonai bands, graduates from prominent Indian boarding schools, non-English speakers, members of Protestant and Catholic churches, families engaged in ceremonial life, and employees at the agency. Participants represented a broad age range (from their twenties to their seventies) and included several generations of Crow Creek families. Many identified with mixed ancestry, and others were recognized as “full-bloods.” Some tribal members were considered U.S. citizens, many were not, and even fewer could vote in national elections. Among the many in attendance were future artist John Saul, Presbyterian Minister David Tatiopa, and Crow Creek elder Don't Know (“D.K.”) How—brother of the deceased, former principal chief White Ghost (Wanaġi Ska).Footnote 2 Consistent with the reform spirit of the Progressive Era, they believed they could influence federal policy, combat political corruption, and cultivate the assistance of federal officials to address their community's needs.
Despite frequent portrayals of Indian decline during the Progressive Era, Crow Creek activists did not look backward to a celebrated distant past. They were a people of the present, looking forward to chart a course for their future. Like other tribes throughout Indian Country, they retained values of their elders and used progressive strategies of council meetings, petition drives, alliance building, and sending delegations to the halls of political power. In the process, they removed corrupt agents, used U.S. legal processes to gain compensation for their loss of land, and cultivated support to educate their children about the American system to prepare for future negotiations with federal officials.
Recent scholarship on the Progressive Era has highlighted multiple progressivisms. Rather than a single, united program, scholars have considered a range of activists fighting against emerging concentrations of political and economic power, and engaged in social justice reform. Studies have examined bottom-up reformers, the agency of non-whites in intercultural relations, and evidence of limited (not necessarily triumphal) victories against emerging economic and political forces. The latest of these efforts have examined women, African Americans, labor, and others asserting their own interest group or class identity.Footnote 3
American Indian history into the 1990s highlighted federal policy and the losses incurred by Native people during the Progressive Era. Revealing the toll that capitalism and settler colonialism had taken on Indian Country, several generations of scholars rightfully highlighted destructive federal policies, land allotment and losses, and cultural assimilation.Footnote 4 Indian people in many earlier works are relegated to the predicates of sentences: land taken from them, culture drawn out of them, and youth taken away to boarding schools. As late as the 1990s, one prominent historian of the American West stated that in the Progressive Era “the Indian was primarily a bystander, seldom a participant, often a victim, and rarely a beneficiary of the progressive reforms.”Footnote 5 Such portrayals mainly kept American Indians marginalized from the national story of the Progressive Era.Footnote 6
In the past few decades, scholars have refuted the claims of Native passivity, and revealed many levels of activism that fit Indian people into the dominant narratives of the Progressive Era.Footnote 7 Frederick Hoxie's Talking Back to Civilization: Indian Voices from the Progressive Era provided numerous examples of American Indian leaders asserting sovereignty and tribal agendas despite federal policies designed to extract sovereignty and eliminate tribal identities.Footnote 8 Tribal histories of communities across the West have also presented political activism of this era within their narratives that cross several historical time periods.Footnote 9 Recently, this journal published an issue exploring American Indians in the Progressive Era with attention to several communities in Indian Country.Footnote 10
A majority of works pertaining to tribal people during the Progressive Era focus on the notable Society of American Indians (SAI) or its prominent leaders like Charles Eastman, Laura Cornelius Kellogg, Carlos Montezuma, Charles Dagenett, Gertrude Bonnin (Zitkala Ṡa), and other graduates of prominent Indian boarding schools. Formed only two years after the better-known National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP), the SAI was the first Indian-led national organization founded to educate American society about the abilities and accomplishment of Native Americans, advocate for federal policies to rectify past injustices, and promote opportunities for individual tribal members.Footnote 11
Several recent articles have highlighted the centennial of the initial SAI conference held in Columbus, Ohio, on Columbus Day in 1911.Footnote 12 Inaugural meetings, council sessions, and publications reveal the significance of Native leaders engaging with themselves as well as literally and metaphorically talking back to white elites. By January of 1912, SAI leaders established their headquarters in Washington, DC, and initiated efforts to challenge persistent Native land losses, promote honest politics, enhance educational opportunities, and advocate for Indian citizenship. In an era that had not experienced this before, these voices brought tribal issues to national attention and laid the foundation for future policies that gradually, though inconsistently, supported elements of sovereignty and led toward self-determination.Footnote 13
This essay shifts away from the SAI and East Coast influence of federal Indian policy to activism over several decades in a single Native community located in central South Dakota. It reveals that while actions were taking place on a national level in eastern cities, a broader constellation of Native American actors talked back to power, advocated for their people, and consistently attempted to govern themselves. Just as colonial assemblies that promoted independence in the 1770s reveal a broader support for Thomas Jefferson's drafting of the Declaration of Independence, so too does local activism demonstrate a broader range of American Indian political activism that in fact took place throughout Indian Country.Footnote 14 Decentering the narrative of Indians in the Progressive Era highlights a broader array of Native leadership and actions during the era.Footnote 15
Crow Creek tribal members who attended off-reservation boarding schools also merged tribal values with lessons learned from their American education. Several may have learned about the inaugural meeting through one of the four thousand invitations sent out to potential attendees, but most chose to focus their attentions at home.Footnote 16 Of approximately two-hundred Crow Creek men in 1911, nearly half were involved in raising livestock, over fifty worked in some capacity for the U.S. Indian Service, and more than a dozen had been married that same year.Footnote 17 Those who found time for political engagement mainly emphasized local dimensions of national issues. According to Crow Creek Agent Harry D. Chamberlain, the returned students certainly sparked new perspectives and resistance to federal policies. “There are some who oppose the new policy [of eliminating the ration system], claiming that they are being paid for their labor with their own money,” Chamberlain noted in 1902, “this feeling and statement originate and come from the more educated ones—those who have returned from Carlisle and Hampton Institutes.”Footnote 18
A closer examination of Crow Creek also reveals the likely influence of this community on the SAI. Prior to joining SAI, both Charles E. Dagenett (1894) and Charles Eastman (1900–03) worked for the Indian Service at Crow Creek, and both went on to serve in prominent capacities within the organization.Footnote 19 Zitkala Ṡa who was raised on the nearby Yankton Reservation and would have been well aware of developments at Crow Creek, served as secretary and editor of the SAI journal American Indian Magazine. Historian Lucy Maddox notes that while members like Zitkala Ṡa focused on reservation life and tribal cultural norms, the organization often struggled with connecting to the daily realities of tribal communities across the nation.Footnote 20 The more they advocated for national policies among themselves far from reservation communities, the less the organization reflected reservation realities. Thus, as Philip Deloria suggests, there is a need to look beyond the SAI leadership to get a better context for Native leadership of the era.Footnote 21
A close study of Crow Creek during the Progressive Era also reframes the portrayal of this community and others in Indian Country from a people who resist change to an engaged community of activists looking forward. A focus on prominent national events that bookended the Progressive Era on the Northern Plains (the 1889 breakup of the Great Sioux Reservation and the 1934 Indian Reorganization Act) shows Crow Creek people exerting themselves in opposition to federal policies. This essay will consider political actions between these national developments to reveal lesser-known acts of engagement rather than simply “agency” of opposition. Consequently, rather than a recalcitrant community in opposition to U.S. policies, research into this historical era shows a civically-minded people establishing themselves within a new political system. And these actions provide a more significant context from which to understand the political choices made after World War II when Crow Creek gained federal recognition.Footnote 22
Crow Creek may seem to be the antithesis of anything progressive. For most, it is known only as the location where federal officials sent Minnesota Dakotas following the 1862 U.S.-Dakota war. The exiled Dakotas barely survived, according to most accounts, and families willingly abandoned Crow Creek for the Santee Sioux Reservation in northeastern Nebraska within a few years.Footnote 23 Despite this ominous beginning, however, Crow Creek became home to an emerging community of bands from the Oceti Sakowin. Following the historic 1863 Battle of Whitestone Hill (North Dakota), Yanktonais and Dakotas were taken by federal troops to Crow Creek where other bands of Lakotas and Dakotas had been gathering.Footnote 24
White Ghost (Wanaġi Ska) served as the principal chief of this community that organized itself on the east bank of the Missouri River during the 1870s. It was not unfamiliar territory, as his father Bone Necklace and other western Sioux bands had spent time in this area of the Missouri River valley over the past few decades. Several other groups, including Two Kettles' bands of Lakotas, had joined them, migrating down from Fort Sully or other locations upriver on the Missouri in a time of declining bison herds.Footnote 25 Drifting Goose (Maġa Bobdu) and his people, despite historic ties to the James River (east of the Missouri), were ushered there by federal officials in 1879. Within a few years, Bull Ghost's people from Standing Rock joined them as well.Footnote 26 Over time, individuals and families from Santee, Yankton, and Lower Brule and Dakotas from Minnesota also made Crow Creek their home.
Crow Creek activism took place on three levels during the Gilded Age and Progressive Era. While leaders like White Ghost held certain influence on the community and had more direct access to the agent, by the 1880s a committee of fifty had been formed to address matters pertaining to Crow Creek.Footnote 27 Most notably, political activism served to pull varied members of the reservation community together in pursuit of common goals. In fact, as early as the mid-1880s, Drifting Goose referred to White Ghost as “our head chief.” Federal officials could see this shared identity formation particularly in negotiations over Crow Creek land.Footnote 28 At the same time, individual bands continued to pursue efforts to reclaim traditional homelands. More than thirty years after their arrival at Crow Creek, Drifting Goose (and after 1909, his descendants) continued to press for rights to their historic lands along the James River. Third, and more recognizable on the eve of World War I, Crow Creek residents became political participants in broader Oceti Sakowin matters as they hosted meetings pertaining to the Black Hills land case that grew in the 1920s.
Portrait of White Ghost n.d. photo by Charles Milton Bell, INV 06647001. National Anthropological Archives, Smithsonian Institution
DRIFTING GOOSE- Dakota: Lower Yanktonai. aka Magha Bomdu. Photo by C.M. Bell, Wash. DC 1884. Neg. 3543-A-1. Purchased from Smithsonian Inst. June, 1979
When pressures grew to relinquish land in the 1880s, Crow Creek leaders used distinct approaches to negotiate for their people's best interests. In the summer of 1883, White Ghost decried the coercion behind prior treaties and Drifting Goose voiced opposition to new agreements until prior commitments had been fulfilled. With most already claiming allotments prior to the Dawes (General Allotment) Act of 1887, both leaders sought to prepare their children for a successful future at Crow Creek.Footnote 29 “I wanted to live here and have my reservation larger, so that my children's children can depend on the land and never dispose of it,” White Ghost noted with an eye toward community self-sufficiency.Footnote 30 Crow Creek opposition even reached the attention of President Grover Cleveland, who in April of 1885 reversed the executive order of his predecessor that had “opened up” Crow Creek to white settlement earlier that year.Footnote 31 Federal officials generally, however, continued to try to acquire more land in the last years of the 1880s. And, while they were more successful in securing signatures of leaders from other South Dakota Indian communities to support the 1889 Sioux land cession proposals, White Ghost and Drifting Goose led a majority from Crow Creek who voted against the measure.Footnote 32
BEAR GHOST - Dakota: Yanktonai Crow Creek. Photo by D.L. Gill, DeLancey B.A.E Wash. DC March, 1909. Neg. 3532-A. Purchased from Smithsonian Inst. June, 1979.
Native leaders realized that they also had to scrutinize the treaties and legal decisions made by federal officials. While California Indians focused on the size of land allotments and the Blackfeet of Montana focused on securing mineral rights, Crow Creek leaders investigated the overall acreage of their homeland.Footnote 33 After close examination, White Ghost noted that west-river Oceti Sakowin tribes were allotted more land than the people of Crow Creek in the 1889 Sioux Act. Using his noted oratorical skills, he astutely approached the Crow Creek agent and, in December of 1896, led a delegation to Washington, DC, to address the issue. “We discovered,” White Ghost noted, “that the number of acres reserved for a permanent reservation for the Indians receiving rations and annuities at the Crow Creek agency was 187,000 less than the number reserved for the people west of the Missouri River, in proportion to our number.” In compensation for the loss of 187,000 acres, General George R. Crook had promised (in the 1889 negotiations) to provide $187,000, as well as provisions for rations and annuities at Crow Creek. White Ghost's delegation could only secure half of the interest earned, or $4,500, but this act initiated an eight-year process for fair compensation.Footnote 34
Receiving payment from Congress took time and allies, particularly in the years following the 1893 economic depression. Crow Creek leaders petitioned the next Congress for payment of principal, and successfully made their case to Crow Creek agent Fred Treon. Agent Treon contacted the commissioner in the summer of 1897 and argued that supporting White Ghost's proposal would benefit Crow Creek and the federal budget in the long run. “If this plan could be followed out,” Treon asserted, “I honestly believe that in five years, these people would be nearly, if not quite, self-supporting.”Footnote 35 By February of 1898, White Ghost prompted Commissioner William A. Jones to submit a new report to Congress on the debt owed to Crow Creek residents.Footnote 36 Finally, in 1902, the Secretary of the Interior authorized the distribution of $60,000 for the purchase of stock cattle; $25,000 for pro rata cash distribution; and over $83,000 for the purchase of cattle fence wire, construction of storage reservoirs, improvement of allotments, and other resources for the general welfare of the Crow Creek people.Footnote 37
In addition to legal documents, Native leaders needed to pay careful attention to the federal agents appointed to their communities. President Grant's Peace Policy attempted to break up so-called Indian Rings that grew rich off annuities meant for tribal communities, but financial improprieties persisted enough for federal officials to gain wealth at the expense of their Native constituents. Some SAI leaders like Carlos Montezuma notably called for the elimination of the Indian Office, but reservation leaders more specifically addressed the individuals holding position as reservation agents. While the Menominees protested the removal of their agent, tribal members at Crow Creek sought the removal of theirs.Footnote 38 By 1898, White Ghost faced a notorious agent who served himself more than the community he was hired to assist.
Agent James H. Stephens regularly abused his authority, intimidated tribal members, employed his staff for his own gain, and punished those who criticized his actions. He had created a system that provided significant avenues toward gaining personal wealth from his government position. By the spring of 1900, White Ghost increasingly raised concerns about the mistreatment of his people, promoting a government investigation, and gathering allies to remove the agent from office. Others joined the chorus of criticism. Stephens had “lost the respect of the Indians,” Frank Avery, superintendent of Crow Creek Boarding School noted, to the extent that “there is not one adult member of the tribe—outwardly friendly to him or not, who does not thoroughly believe him to be dishonest.”Footnote 39
Stephens learned to work the system to his advantage for more than three years while unintentionally unifying the community in opposition to him. Stephens undermined federal policies to support economic opportunities for tribal people on reservation lands by renting out land to non-Indians (without tribal consent), limiting economic opportunities for tribal members, and securing personal profits for sales of his cattle.Footnote 40 He broke the law that forbid agents from participating in trade with Indians—requiring individuals to only sell their livestock to him and then only offering the lowest market rates. Stephens even used agency staff in his illegal cattle business, preventing Crow Creek families from earning any profits from their own livestock. During a federal investigation into these prohibited activities, nearly twenty tribal members testified to his illegal livestock business. Still he retained his position, and then got revenge on those who testified against him. He outlawed public meetings and confronted those who opposed him. His decision to arrest George Grey Cloud, and keep him in jail for over a month, however, did not stifle tribal opposition to federal officials. Instead, it seems to have motivated Grey Cloud to initiate political activism in the next few years.Footnote 41
By the summer of 1900, White Ghost turned to other members of the community to help him make the case for the removal of Agent Stephens. One hundred and sixty-six Crow Creek residents signed a petition requesting his removal: “We the undersigned being citizens of the Crow Creek Reservation and the Indians who think our rights should be respected Petition the office at Washington to remove from our Agency the man who is now filling the office of Agent namely, J. H. Stephens, on the ground that he is incompetent and not fit for the position, and second that he has not looked after the welfare of the Indians but his own and Robbed them in every way he could.”Footnote 42 Other tribal members, like Henry St. Pierre, a farmer at the federal school in Fort Thompson, made their own specific criticisms of Agent Stephens. In an eleven-page letter to Herbert Welsh, a founder and secretary of the Indian Rights Association, St. Pierre laid out additional charges of Stephens's treatment of agency workers and poor supervision of the agency boarding school.Footnote 43
By February of 1901, White Ghost had attracted the support of church and federal leaders. Episcopal Bishop William Hobart Hare finally voiced his opposition to the agent and even Crow Creek Episcopal Minister Hekalia Burt, who was often critical of White Ghost's politics, agreed to support Stephens's removal. Agent Nathan P. Johnson, from nearby Sisseton, provided legal evidence for Stephen's dismissal. He noted that, according to Section 2078 of the Revised Statutes of the United States, “no person employed in Indian Affairs shall have any interest or concern in any trade with the Indians, except for, and on account of the United States; and any person offending herein, shall be liable to a penalty of five thousand dollars, and shall be removed from his office.”Footnote 44 Federal officials in Washington finally ended Stephens's employment, and by April 1901, he left Crow Creek.Footnote 45 While South Dakota had led the nation as the first state to adopt the initiative and referendum process, Crow Creek leaders effectively acted to have federal officials recall their agent.Footnote 46
Crow Creek leaders were not simply critics, they acted in support of positive choices to secure qualified people to work within their community. Though not officially affiliated with a particular Christian church, the seventy-two-year-old principal chief allied with several Protestants to benefit his people. Together with Presbyterian Rev. David Taliyopa and Catechists James Williams and Homer Clark, White Ghost requested that Sarah LaCroix succeed Mildred Halliday as field matron in 1900. For decades, La Croix had acted as a culture broker between Catholic missionaries and tribal members on the north side of the reservation. While federal records identify Halliday as “mixed blood” and LaCroix as “Indian,” it was the latter's qualities more than so-called race that revealed the Crow Creek agenda.Footnote 47 They argued to the commissioner of Indian Affairs that Mrs. LaCroix “speaks our language, is a member of our tribe, and has always been a friend in sickness.”Footnote 48
Ever watchful of federal corruption at Crow Creek, White Ghost's resistance toward agency officials persisted even after Stephens's departure. No more than a year later, he was reconnecting with his political allies at the Indian Rights Association about the new agent, Harry D. Chamberlain. White Ghost used similar tactics, but in this case it was major philosophical differences that caused political tensions. Chamberlain had a background in the merchandise and hotel business and no particular experience with Indians. He was a classic progressive, who came to Fort Thompson with a focus on promoting assimilation, moving tribal people from annuities to work programs, and the use of reservation land for economic development. The principal chief opposed Chamberlain's abrupt policy changes and his advocacy for leasing tribal land to cattlemen in the region.Footnote 49 White Ghost's actions could be consistent with progressives in some reform endeavors, but it was clear that he was no progressive if that meant leasing out more of his people's land to non-Indians, even if U.S. officials saw it as efficient use of natural resources.
When Dakota physician Charles Eastman came to work as an agency physician at Crow Creek from 1900 to 1903 he again learned how federal policy played out in political conflicts at the agency.Footnote 50 Dr. Eastman initially stayed out of agency politics. He sent no letters to the commission about problems at the agency, and when Chamberlain arrived, Eastman commented that he “seems to be a good and well-meaning man.” Over time, however, Eastman agreed with White Ghost's criticisms of Chamberlain's efforts to withdraw annuities earned through treaties, opposition to tribal dances, and support of land transfers from deceased tribal members to non-Indians. By 1902, Eastman drew the ire of Chamberlain, who accused the Dakota doctor of working with White Ghost in opposition to agency policies and even forging White Ghost's signature on a letter that criticized Chamberlain. Eastman left Crow Creek by March of 1903, and within a few years participated in conversations that led to the formation of the Society of American Indians.Footnote 51
Land and access to economic opportunities drove the conflict. If Chamberlain's assessment of White Ghost's motivation is correct, the tribal leader was concerned that additional leasing would lead to further land losses. White Ghost did not see leasing out more of his people's land as progress. “A few of the old chiefs are opposed to the leasing of their tribal lands,” the agent figured, “giving for their reason that the white man is trying to get possession of their lands.” Chamberlain, on the other hand, saw leasing land to area stockmen as holding great potential for earning at least $2,000 per year for the reservation community.Footnote 52 In response to Chamberlain's agenda, George Grey Cloud and White Ghost held a council meeting in April of 1902 that promoted the idea of stronger leasing laws to retain more control over their land. While federal law stated that none should be allowed to sell or lease any land for up to twenty-five years, the council instead advocated for a longer period without leasing if not the end of the practice altogether.Footnote 53
Two political systems were in conflict: White Ghost's traditional tribal system of kinship relations and Chamberlain's program promoting assimilation and capitalism. In marked contrast with his predecessor, Chamberlain followed orders from the commissioner of Indian Affairs to attack the annuity system (earned through treaties) and tribal cultural traditions.Footnote 54 Chamberlain cut off from the ration roles those under fifty and “able-bodied,” and instead put them to work building roads, running fences, and making other reservation improvements. While his predecessor Agent Stephens even had allowed tribal members to hold dances as they wished in exchange for providing him with manual labor, Chamberlain tried to reduce dancing.Footnote 55 These actions ultimately undercut White Ghost's political influence by eroding cultural systems that supported his leadership. Not one to be limited in his actions, Chamberlain must have mounted some opposition to White Ghost. In April of 1903, after having already contacted the commissioner about it before, White Ghost wrote, “My people much disturbed by Agent advising young men to depose me as chief, please wire him [to] desist and quiet people.”Footnote 56
Later developments suggest that many of White Ghost's concerns were on the mark. Throughout the early years of the twentieth century, federal rulings from the so-called Dead Indian Act (1902), Burke Act (1906), and other legislation increasingly made it possible for land to be leased and sold.Footnote 57 During the early years of the century numerous cattlemen leased available allotments at Crow Creek. By 1902, John “J. Q.” Anderson of Chamberlain had thirty leases at Crow Creek, and by 1907 he had purchased many allotments. By 1914, he leased many allotted lands, from 80 to 140 acres, and carefully selected allotments that bordered tribal lands to use its pasture for his livestock. By fencing in his new lands (a tax deductible cost as a “land improvement”), he also limited tribal herds' access to natural water supplies. Using legal methods, this process created barriers and separation from water sources that dissuaded tribal members from entering the cattle business. Chamberlain himself participated in the process by granting “competency” to tribal members that allowed them to then sell their land. Under challenging economic conditions, and now faced with paying property taxes, many opted to sell. By June of 1912, federal acts of 1902 and 1907 allowed Crow Creek residents to legally sell nearly forty thousand acres of land.Footnote 58
Native leaders throughout Indian Country mounted actions against an encroaching economic system. While the Mille Lacs Ojibwes sought to remove squatters and turned to the U.S. Court of Claims to secure their homelands, Crow Creek leaders met in tribal council to increase their compensation for leasing land to outsiders.Footnote 59 From single-year contracts with payments of ten cents per acre, they instituted a new fee of $1.50 per head of livestock on their land that cattlemen agreed to pay. And despite much loss, many Crow Creek tribal members retained allotments of patents in trust by the 1920s, with several dozen maintaining a quarter section, 160 acres, or more. According to industrial surveys taken in the 1920s, dozens of families had dairy cows, flocks of chickens, hogs, and gardens. They may not have achieved the picture that non-Indians had promoted in their assimilation programs, but Crow Creek residents found ways to survive through wage work at the agency, employment by cattlemen like Anderson, or work in the government service. While many Crow Creek tribal members still noted a federal system that contributed to Native land loss, others welcomed wage earning possibilities that rose from just over a dollar a day to ten dollars a day for skilled labor.Footnote 60
The Progressive Era witnessed tribal leaders adopting new political strategies, but many still retained commitment to their ancestral lands even after they had been removed from them. Like others at Crow Creek, Drifting Goose continued to advocate for a return of his Hunkpati people's land along the James River. In 1901, he informed the commissioner of Indian Affairs that his people had never sold their east-river land. Recognizing American significance of written evidence over oral tradition, Drifting Goose presented a copy of President Rutherford B. Hayes's 1879 Executive Order to support his people's rights to three townships in central South Dakota.Footnote 61 By 1902, Drifting Goose shifted from an argument for justice to the economic benefits to the United States if his people were permitted to return to the James River. Using the American financial efficiency rhetoric of the day, he argued that permission to return would save the federal system money. He stated that he “wanted to go back there to make my living with my people by farming there” and would go “without the government aid.”Footnote 62 Drifting Goose did not reclaim that land in his lifetime, but his descendants continued his efforts even after he died in 1909.Footnote 63
A key to promoting social change during the Progressive Era was for groups to strengthen social networks and cultivate allies. Tribes like the Menominees turned to Protestant and Catholic organizations at the same time to secure their rights, but at Crow Creek there was often more of a division within their community in terms of alliances with religious groups.Footnote 64 While White Ghost had turned to Protestant organizations like the Indian Rights Association as allies, others turned to Roman Catholics living north of the agency for assistance with land claims and educational opportunities for their children. In November of 1902, Bull Ghost and Wooden Horn worked with Benedictine Father Ambrose Mattingly, O.S.B., on a petition to Washington, pertaining to their ancestral land.Footnote 65 It began a process that Wooden Horn and Crow Man would take to Washington, DC, more than a decade later.Footnote 66 One year later, Peter Caron reached out to the superintendent of his alma mater, Immaculate Conception Indian Mission (also known as “Stephan”), for assistance. Father Pius Boehm, O.S.B., agreed to type up a petition to the commissioner of Indian Affairs for Caron to take to Fort Thompson to gather signatures. Consistent with the rest of the nation, the petition system increased political participation in Indian Country.
Only a few years after Theodore Roosevelt became president, several Crow Creek leaders worked with the new Bureau of Catholic Indian Missions (BCIM) director William Ketcham, and federal officials to reclaim federal support for their Catholic mission school. Administered since 1886 by Benedictine fathers, brothers, and sisters, Immaculate Conception had suffered financially since the decline in federal funding a decade earlier.Footnote 67 Catholic leaders and tribal members convinced federal officials to issue contracts to Stephan Mission and seven other Catholic missions for fiscal year 1905. Tribal signatures on the petition secured a contract for sixty-five Crow Creek students worth over seven thousand dollars.Footnote 68
Still, activists in Indian Country were no more united than were progressives in the rest of the country. Many Crow Creek residents agreed on the significance of education, but divided on the idea of using tribal funds for a single educational institution, in this case the Catholic mission school. By June 1904, some tribal members signed a petition asserting that the work of “devoted Fathers and Sisters has been of the greatest benefit to us and our children, and we most earnestly desire to have them continue among us.” Signers of this petition, many of whom either attended the mission or had relative who did, asked the commissioner to make “use of our funds, a sufficient amount to pay for the care and education of all our children who may attend said mission.”Footnote 69 Others, particularly on the southern side of the reservation, disagreed. In fact, more than one hundred tribal members signed an opposite petition. “We are not Roman Catholics,” the opposing petition noted, “we most strongly object to the use of our share of tribal funds for the support of Roman Catholic schools.”Footnote 70 Crow Creek divisions on this issue persisted into future cycles of petition signing, with both sides revealing active political action campaigns. Despite this resistance, Mission supporters gathered enough signatures for thousands of dollars per year to support the Catholic mission school.
With the death of White Ghost in 1905, community leadership spread to other tribal elders blended in with a new generation of leaders. While other tribes like the Cheyenne and Arapahos followed a model of successive generations of chiefs following prior generations, in this case Crow Creek opted for an integrated model of leadership.Footnote 71 When they held council in the winter of 1908, for instance, they selected four delegates with distinct experiences to send to Washington, DC. White Ghost's brother D. K. How, a former store owner, and their cousin Wizi, both in their seventies, had served as tribal judges at Crow Creek. Bear Ghost (Mato Wanaġi), in his fifties, was the son of a former band leader, had served as a tribal judge, and was recognized as a traditional leader. Joe Irving, who had studied at Hampton, was in his thirties and worked as an agency employee. Decades later, Irving served on the Crow Creek delegation to the 1934 Plains Indian Council that met to discuss varied dimensions of John Collier's Indian Reorganization Act.Footnote 72
Federal officials attempted to discourage Indian delegations from coming to Washington, DC, but Indian political leaders were not easily dissuaded. Commissioners informed the Indian agent that “there is nothing they [tribal members] could say in personal conference with the commissioner which could not just as well be reduced to writing and sent here.”Footnote 73 At Crow Creek, however, the community followed the advice that Bull Ghost (Tatanka Wanaġi) gave them decades earlier that it was best to negotiate with federal officials in the nation's capital. “When I was in Washington,” Bull Ghost stated in 1889, he learned “when any of you wants to lay a good foundation for your people you come to this house.” With experience of revised treaties and other agreements he noted that “the most uncertain work among the Indians is to do this kind of work among the Indians, out in the Indian country.”Footnote 74 Following a similar protocol, the Crows, Cheyennes, Arapahos, and many other tribes sent multiple delegations to Washington in the early 1900s.Footnote 75 Lessons of the past may have suggested that federal officials often broke treaties made in the West, or the perception that their prior problems with Washington came from miscommunication, and thus direct conversation with federal leaders would serve them better.
In 1909, three delegates made plans to go to Washington, DC.Footnote 76 The council again selected Bear Ghost, in addition to two other younger men, Thomas Tuttle and Levi Big Eagle. Each had significant experiences working in their own community and working with American leaders. Tuttle had worked his way up through the agency bureaucracy from agency herder to the better-paid position of issue clerk, and Levi Big Eagle had also worked at the agency and held a prominent position in the local chapter of the YMCA.Footnote 77 Both had attended Hampton Institute for several years, worked in tribal political circles, and thus were well versed in American and Crow Creek cultural traditions. Without initial support by federal officials, they followed their tribal council's authorization to travel and embarked on the trip to the nation's capital.Footnote 78 Ultimately, the commissioner of Indian Affairs agreed to support the delegation, and, perhaps even more significant as a political outcome, the commissioner recognized “the council of Indians of the Crow Creek Reservation” who had authorized the delegation.Footnote 79
By the second decade of the century, descendants and relatives of White Ghost and Drifting Goose's bands had worked together in varied capacities on political matters and in agency work for more than a decade. While non-Indians still held many top agency positions, nearly twenty tribal members (and five from other Indian communities) worked at the Fort Thompson agency. Thomas Tuttle, as noted earlier, had worked closely with White Ghost as an interpreter during negotiations for the 1889 Sioux Act. By 1911, he was a forty-three-year-old husband and father of a seven-year-old boy, and the highest paid tribal member at Crow Creek.Footnote 80 Thirty-year-old Smith K. Bear also worked at the agency. He was a descendant of John K. Bear, the creator of the winter count pertaining to the Drifting Goose band and Crow Creek community.Footnote 81 Through experience and family relations, these men and others worked within the system while also passing on their people's history to provide a solid cultural context for political actions.Footnote 82
Tribal members also had an impact on an emerging reservation justice system. While the federal Major Crimes Act (1885) placed seven major crimes in Indian Country under federal jurisdiction, tribal members were in leadership positions to influence sociocultural dynamics at Crow Creek.Footnote 83 By 1911, seven served as police officers at Crow Creek. For Frank Black and Henry Little Eagle, law enforcement followed several years away at boarding school and prior work at the agency.Footnote 84 They exercised their influence through action and selective inaction. With tribal dances continuing through the twentieth century at Crow Creek, it is clear that enforcement of government assimilation programs remained limited. Other tribal members, typically elders, served as judges who heard civil cases and dispensed justice within their community. By 1911, a seventy-one-year-old Two Heart (formerly a tribal police officer), and sixty-one-year-old Shoots the Enemy (a survivor of the Battle of Whitestone Hill) had been serving as tribal judges for about a decade.Footnote 85
These members of the Drifting Goose and White Ghost bands were held in high regard not only by Crow Creek residents, but also the federal agent. More than tolerated, federal officials praised them as “very intelligent and very well intentioned” as well as “thoroughly acquainted with the different members of the tribe living today and those who have lived in the past.”Footnote 86 Being part of the federal Indian system, however, did not mean abdicating their interest and engagement in tribal matters. At the same time that tribal elders served in key agency positions, they participated in tribal business on delegations to Washington in 1910.Footnote 87
While members of Drifting Goose's band, White Ghost's people, and other relatives came together in common cause, generational divides did arise during these transformational times. For instance, federal officials had authorized allotments for women at Cheyenne River, Pine Ridge, and Standing Rock by 1907, but Crow Creek women had not been included. When a 1911 tribal council discussed the rights of women to unallotted and unreserved lands at Crow Creek, support divided generationally. Older members were mainly opposed, but more than thirty younger members were enough to support “opening of their surplus lands” of nearly twenty thousand acres of unallotted and unreserved lands to women who had not been provided for in the past.Footnote 88
In addition to internal community complications, Native people grappled with how they fit into an American identity in the years before World War I. At the same time that federal officials seemed to encourage Indian people to participate in American society, they considered Indians to be a people set apart. Consequently, Crow Creek tribal members had to navigate between mixed messages from federal officials. When the Rodman Wanamaker Expedition of Citizenship traveled its clockwise circle of a nationwide tour country in 1913, it planned to stop in Chamberlain and head up to the Crow Creek Reservation to cultivate patriotism in Indian Country. Tribal members were encouraged to attend and witness the playing of a recorded message from the president and the commissioner of Indian Affairs, the hoisting of an American flag to the tune of tribal drums, and tribal signatures to a “Declaration of Allegiance of the North American Indian.”Footnote 89 Interestingly, while inviting political support that might lead toward equality, the Indian office also encouraged people to “appear in their native costume.”Footnote 90
Tribal members incorporated certain American traditions into their worldview, but continued to chart their own political courses. Crow Creek leaders gathered at Walking Warrior's Hall along Elm Creek, southeast of the agency as winter began in 1913 to prepare to send another delegation to Washington, DC. The council appointed political activist Homer Clark to inform the Crow Creek superintendent about their intentions.Footnote 91 “We wish to send a delegation to Washington, D.C., sometime after Jan 1, 1914, to look after business connected with this Lower Yanktonai Sioux Tribe,” they had stated, and “we may send 1, 2, or 3 members, we have not decided how many yet.”Footnote 92 Clark asserted that their delegates wished to address several individual land claims, but they were not so much asking permission as confirming the process for securing financial support for their travel from their tribal trust funds.Footnote 93 Decades before the Indian New Deal, tribal councils saw themselves as significant political entities that acted on their own volition.
Similar to other progressive organizations that appealed to the federal government for rights of groups of people, tribal leaders sought assistance beyond individual interests. Tribal leaders pressed for their common rights as a tribe within the new political system, even as federal officials focused on assimilation and the breakup of tribal communities. “It is none of the business of the TRIBE if one or more members failed to receive what you might regard as their rights,” the superintendent replied, “You should learn that it is the policy to make all these matters individual instead of taking up the business with the tribe, where only individuals are affected.” Ultimately, the superintendent discouraged the delegation, but if they insisted on coming to the nation's capital, he asserted, they needed to be sure to have enough funds to pay for their travel expenses in both directions.Footnote 94 In turning to federal officials as groups, tribal councils asserted the reality that the decades-long federal assimilation efforts at promoting individualism remained incomplete.
By April 1917, Indian and non-Indian progressives had turned their attention to the war in Europe. Crow Creek leaders held dances that fall to support the war effort that attracted people from many parts of the reservation. Despite years of federal efforts to eliminate tribal practices, dance traditions persisted at Crow Creek and other parts of Indian Country.Footnote 95 In March 1918, Bear Ghost informed the superintendent that he was a member of the expanding American Red Cross and planned to hold monthly dances for the benefit of that organization.Footnote 96 In fact, by that point, the Bear Ghost Dance Hall had already contributed several donations totaling nearly two hundred dollars to Crow Creek Superintendent W. F. Haygood. In a letter to the commissioner, the superintendent presented such gatherings on reservation land as excuses for permission to practice outlawed traditions. “Subterfuge used under the guise of Patriotism and working for the Red Cross,” Haygood asserted, “was only too apparent.”Footnote 97
At the same time that they were raising money for the U.S. war effort, Crow Creek leaders joined forces with leaders of other bands of the Oceti Sakowin in 1917 to promote a land claims process that would last for decades. Less than two weeks after President Wilson declared war on Germany, Crow Creek hosted representatives from the six western Sioux reservations (and their historic allies the Northern Cheyennes and Arapahos) to confer on the Black Hills land case. Consistent with a culture that tolerated separate agendas within a broader alliance system, tribal leaders discussed strategy and conducted research in preparation to challenge U.S. rights to their historic homelands. Recognizing the significance of historical evidence, they took testimony from twenty Lakota elders engaged in nineteenth-century treaty negotiations to preserve their words. These statements would serve as evidence in the 1923 suit filed with the U.S. Court of Claims and for proposed House and Senate bills to settle the Black Hills case.Footnote 98
Crow Creek members cleverly navigated the tribal and American worlds through the first decades of the twentieth century. Through active political engagement tribal leaders helped to bridge the gap between tribal political systems of the pre-reservation era and the post-World War II era of federally recognized tribal governments. Like the Navajos, Crow Creek leaders selectively turned to Christian religious as allies to promote their own agenda, and like the Crows they supported schools to educate their youth to better prepare them to serve their people in the future.Footnote 99 Similar to Ojibwes at Mille Lacs, they met with federal officials about land policies, sought the removal of squatters, and prompted concessions from representatives of the federal government.Footnote 100 And, like the Cheyennes and Arapaho, the Crows, and other tribes they presented their agendas and spoke back to power as political delegations to Washington, DC.Footnote 101
Tribal members had knit together distinct bands into a Crow Creek political system with certain immediate and long-term results for the reservation community, distinct bands, and their Oceti Sakowin kin across the Northern Plains. As they had since 1880s, the council of fifty met regularly to address the needs of the people while smaller groups addressed other particular issues.Footnote 102 Their political actions led to several immediate results during the Progressive Era. Reservation leaders gained financially in renegotiating particular treaty elements, raised the price of leasing agreements, argued for funds to support education, and even removed a corrupt agent by the early years of the twentieth century. Other results followed in succeeding decades. Progressive Era leaders passed on political strategies to their children that would not necessarily prevent federal programs like Pick-Sloan Missouri Basin Program, but provide them with tools to respond and reap the best compensation possible when that program flooded their best agricultural lands along the Missouri River after World War II.Footnote 103 Crow Creek representatives also participated in the Black Hills land case that led to a major 1980 Supreme Court decision for financial compensation (though not land return) for federal land seizure. And members of the Drifting Goose band asserted their land claims along the James River enough that South Dakota came to at least recognize their historical land claims. In fact, in 2011, South Dakota officials even named the bridge over the James River the Chief Drifting Goose Memorial Bridge.Footnote 104
When Crow Creek leaders gathered in 1909, they were building on their political traditions of the pre-reservation era and laying a foundation for which they could prepare for their future. They selected individuals with varied political, cultural, and economic experiences: Levi Big Eagle served as the vice president of the committee of fifty, Bear Ghost ran a prominent dance hall, and Thomas Tuttle had risen to the highest ranking tribal employee at the agency. When these men traveled to Washington, DC, they carried distinct life experiences and represented a broad range of tribal interests. In the crucible of these dramatic decades, they were three of many American Indian political leaders who attended council sessions, met with federal officials, signed petitions, and served on delegations. Like others from different tribal communities, they helped to transform political traditions, and shaped the future of Native political action at home and with federal officials in Washington, DC, into the twenty-first century. Their actions would serve as examples and inspire others to continue to assert their cultural distinctiveness, retain and create new kinship relations, and challenge American systems to promote opportunities for their children. Those who occupied the Bureau of Indian Affairs Building (1972), pressed cultural reparations leading to the establishment of the Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act (1990), attended the opening of the National Museum of the American Indian (2004), finally secured a settlement in the Eloise Cobell (Blackfeet) Individual Indian Money (IIM) case (2010), or camp at Standing Rock in the winter of 2016–17 followed in the traditions of their Progressive Era predecessors.
