This book is a welcome addition to the history of the Ottoman Empire and modern Turkey. Carter Findley, an eminent scholar who specializes in late Ottoman history, expands beyond his field of expertise to address continuity between the Late Ottoman and republican periods. The study commences with the modernizing reforms of Sultan Selim III, who acceded to the Ottoman throne in 1789, and continues up to the contemporary period. As such, it follows the historiographical tradition of locating Turkish republican history in its Ottoman roots, a tradition first developed by scholars such as Niyazi Berkes and Erik Jan Zürcher.
The first chapter of the book focuses on the Ottoman return to centralization during the reign of Sultan Selim III. Chapters 2 and 3 cover the 19th-century Tanzimat period and the reign of Sultan Abdülhamid II (1876–1909), respectively. Chapter 4 focuses on the Young Turk era (1908–18) and concludes with the end of the Turkish national struggle (1909–22). Chapter 5 covers the early republican period, while Chapter 6 deals with Turkey's transition to multiparty politics, the coming to power of the Democrat Party, and the ensuing Second Republic (1961–80). Chapter 7, the final chapter, positions Turkey in relation to the world, arguing that after three years of military rule (1980–83), a new constitution established Turkey's Third Republic. The periodization that Findley employs in the text is thus conventionally predicated on significant transformations in formal political rule during the late Ottoman and republican eras.
Nevertheless, Findley employs the concepts of Islam, nationalism, and modernity as analytical tools to move beyond his conventional focus on political rule. Stating that the “political, economic and demographic side of social history has been relatively well studied,” Findley concentrates on “the quality-of-life side of social history and cultural history” (p. 2). In practice, this novel focus leads Findley to place at the end of each chapter “essays exploring [particular contemporaneous] writers’ worlds,” through which he captures cultural production and offers interpretations of political, social, and economic issues (p. 3). These writers are, chronologically, Sadık Rifat Pasha, Namık Kemal, Ahmet Midhat and Fatma Aliye, Ziya Gökalp and Halide Edip (Adıvar), Ahmet Hamdi Tanpınar, Orhan Kemal, Adalet Ağaoğlu, and finally Orhan Pamuk. In an effort to overcome the inherent secular biases in scholarship, Findley also discusses three religious movements that were influential throughout Ottoman and republican history, specifically those established by Mevlana Halid (1766–1827), Said-i Nursi (1873–1960), and Fethullah Gülen (b. 1938). These two emphases, namely, bringing contemporary writers and three religious movements into an exhaustive survey of Ottoman and Turkish history, make Findley's book stand out from existing studies. Yet Findley does not fully explain how and why he selected these writers and movement leaders instead of others.
It is evident throughout the text that Findley not only engages Ottoman and Turkish sources but also attempts to maintain a dialogue with prominent critical social science and humanities scholars such as Partha Chatterjee, Jens Hannsen, Ussama Makdisi, and Edward Said as well as significant scholars of Arab and Iranian history, including Beth Baron, Kenneth Cuno, Beshara Doumani, Khaled Fahmy, and Nikki Keddie. His engagement with critical history scholarship, however, remains limited; even though Findley references and ties in their work, he does not take the next step of applying their theoretical insights in order to reinterpret Ottoman and Turkish history. Nevertheless, Findley's thirty-page bibliography of published sources (pp. 457–87) covers all of the significant works on Ottoman and Turkish history, making the book a vital reference for all scholars interested in this part of the world.
Findley's lucid writing style in this monumental book enables all those interested in the Middle East in general and Turkey in particular not only to learn the pertinent historical facts and processes but also to study the historical transformation of the late Ottoman Empire and republican Turkey over more than two centuries. The single point of contention this reviewer has with this most impressive work concerns Findley's use of theory. Although Findley engages literary works not only of men but also of women (a most welcome addition), not only of secular but also of religious leaders, he is not able to present a fully novel, theoretically informed approach to Ottoman and republican history, one that would truly engage critical social science scholarship. That task might have to be left to the next generation of scholars.
