I anticipated I would enjoy reading through this book; however, this proved a very brief exercise indeed, and I was left with mixed views, frankly. Its title suggests a work on the inner ear, and the back cover expands this to ‘the inner ear and lateral skull base’, an ambitious undertaking for such an ultra-thin textbook. Indeed, the book tries to develop its scope even further, and the result can be very sketchy.
At 88 pages of text (several of which are actually completely blank pages between chapters), the book is brief for any atlas. As such, it must be judged on the quality of the illustrations even more than that of the text. This varies, and many pictures reflect the fact that they have been amassed over decades of clinical practice. Most teachers of our generation will have acquired thousands of 35-mm transparency slides which, while once the gold standard, do not compare with modern digital photography.
Copying X-ray films usually resulted in green tints for Kodak Ektachrome or blue for Tungsten film, as seen in so many illustrations here. Only a ‘Heath Robinson’ set-up, with a monopod, a bottomless black plastic flower pot, two L-shaped black cards and a shutter cable to allow a 14-second exposure, could then produce true monochrome slides from Kodak reversal film. A simple slide digitiser in one's office, however painfully slow, allows conversion and editing of one's collection and makes for a very worthwhile exercise.
There is a special need for magnification and zoom for so many of the pictures reproduced here. Tiny views of demineralisation in cochlear otosclerosis, an occluded posterior canal in BPPV or a hypoplastic VIIIth cranial nerve are frankly unconvincing.
There are some good illustrations, such as otoscopic endoscopy of glomus vagale and facial nerve schwannoma, and a CT of a duplicate facial nerve, but none of these relate to the inner ear. All imaging is accompanied by pathology photomicrographs of variable quality. The majority are poorly labelled and badly illuminated, with a dark yellow cast – again, a film effect that modern digital processing can correct.
There are 13 chapters. These start with ‘Temporal bone tumours’, concentrating almost exclusively on metastatic malignancy and telling us the obvious, that these are ‘rarely diagnosed when asymptomatic’. A cholesteatoma chapter tends to concentrate on intracranial rather than intralabyrinthine complications. There is a superb sequence of CTs demonstrating presentation and skilled management of a petrous apex cyst, let down by poor reproduction. A lengthy chapter on inner ear malformations reflects the topic's recent importance in implantation. In contrast, a very brief chapter on sudden deafness is almost exclusively illustrated with normal cochlear anatomy, and there is no coverage of the commonest, idiopathic, presentation. Trauma to the inner ear is well done, otosclerosis less so, missing the opportunity to show decent imaging of otic capsule demineralisation. It is almost a relief to note that superior canal dehiscence is ignored for once! Presbyacusis and Ménière's disease rate three and two pages respectively, oddly, considering the title of the book. This contrasts with the attention given to meningiomas and various such tumours in three subsequent chapters. Illustrations tend to reflect the bizarre in a personal collection, rather than the typical appearance. Thus, there is an acoustic neuroma in the middle ear, a meningioma eroding the floor of the external canal, and a facial neuroma labelled as occurring in the left ear on endoscopy, which looks suspiciously like a right ear. Two CTs of a trigeminal nerve schwannoma nicely illustrate the green of Ektachrome and, beneath, the blue of Tungsten film which once dogged all collectors of 35-mm radiology slides.
This book must compete in a market-place offering many superbly illustrated atlases and countless textbooks on otology and neurotology. For the former, quality of illustration, at a reasonable price, is everything; for the latter, the target audience must be clearly identified. This book left me unconvinced and disappointed.
