In his introduction to this collection of essays, Derek Penslar articulates the concerns that drive his work to create an intellectual world in which Israeli history can be put in conversation with a broader and more varied set of questions than have often been posed. Although some of these essays have been published previously (in part or more completely), the guiding argument for assembling them in one place is Penslar's belief in “the need to study Israeli history within multiple and overlapping comparative frameworks” (p. 4). Thus the essays, organized in four sections, all contribute to this effort to construct a variety of comparative frameworks for locating aspects of Israeli history.
The first section on writing Israeli history directly addresses historiographical questions. Here Penslar devotes two essays to a critical discussion of what has been labeled the “new history” but that Penslar sees as revisionist in its comparability to works challenging earlier histories of the Cold War in the United States. Penslar recognizes the significance of these studies, largely based on archival research, that have often made evident the inaccuracy of earlier narratives. At the same time he points to the context in which this history was written as critical to understanding its impact. He then goes on to discuss more current developments, elaborating on work that has been done and suggesting areas that remain understudied.
These two essays are particularly useful for providing succinct evaluations that allow the reader both an introduction to the subject and ample references for further exploration. The section ends with an essay that is both much more specific in focus and somewhat more provocative in its argument. Here the author examines alternative interpretations of Theodor Herzl's relatively limited writings on the subject of Palestinian Arabs, particularly those of one diary entry in 1895. His analysis concludes with a call to “responsible historians of Zionism and Israel” to directly confront sensitive issues and with a critique of analyses that too readily present Herzl's prejudices as “merely products of his age” (p. 61).
The second section, which comprises three essays, is at once the most challenging and the one most likely to evoke debate. Here Penslar takes on three subjects of particular current meaning and emotion (“Is Israel a Jewish State?” “Is Zionism a colonial movement?” “Antisemites on Zionism: From indifference to obsession”), striving to elucidate the historiography as well as to offer his own analyses. The first of these chapter titles can be read in a number of ways, but here it constitutes an argument for integrating the study of the Zionist project and its realization into broader Jewish history, recognizing that emphasis on difference has at times interfered with recognition of the ways in which the historical and contemporary relationships between Israel and the Diaspora can be described as “relatively smooth continuities” (p. 65). This section as a whole is characterized by wide-ranging arguments supported by a breadth of evidence extending from detailed knowledge of the literature on Jewish and Israeli history to materials on the study of anticolonialism and the history of European anti-Semitism. In the final essay, the author makes an argument for the recognition of historical differences between the European case and the emergence of modern anti-Semitism in the Middle East. In keeping with the overall focus of this collection, these chapters offer a variety of comparative frameworks, provoking thought and encouraging new questions.
The third and fourth parts are less wide ranging and offer studies more specific to the study of Israeli history as integrated with aspects of modern Jewish social and cultural developments. Interesting in themselves, these pieces also encourage further research into areas not as well covered as political history.
This is a book that will appeal most obviously to those with interests in Israeli history, but it is a collection that raises historiographical questions of significance to Middle East historians more broadly, particularly those studying the history of Palestine and/or the Arab–Israeli conflict. Penslar's nuanced discussions of topics subject to heated debate and his comfort with ranging across the boundaries of European and Middle Eastern histories create a thoughtful case for the value of recasting assumptions and reconsidering existing frameworks.
