Only a truly dedicated historian with the passion and patience for minute details, including those details which are found scattered in space and time, could write such a book. By organizing and interpreting such details, J. Calvitt Clarke III has rendered outstanding service to those of us who, for personal or professional reasons, are interested in Japan's relations with Ethiopia. While Ethiopia had had longstanding, and at times intimate, diplomatic relations with the United States after World War II, Ethio-Japanese relations had been eventful before World War II. But there was a gaping hole about the latter in the scholarship until now. This book is the first and fullest account of Ethio-Japanese relations before World War II.
Clarke III starts out with the discourse about the notion of ‘the yellow peril’, the genealogy of the idea, and moves on to the history of Japan's ‘colonial’ ambitions in Africa and how, among other things, Europe's changing attitudes towards Japan crushed those ambitions from the outset. What follows is a general discussion of the dilemmas of modernization Ethiopia had faced and how it generally resolved them as illustrated by the struggle that ensued between Ethiopia's ‘Japanizers’ and ‘traditionalists’ in the 1920s and 1930s. The author then casts the major characters in Ethiopia who were to play a central role in the debates about whether Japan could serve as a model for Ethiopia's modernization, drawing in passing a useful comparison, including in the appendix, between the constitution of Meiji Japan (1889) and Ethiopia's first constitution (1931). Clarke III finds a ‘close’ resemblance between the two. It is remarkable to discover in this book that Ethiopia's approach to modernization resembled that of Japan to some extent. Both Ethiopia and Japan showed readiness to adapt different systems of organization and thought from abroad in their respective efforts to modernize their societies. Both countries put emphasis on the positive role of education in social transformation. We also learn that although Emperor Haile Selassie was committed to Ethiopia's modernization, he was unwilling to devolve power as Emperor Meiji had done in Japan. Haile Selassie sought to perpetrate himself as ‘absolute monarch’. The question is whether this divergence explains the failure of Ethiopia and success of Japan. This, of course, is an intriguing issue, which is worth exploring more fully in its own right.
Half-way through the book we are treated to the visit of Ethiopia's foreign minister Heruy Welde Sellase to Japan from November to December 1931. Sellase later authored a book in Amharic about what he called Great Japan, which was subsequently translated into Japanese and was published in Tokyo as Dai Nihon in 1934.
The same portion of the book includes critical reviews of the myth and reality of Japan's interest in Ethiopia. This is followed by a closer examination of the changing contours of the relationship between Italy, Russia, Japan, and China − again in the context of Ethio-Japanese relations. The gripping story of a ‘royal wedding’ between an Ethiopian and a Japanese and the various reactions to it in different quarters in both countries are then dissected piece by piece.
The contending theories about political and military ties between Japan and Ethiopia are closely examined in Chapter 8 against the background of Italy's impending assault on the East African country, the support for Ethiopia among the Japanese at the grassroots level, and the 1934 visit by Ethiopia's first ‘consular secretary’ to Japan, Dabba Birrou.
The last chapter of the book is concerned with the official and unofficial positions of Japan vis-à-vis the Italian invasion and subsequent occupation of Ethiopia in 1935. The reactions generated by Italy's actions in different segments of Japanese society are also carefully outlined. As part of the conclusion about Japan's official position, the author says: ‘Japan has chosen an opportunistic policy toward the so-called Italo-Ethiopian war, sometimes favoring Italy, sometimes Ethiopia’ (p. 162).
One of the unique features of the book is that it integrates a variety of issues relating to Ethio-Japanese relations in the 1920s and 1930s and treats them in a manner which is both engaging and stimulating, significantly raising in the process the level of discourse in this field.
Of course, the book is not flawless. To start with the title of the book, Alliance of the Colored Peoples, is somewhat misleading because there is no indication, except for some anecdotal statements, of sustained discourse either in Ethiopia or in Japan about such alliance. If anything the generalization we could draw from this book is that the driving force of Ethio-Japanese relations was more complex and that it was not solely, or even primarily, based on ‘pigmentational solidarity’.
Another flaw is that major events in the book are generally related only by the month and date of their occurrence, with the year rarely mentioned. This approach probably sprang out of the confidence the author placed in his readers’ capacity to know which events took place in which years. But the fact is that this system of dating makes the task of reading cumbersome at best, especially given the density of the book. Also there is no indication in the book as to whether or not the author had visited Ethiopia and consulted Amharic archives there. Instead, it was implied that he had not. If so, the question becomes if he was able to travel to Rome, Tokyo, and Washington for archival research, why was he unable to go to Ethiopia to do the same? Surely, language could be a barrier for the author in Ethiopia (if he does not speak Amharic), but still he could have found some way for dealing with that challenge. After all the central issues in some of the chapters of the book included the discourse which had taken place among Ethiopian elites in one of the oldest newspapers in the country. Last but not least, J. Calvitt Clarke III uncritically repeats Jeanne Pierre-Lehman's familiar but logically untenable assertion (p. 5) that Japan's victory over Russia (in 1905) inspired Ethiopia's victory over Italy (in 1896). If this issue was tangential to the subject under discussion one could have simply ignored it as a minor distraction − but it is not. That said, however, the book is still a most welcome analysis of the history of relations between Ethiopia and Japan before World War II. J. Calvitt Clarke III'sAlliance of the Colored Peoples (2011) does for Ethio-Japanese relations before World War II what Theodore Vestal's The Lion of Judah in the New World (2011) does for Ethio-American relations after World War II.
