This beautifully written study offers a survey and synthesis of the documentary evidence for scribae from the early Roman Republic to the late Empire. As Benjamin Hartmann acknowledges from the outset, this is soil well tilled by previous generations of scholars: the cataloguing of known scribae was a preoccupation of Theodor Mommsen; in the subsequent century, Nicholas Purcell convincingly outlined the responsibilities and attractions of the scribal office, as well as the preconceptions and prejudices that greeted those who inhabited it. Roman scribes, defined by their proximity to powerful men and their receipt of payment for services, were scapegoated by an anxious elite distrustful of upward mobility and eager to blame crooked subordinates for the moral failings of their ‘betters’. H.'s contribution is a readable and engaging overview of the scribal profession that sets individual scribae known from epigraphic and literary sources within the contours of their cultural and social contexts.
In H.'s Introduction, an imaginative retelling of an episode in the life of the earliest scribe known from literature (Cn. Flavius) dovetails into a discussion of how Pierre Bourdieu's notion of ‘cultural capital’ can elucidate the particular advantages that scribes, often low-born, had within a rigidly hierarchical society. H. carefully distinguishes between the post of scriba librarius, a functionary role accessible to the formerly enslaved, and that of scriba, which often recruited from the same milieu but could encompass politically sensitive and well-remunerated labour. Here and in ch. 2 (‘The Human Archive’), H. is well attuned to the complex issue of literacy in the ancient world. How would a scribe's proficiency in ‘reading, writing, and reckoning’ (4) stack up against that of supervisors as well as class peers? H. offers a range of possibilities, appropriate to the nuances and lacunae of the surviving evidence (13–27). Ultimately, H. emphasises that it was not chiefly their skills that so empowered Roman scribes, but their access to protected information.
Very welcome is H.'s engagement with visual representations of scribes, most notably the Ara degli Scribi, discovered in 2000, which depicts the deceased seated at a table with large-format tabulae ceratae. Ch. 2 explores what such monuments tell us about the materiality and lived experience of scribal work. H. gestures towards current debates surrounding the location and function of the tabularium in Rome when noting that, due to the sheer scale of the tablets, it was not merely the secrecy but also the mechanics of scribal labour that would have called for an expansive, enclosed workspace (38–41).
Ch. 3 (‘The Attendant’) moves beyond the literacy and core tasks of scribae to consider milestones in the scribal career path, including the assumption of posts under magistrates and the organisation of scribes into associations called decuriae. H. theorises plausibly that membership in a decuria was permanent and that the triennial induction (lectio) counteracted attrition rates due to death and desertion (71). Throughout the chapter, H. helpfully draws attention to gaps in our understanding of how the scribal profession was structured and posits thought-provoking hypotheses.
H. shifts his focus, in ch. 4 (‘The Profiteer’), from the lives of Roman scribes to the negative stereotypes they confronted. Here, H. could have productively situated his analyses of Cicero's Verrines within a broader discussion of literary sources. Particularly compelling in this regard is Vitruvius’ De architectura and its send-up of the profligate scriba Faberius, who may have helped Mark Antony make insertions into Caesar's unpublished papers and later aided Dolabella in embezzling money from the treasury of Ops. The tantalising possibility, deduced from remarks in De architectura itself, that Vitruvius was Julius Caesar's scriba armamentarius likewise goes unmentioned in H.'s book.
Vitruvius and Horace are the two Roman scribes who bequeathed to history not just their names, but also entire literary works. Both authors glancingly allude to their own (probable) scribal professions and caricature scribae designated by name and profession. That so little is made of these authors by H. is a puzzle. It likewise detracts from the authority of the book that so much recent scholarship on perceptions of scribae goes uncited (e.g. E. Gowers, ClassAnt 22 (2003), 55–92; M. F. Nichols in L. B. T. Houghton and M. Wyke (eds.), Perceptions of Horace (2009), 109–22; E. Gowers in G. Urso (ed.), Ordine e sovversione nel mondo greco e romano (2009), 301–16; M. F. Nichols, Author and Audience in Vitruvius’ De architectura (2017) 42–82, 163–79). Ch. 5 (‘The Parvenu’) devotes attention to Horace's scribal career, mentioned in preceding chapters, but much of the complexity of Horace's authorial persona and the generic concerns that shape his satires are left underexplored.
Ch. 6 (‘The Roman Scriba Reimagined’) considers the legacy of the scribe as ‘the embodiment of trustworthiness … the guardian of the written’ in Late Antiquity (149). Such positive portrayals reinforce H.'s argument that the virulent condemnation of scribal perfidy in the literary record is an index of the profession's close association with fides. Closing his book with an appendix of known Roman scribae (150–75), H. furthers the essential irony of the scribal profession: while the tabulae they so jealously guarded are lost, the scribae left behind their own names as an indelible feature of the Roman historical record.
