Iranian Jewry has been the subject of relatively substantial research compared to many other religious minorities in Iran. However, the conversion of many Iranian Jews in the 19th and 20th centuries to the Bahaʾi faith has received insufficient attention. Amanat's Jewish Identities in Iran sheds much light on this phenomenon. Based on the author's doctoral dissertation, the book traces trends and patterns related to Jewish assimilation and participation in Iranian public life and to their conversion to the Bahaʾi faith as well as to Islam. It also makes an important contribution toward a better understanding of Bahaʾis and the Bahaʾi faith in Iran more broadly. Until a decade or so ago, many studies of modern Iran failed to pay attention to the role of Bahaʾis in areas such as education, health, women's rights, and constitutionalism. Such research was hindered in part by the fact that Iranian governments from the Qajars to the present have to a greater or lesser degree persecuted the Bahaʾis and restricted them from openly practicing their religion.
Following a review of the existing literature, Amanat provides a detailed account of the social history of the Jews in Iran from pre-Islamic times to the early Qajar period, citing various cases of conversion to Islam. He then discusses the emergence of the trend to convert to the Bahaʾi faith, and analyzes the reasons behind it, focusing on the cases of three Jewish families who converted in the latter part of the 19th century. While conversion to Shiʿi Islam—the majority religion in Iran—might be easily understandable, the main question of the book is why members of an already persecuted religious minority (Jews) chose to join a new religion (the Bahaʾi faith) that was subject to even harsher persecution. In other words, why did Iranian Jews not seek the relative security of conversion to Shiʿi Islam?
Existing scholarship on Iranian Jews has posited a number of possible reasons for their attraction to the Bahaʾi faith, including its cosmopolitanism, its support for religious tolerance and human equality, its acceptance of Moses's revelation, and its lack of religious hierarchy, as well as the absence of a version of “reform Judaism” in Iran that might have offered an alternative. While accepting some of these reasons, Amanat argues that these conversions should be seen as part of the larger processes of change, reform, and national integration in Iran since the beginning of the 19th century. The appearance of a new faith that promised tolerance and equality—especially at a time of high messianic expectations among the majority Shiʿi population a millennium after the disappearance of the Twelfth Imam—inspired a sense of optimism among Jews, who had suffered centuries of discrimination and prejudice. The Bahaʾi belief in progressive revelation enabled Jews to convert to a new faith without having to refute their former religious identity; instead, they could negotiate a new identity that not only allowed but also recognized their former revelations. Moreover, conversion to the Bahaʾi faith offered Iranian Jews an opportunity to leave their ghettos and assimilate into a wider socioreligious circle. In spite of harsh persecution, the Bahaʾi faith was growing rapidly throughout Iran.
There were undoubtedly different reasons for why Jews converted to the Bahaʾi faith, and Amanat explores them persuasively. He draws on a wide range of primary sources written by Bahaʾis and non-Bahaʾis, mainly in Persian and English, including memoirs, chronicles, unpublished manuscripts, and some of the Bahaʾi holy writings. Amanat also makes use of studies on the religious, social, political, and economic aspects of Iran during the 19th and early 20th centuries, as well as those on Bahaʾi and Jewish life. Some additional sources might have enriched the book further, including a more extensive use of sources in Hebrew, newspapers of the Iranian Jewish community (especially Shalom, ha-Geulah, and ha-Chayim), archives of the Alliance Israélite Universelle, and the annual reports of the Anglo-Jewish Association.
The book's endnotes are efficiently and clearly presented, not only providing references to sources and further readings but also explaining terms and offering short biographical notes on the main characters in the book. This work is to be recommended to all scholars of modern Iran, especially those interested in social history, the later Qajar and early Pahlavi periods, and the history of religious minorities, conversion, and identity.
