The public finances of the ancient city state, Rome being no exception in this regard, were characterized by the absence of ordinary direct taxes imposed on the citizens. Every city state was expected to live off revenues deriving from its own lands whereas the imposition of direct annual taxes was accepted in wartime only when ordinary public revenues were insufficient to meet the costs of war (cf. Claude Nicolet, Tributum. Recherches sur la fiscalité directe sous la république romaine (1976), 1–15). In Rome, the so-called tributum was an example of an extraordinary tax imposed on the citizenry in case of war. After 167 B.C. Rome ceased to impose tributum on its own citizens since the revenues pouring in from the provinces and from other sources made it possible to exonerate the Roman citizenry from this particular fiscal burden (cf. Nicolet, op. cit., 16–55). However, other taxes continued to exist or were invented to meet public expenses especially for military purposes, including a number of indirect ones. In his monograph, a modified version of his 2008 dissertation, Sven Günther of the Johannes Gutenberg-Universität Mainz offers a detailed study as well as an overview of indirect taxes in Rome in the period from Augustus to Diocletian.
As to taxonomy, G. prefers to classify the various taxes, duties etc. of the Roman Empire according to whether they were levied on the basis of a census list or not. The Roman concept of state finances implied that this was a decisive criterion when dealing with state revenue. The taxes examined by G. were not based on a census list, but levied on the value of the object involved in certain transactions occurring in Roman society, e.g. the manumission of a slave. In G.'s terminology such taxes are referred to as indirect. One should note that this approach results in a selection of taxes some of which may be considered to be direct by scholars using other criteria. In his often quoted work on the ‘direkten Staatsabgaben’ Lutz Neesen, for instance, includes the vicesima hereditatium and the vicesima libertatis using a modern definition characterizing a tax as being direct when it is collected from the same persons as will have to bear the burden ultimately (cf. Lutz Neesen, Untersuchungen zu den direkten Staatsabgaben der römischen Kaiserzeit (27 v. Chr.-284 n. Chr.) (1980), 135–42). Furthermore, G. excludes portorium arguing that it should be classified as ‘eine indirekte Abgabe’ rather than ‘eine indirekte Steuer’ (2).
The main part of G.'s monograph consists of four chapters each devoted to one of the four most important indirect taxes of the Roman Empire: vicesima hereditatium (five per cent tax on inheritances), vicesima libertatis vel manumissionum (five per cent tax on the manumission of slaves), centesima rerum venalium (probably one per cent tax on auctions), and quinta et vicesima venalium mancipiorum (four per cent tax on the sale of slaves). Of these, the vicesima hereditatium (23–94) receives the most thorough analysis by far. In each chapter G. scrutinizes topics such as chronology, development, arrangement, organization, administration and regulation of the tax in question. In doing so he uses the full spectrum of sources available including epigraphic material — by nature always problematic, alas.
G. has written a highly commendable book offering a judicious treatment of an important source of revenue for Rome. Reviewing existing scholarship he argues convincingly (8–14), in my opinion, that a modern all-encompassing study of the indirect taxes of Rome is needed although many contributions concerning various aspects of this topic have been made in the course of time. Since to a great extent G. discusses sources afresh and reviews previous scholarly contributions, his work will be a convenient starting point for anyone interested in the indirect taxes of Rome whether or not one agrees with G. in every single detail.
