In my 2014 treatise on Global Health Law, I broadly defined global health law as the use of “hard” and “soft” law — as well as good governance — to shape norms, processes, and institutions to attain the highest attainable standard of physical and mental health for the world’s population. Normatively, the field of global health law seeks innovative ways to mobilize resources, set priorities, coordinate activities, monitor progress, create incentives, and ensure accountability among a proliferation of actors. The value of social justice infuses the field, striving for health equity, with a particular concern for the world’s most disadvantaged people.
In the aftermath of the COVID-19 pandemic, it has become even clearer to me that justice is the north star of the field. In the decade since the first edition of Global Health Law was published, the world has moved incrementally towards justice, at least by one basic metric: life expectancy has edged up globally, with more rapid gains in low- than high-income countries. 1 Recent scientific advances could lead to major progress against diseases burdening lower-income countries, such as malaria, tuberculosis, and HIV/AIDS. This modest progress sits alongside legal achievements, including the adoption of amendments to the International Health Regulation (2005) (IHR) at the 2024 World Health Assembly, initiation of an intergovernmental process to negotiate a new Pandemic Agreement, stronger commitments under the Paris Agreement on the climate crisis, and more countries codifying the right to health in their laws and constitutions.
But to look around the world, global health with justice still seems a distant dream. Despite progress, health gaps between people in rich and poor countries remain shocking and unconscionable — as do health inequities within countries.Reference Ferreira 2 As I write, more than one hundred children in a single internally displaced persons camp in Darfur die every day — starving to death, dying from malnutrition and lack of health care, perishing due to unsanitary, inhuman living conditions — below the public’s gaze,Reference Friedman and Heffernan 3 emblematic of the desperation inflicting millions who are experiencing armed conflicts and fleeing from them. And the existential crises we face — from food insecurity and climate change to animal health and antimicrobial resistance — all place vastly disproportionate burdens on the world’s poor and most vulnerable.
The pandemic gave rare political and public salience to profound health injustices — from vast injustices in access to lifesaving drugs and vaccines to gaping disparities in morbidity and mortality based on income, race, and national origin — and the Trump administration’s “America First” approach to global affairs have placed us in a perilous moment. And yet, the past decade has evinced some glimmers of hope — real steps that could chip away at health inequities. How should global health law evolve to enhance equity, justice, and solidarity? How can we ensure that scientific advances will fairly benefit everyone? And how can we address the underlying social, economic, political, commercial, and environmental determinants of health?
Global Health Law: A Brief History
To understand global health law as a field of study and practice, we need to contemplate its origins. No history of global health law can be told without the singular importance of the World Health Organization (WHO). The WHO is the world’s health leader, with the expertise, legitimacy, and authority to coordinate global health activities. The organization was preceded in the 19th and 20th centuries by a series of International Sanitary Conferences, the Pan American Sanitary Bureau, the Paris-based Office International d’Hygiène Publique, and the Geneva-based League of Nations Health Organization.Reference Gostin and Meier 4 Yet these early conferences and organizations were concerned almost exclusively with the international spread of infectious diseases. The WHO’s constitutional mandate is more robust and far-reaching:
“Health is a state of complete physical, mental and social well-being and not merely the absence of disease or infirmity. The enjoyment of the highest attainable standard of health is one of the fundamental rights of every human being without distinction of race, religion, political belief, economic or social condition.”
From the ashes of World War II, the WHO was established as the United Nation’s first specialized agency. The Organization’s groundbreaking Constitution recognizes a right to health, since adopted in international and regional treaties and national constitutions,Reference Heymann, Sprague and Raub 5 and gives the WHO vast normative powers to adopt conventions and regulations, as well as non-binding instruments which it has deployed on topics ranging from environmental health, infectious diseases, and medicines, to tobacco, alcohol, unhealthy foods, and breastmilk substitutes. Its crowning achievement, the eradication of smallpox, saved countless lives from an ancient scourge. And it has made significant advancements in health system strengthening, universal health coverage, and addressing the social determinants of health.
While the United Nations (UN) and several of its agencies have adopted health policies, the WHO remains the directing and coordinating authority on international health work. However, the organization has faced considerable challenges throughout its long history, from financial crises and scrutiny over its handling of several public health emergencies to political shifts hostile to multilateral institutions, all of which have threatened its legitimacy, financing, and ability to develop and implement global health law.Reference Gostin and Meier 6
Evolving Themes in Global Health Law
The field of global health law is currently undergoing a major transition, from the threats to solidarity and multilateralism to the urgent demands of equity and the poly-crises that pose deeply consequential risks to the public’s health, including climate change, antimicrobial resistance, and conflict. How can we build innovative global norms and robust institutions that fulfill the WHO’s fundamental aspiration of the right to health for all?
The Health of Multilateralism
Soon after Harvard University Press published the first edition of Global Health Law, the UN adopted the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) — unprecedented in their scope and ambition — incorporating wide-ranging health targets and guided by a shared commitment “to ensure that no one is left behind.” The international community lauded the SDGs as historic, a milestone for multilateral cooperation.
But ever since, the health of multilateralism itself has floundered against the rising tide of nationalism, geopolitical rivalries, and widening trust deficits — trust in science, trust in institutions, and trust among nations, especially between the Global North and South.
Failures of international cooperation had become evident with multiple health emergencies, including H1N1 Influenza (2009–2010), Ebola in West Africa (2014–2016), Zika (2016), Ebola in the Democratic Republic of the Congo (DRC) (2019–2020), and mpox (2022–2023).
By 2024, the WHO declared yet a second global emergency for mpox, which had spread from the DRC to multiple African nations. For the first time ever, Africa CDC declared a Public Health Emergency of Continental Security, urging the world to make available ten million vaccine doses. And yet, as illustrated in the New York Times,Reference Gostin, Halabi and Finch 7 there was a cavernous mismatch between where mpox cases were raging and where vaccine supplies are manufactured and stored — a story of injustice that has long been staring us in the face.
Yet no health emergency challenged multilateral cooperation quite like the COVID-19 pandemic. Nationalist leaders disregarded IHR norms and WHO recommendations, for example by imposing travel restrictions targeted at countries in Southern Africa.Reference Meier 8 The origins of SARS-CoV-2 proved highly contentious.Reference Gostin 9 The WHO struggled to secure equity in affordable access to lifesaving medical countermeasures, as states hoarded vaccines, antivirals, and the materials needed to make them.Reference Gostin 10 Countries even went so far as to impose export restrictions on supplies needed to prevent and treat COVID-19.
In 2020, the Trump administration suspended financial support and initiated a process to withdraw the US from WHO membership, marking the nadir in the US relationship with the WHO. While President Biden reversed this decision upon taking office, the pandemic highlighted a decades-long trend of inadequate global health financing. For years, nations had starved the WHO of the funding necessary to carry out its mandate.Reference Finch 11 By 2022, because of states’ resistance to increase their own assessed contributions, the WHO had full control over only 17% of its budget. 12 This made it reliant on voluntary earmarked contributions from a small set of wealthy donors, skewing priorities, eroding trust, and creating “pockets of poverty” in global health policy. 13 Donor fatigue and fragmentation in the financing architecture also plagued the funding environment, impacting health programming in low-income countries the most. WHO’s funding situation only worsened in 2025, when the second Trump administration announced its intent to withdraw from WHO and immediately stopped all funding for the organization.
If multilateral cooperation for health is to be revived, there must be a groundswell of solidarity, financing, and trust. The adoption of amendments to the IHR in 2024 is a sign that cooperation for health remains possible. And there remains hope that WHO member states will finalize a new Pandemic Agreement. But these achievements alone will not be sufficient to confront the marked health challenges of a changing world. From tackling climate change and antimicrobial resistance to injuries, non-communicable diseases, and mental health, multilateral cooperation is essential.
Scientific Wonders and the Demands of Equity
Even before the COVID-19 pandemic, the prevailing narrative on global equity was one of deep injustice. A 2020 Credit Suisse Global Wealth report revealed that the top one percent of households globally own 43 percent of all personal wealth, while the bottom 50 percent own only one percent. 14 And by 2024 the richest among us (the wealthiest 1.5%) held nearly half (47.5%) of global wealth. 15
The pandemic itself spurred a further breakdown of solidarity with dramatic disparities in access to lifesaving medical resources between rich and poor countries.Reference Gostin 16 Yet, if we respond wisely to this injustice, it could be the last time we are forced to tolerate the intolerable. Rather than lower-income countries having to rely on donations or unfair contracts for vaccines and medicines, they should be empowered with the tools to create these medical technologies themselves. We need a new model to facilitate rapid, universal, and equitable access to new medical technologies: sufficient manufacturing capacity in all regions, with a diversity in the number and type of manufacturers. In other words, the very enterprise of global health assistance must transform from a model based on charity and philanthropy to one based on self-reliance and human rights.
The world is on the verge of wondrous scientific achievements. We witnessed the magic of science during the pandemic with the development of COVID-19 vaccines in under a year. Landmark scientific medical achievements have also included two malaria vaccines, one of which is manufactured by India’s Serum Institute with a capacity of at least 100 million doses annually; it is inexpensive and has a remarkable 80% efficacy.Reference Gallagher 17 A twice-yearly injectable medicine that can prevent HIV/AIDS had a stunning 100% efficacy in a clinical trial.Reference Brangham and Merchant 18 New technologies like mRNA and the genome-editing tool CRISPR show promise for a host of new vaccines and therapeutics. Artificial intelligence, combined with massive computing power and immense virtual libraries, shows huge promise in advancing drug discovery, including rapid evaluation of drug candidates and optimizing drug structure and dosing.Reference Paul 19
A legal framework should be established to enable diversified manufacturing of health technologies, encompassing sustainable investments, open knowledge, transfer of technology and know-how, intellectual property waivers, licensing, and tiered pricing. Government research funding and purchasing agreements could be key leverage points with private companies. We must no longer allow the pace of scientific advancement to outstrip our capacities to share the benefits equitably.
Global Health Law for Global Poly-Crises
Global health law has an indispensable role in addressing overlapping and rising crises of pandemics, antimicrobial resistance, climate change, mass migration, and armed conflict, each with its own devastating impacts on human health and development. The COVID-19 pandemic, like zoonotic disease epidemics before it, demonstrated the inextricable link between human health, and the health of animals and of our shared planet. Eight public health emergencies of international concern have been declared since the IHR’s 2005 overhaul, revealing major shortcomings in the IHR and states’ compliance with them, and the alarming frequency and geographic diversity of emerging health threats. Each made plain the need for stronger governance.
Like the emergence of zoonotic diseases, human behaviors drive the growth of antimicrobial resistance, making dangerous pathogens even harder to defeat. Multisectoral policies through WHO, the Food and Agriculture Organization, and the UN’s animal health and environmental agencies monitor the threat and encourage antimicrobial stewardship, but it is apparent that binding rules will be needed to protect future generations from resistant pathogens and to develop new antimicrobial drugs.
Similarly, the myriad health impacts of climate change are already manifesting faster than states’ ability to adapt and respond. It is a deep injustice that countries that have contributed least to climate change will bear the brunt of its impacts, with the low-lying Small Island Developing States at risk of becoming entirely unlivable. Climate change-induced extreme weather events, including fires, heatwaves, floods, and droughts, pose direct risks to human health and life, including food insecurity.Reference Pörtner 20
The impacts of climate change on ecosystems give rise to food- and water-borne diseases, alter the geography of vector-borne diseases, and enable zoonotic spillover that drives health emergencies. And the impacts of climate change on the livelihoods, economies, and cultural practices of Indigenous peoples are a human tragedy.Reference Reyes-García 21 With the 2015 adoption of the Paris Agreement, momentum has grown for effective climate change mitigation, adaptation, and financing, but too slowly. The world is expected to reach 1.5ºC of warming in the near term, to disastrous effect. 22 Without more coordinated action and enforcement, our world will get hotter, sicker, and more unjust. Far more ambitious global health law for a changing climate cannot wait.
Armed conflicts resulting in tens, even hundreds of thousands of deaths have marked the past decade accompanied by flagrant disregard for international humanitarian law, intended to protect civilians, humanitarian workers, and other noncombatants. Health workers and facilities have been targeted again and again. Through conflicts’ intergenerational impacts on health, the harms of fighting will extend long after active fighting has ended. And mass migration — millions fleeing unlivable climates, famine, and armed conflicts — will bring untold misery, suffering, and deaths.
In an increasingly fractured world, global health law must meet the challenges posed by multiple, interconnected drivers of ill health. It is no longer possible to think of global health law as confined to WHO and other related institutions, international law, and governance. This is going to take a more holistic approach across societal sectors.
Innovations for Human Rights, Equity, and Empowerment
From the full gamut of human rights violations during the COVID-19 pandemic to the plethora of attacks on civilians during armed conflictsReference Daniele 23 and flagrant violations of the rights of forced migrants, 24 capped by the Trump administration upending US foreign assistance, this has in many ways been a difficult decade for health and human rights. Yet there have been noteworthy human rights developments, compassing at least three major categories. The first is equity itself, with many innovations inspired by the COVID-19 pandemic: the creation of the flawed but groundbreaking Access to COVID-19 Tools Accelerator and its vaccine arm COVAX,Reference Usher 25 a deeply belated waiver for certain Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS) intellectual property protections for COVID-19 vaccines,Reference Fischer 26 the development of the Principles and Guidelines on Human Rights and Public Health Emergencies, 27 and the inclusion of equity in the 2024 IHR amendments. But potentially the most significant development had come earlier with the adoption of the SDGs, with health targets for universal access to clean water, sanitation, food, and housing. 28 And universal health coverage became — at least until COVID-19 — the centerpiece of the global health agenda. 29 We may still have another truly remarkable turn of events in 2025, with the adoption of the first new legally binding international health instrument in a generation — a Pandemic Treaty.
A second set of reforms centered on the environment. The UN General Assembly recognized the right to a clean, healthy, and sustainable environment. 30 National courts have used constitutional environmental and other rights to require more forceful action to reduce greenhouse gas emissions,Reference Guruparan and Moynihan 31 while the European Court of Human Rights held that Switzerland had failed to take adequate steps to reduce greenhouse gas emissions.Reference Quell and Casert 32
The third set of reforms has moved economic, social, and cultural rights, towards equal footing with civil and political rights,Reference Massa, Villouta and Ferrada 33 including with the UN Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights beginning to adjudicate individual complaints of rights violations, a power its civil and political rights counterpart has had for decades.
What the next decade needs are forceful actions toward fulfilling human rights and incorporating equity with soaring ambition. Closely linked to equity is good governance, including inclusive participation, civil society engagement, transparency, setting benchmarks and monitoring progress, and genuine accountability. Governance rooted in these principles would advance health rights for everyone, while making global institutions stronger.
Several potential new instruments have the requisite boldness. One would target the shameful inadequacy of financing for UN humanitarian appeals, left tens of billions of dollars short in recent years, with growing need driven by the poly-crises discussed above. 34 A new UN framework could be adopted to fully finance UN humanitarian response plans. A model exists. UN member state contributions to the organization’s peacekeeping budget are mandatory and based on assessment levels established by the General Assembly. Why not the same for UN humanitarian appeals? 35
Another ambitious instrument would be a human rights treaty aimed at achieving national and global health equity. We have urged and continue to urge the adoption of a Framework Convention on Global Health that would revolve around the principles of equality, participation, and accountability, infusing them into financing decisions and operating across sectors and actors, locally to globally. Its power would be rooted in its precise standards, specific mechanisms, and an innovative compliance regime,Reference Gostin and Friedman 36 enabling the SDGs’ promises of equality and universality to be backed by clearly defined obligations.
Additional rights reforms could be promulgated through national laws and policies. Health equity programs of action could establish a detailed roadmap towards health equity, embracing each marginalized population and spanning the range of health determinants.Reference Friedman 37 Countries could make right to health impact assessments a regular practice.Reference Gostin and Friedman 38 And community-led monitoring of health services should be widely supported through national and global health programs. This approach entails community groups gathering qualitative and quantitative health information locally and using their findings for evidence-based advocacy. 39
Finally, to combine the local and global a new global human rights institution — a Right to Health Capacity Fund, that finances NGO advocacy on health rights — could be created. Civic action has unmatched potential — witness, for instance, the HIV movement and the movement of people with disabilities — and could lead to policies and funding that improve health across the full spectrum of diseases and health threats. Funding for health rights advocacy is severely limited. This fund could change that.Reference Friedman 40
Conclusion
In COVID-19, we saw the unrealized potential of global health law — international regulations that were not heeded and an innovative mechanism for equitable vaccine distribution that fell short. Creating solutions to the many daunting global health challenges, with a constant commitment to human rights and dignity, and tackling the epidemic of health inequity itself, are the pressing tasks before us. With the vastness of the deepening challenges, the stakes are only growing. We will need to replace dangerous nationalism with solidarity. We must prove up to the task.
Acknowledgments
The author is grateful to Alexandra Finch, Eric A. Friedman, and Adi Radhakrishnan for their research and assistance in developing this text, and to Jack Ross-Pilkington for assistance with the citations.
