Thomas Cromwell has been more spoken of than rigorously studied since Geoffrey Elton completed his studies on the Henrician minister's career in the 1970s. On the five hundredth anniversary of the accession of that prince he so faithfully served, Cromwell is back in focus. J. Patrick Coby offers a new take on a man who has been alternately praised and reviled as the architect of a Tudor revolution in government. Few academics are more qualified than Professor Coby to make such an examination: his previous work on Machiavelli and the Reformation Parliament gives him unique qualifications to tackle Cromwell's life story and determine how much Machiavellianism there really was in this legendary statesman's thoughts and actions.
In his preface, Coby notes that Cromwell lacks a current life history and his intention is to provide such a work, aimed at undergraduates. As such, the work is handsomely equipped with an extensive set of glossaries and a thoughtful bibliographic note that, together, provide a sure guide for any reader unfamiliar with the complicated background to Cromwell's life and times. Similarly, the book opens with a sweeping overview of the era in the introductory chapter. Cromwell figures lightly into what is an elegantly written and insightful summary of the major elements—political, religious, and intellectual—of the tumultuous time when Cromwell is credited with creating the concept and framework of the royal supremacy. Even readers who come to the book with a strong grounding in the period will benefit from Coby's lucid overview.
After this opening, Coby takes quite a different tack, moving to more of a biography of the ideas that underlay these political concepts of supremacy found in the works of Marsilius of Padua and Niccolo Machiavelli. Again, this approach is most welcome. Marsilius, a fourteenth-century physician and imperial courtier, ably defended his imperial patron, Ludwig, against his nemesis, Pope John XXII, who withheld his recognition of Ludwig's imperial status. Marsilius went beyond the particulars of Ludwig's case to construct a generic assault on papal supremacy, making a case for the authority of councils within the Christian community. Coby shows readers that this work had useful parallels to the case of sixteenth-century princes, such as Henry, who sought to limit the pope's authority over themselves and their realms. Coby notes that Marsilius can be closely tied to Cromwell on two counts. First, he served as patron to William Marshall, translator of a 1535 English-language edition of Defender of the Peace. Second, and more significantly, Cromwell distributed copies of the translation to his Catholic critics in the expectation that Marsilius's arguments would convince them of the rightness of promoting the king's authority.
After Marsilius, Coby moves on to consider the infamous but slightly less robust links between Cromwell and Machiavelli. As he points out, evidence that Cromwell introduced Machiavelli's The Prince to England comes only from the hostile witness of Reginald Pole who was recounting events, years later and after he had broken with his cousin, Henry VIII, over England's denial of papal supremacy. Pole's antagonism toward Cromwell as the agent of England's break with Rome means that the story might be nothing more than an attempt to blacken Cromwell's reputation. Coby shows that while we can see some plausible parallels between Cromwell's own words and actions and Machiavelli's thought (he outlines elements that could be tied to Cromwell from both from The Prince and The Discourses), still we cannot know this for sure since Cromwell left no works of political theory and few direct statements on his ideology. But he leaves the door open for testing the link between Cromwell and Machiavelli through an examination of Cromwell's life story. This chapter is easily the most valuable contribution in recent years to our understanding of how Cromwell relates to the political theories of the royal supremacy.
Following this rich chapter, the book descends into a more mundane treatment of Cromwell's life story. Coby takes an oblique approach to illustrating how Machiavelli's ideas are seen in Cromwell's actions. Much of the chapters get bogged down in the extensive and exhaustive details of the history of the era. In passing, Coby will end passages with a parenthetical reference to some part of Machiavelli's work, as when he discusses the pardons for clergy and laity passed by parliament in 1531: “this obeisance was not quite in keeping with king-in-parliament constitutionalism, but it was fully in line with Machiavelli's advice on how to dispense benefits—i.e., never in response to demands (Dis, I.32, 38, 51)” (88). More often, the reference baldly follows a description, such as when Coby discusses Cromwell's pursuit of an imperial alliance in 1535 against Henry's own inclination. All the reader sees is a laconic “(contra Dis, III.35)” following Coby's assertion that Cromwell's trouble was the result of pursuing something publicly repudiated by his king (124). These brief references to Machiavelli appear only fleetingly in each chapter (Marsilius of Padua seems entirely absent); the undergraduate audience might have been better served by chapter summaries or more detailed discussions of the citations.
Aside from this, Coby's work in contextualizing the rich and complicated story of Cromwell's life cannot be praised enough. The man who served as Henry's Lord Privy Seal and Vicegerent in Spirituals was a tireless politician and administrator who managed a great part of the royal administration during a critical and epoch-changing decade. Coby ably depicts how Cromwell worked with and against his fellow courtiers, promoting his royal master's interest with great success until his fall from grace in 1540. In the conclusion, Coby essays some broader arguments of his own as he reviews Cromwell's character, reputation, and legacy. Not all are entirely persuasive: he holds that if “Cromwell was a Machiavelli disciple, then it is quite unthinkable that Cromwell also was a true-believing Protestant, or even much of a Christian” (196). But nowhere does he lay out why the two must be antithetical in Cromwell's person. More convincingly, Coby refutes R. B. Merriman's longstanding depiction of Cromwell as a villainous failure, countering with a depiction of Cromwell as a principled statesman ultimately victimized by the mercurial monarch he served.
Thomas Cromwell: Machiavellian Statecraft and the English Reformation will revitalize the study of Cromwell as Henry's minister and as student of Marsilius and Machiavelli. If Coby's book is read in conjunction with The Discourses and The Prince, it will particularly illuminate how political thought and political action were linked in constructing the royal supremacy and the Henrician church.
