Brittney Cooper's brilliant book, Beyond Respectability: The Intellectual Thought of Race Women, makes crucial interventions into the history of black women's intellectual thought by using black women's own words to identify and define their ideas. Whereas men's intellectual thought is often located in their explicitly theoretical texts, black women's knowledge production, Cooper argues, must be gleaned from a wider variety of sources, including “autobiography, novels, news stories, medical records, organizational histories, public speeches, and diary entries” (12). Cooper uses these sources to reveal the intellectual thought of the race women who created, what she terms, the NACW (National Association of Colored Women) “school of racial thought” (17).
Anna Julia Cooper, Fannie Barrier Williams, and Mary Church Terrell represent the main thinkers whom Cooper credits with having created the NACW school of thought. She begins with Anna Julia Cooper's insistence on black women's “undisputed dignity (5) and her articulation of intersectionality in black women's lives, then moves to Williams's use of the term “organized anxiety” to describe how black women eagerly and insistently challenged negative images of themselves, positioning themselves instead as “‘educator[s] of public opinion’” to assert positive ideas about black women in order to achieve social change (19). Anxiety, in this case, must be read more broadly, Brittney Cooper suggests, as “simultaneously an anxiety of adversity and an anxiety of aspiration,” as in “anxious for” a more progressive society (54). She then discusses Terrell's articulation of the concept of “dignified agitation” as a form of “militant racial agitation” (144).
Cooper's book issues a timely challenge to historians’ overreliance on the concept of respectability as the main trope through which to see and understand race women from the 1890s on. It is true that black women's bodies were negatively caricatured in the dominant white society as either overly sexualized or unsexed (as in the “Mammy” stereotype). It is also true that many race women emphasized their respectability, or what they often termed their “dignity,” as a way to assert their own humanity and protect themselves from antiblack racism. But Cooper argues that historians suffer from an overreliance on viewing black women's lives and writings from the perspective of respectability, privacy, and secrecy.
Cooper uses the term “embodied discourse” to define “a form of Black female textual activism wherein race women assertively demand the inclusion of their bodies … in the texts they write and speak” (3). Importantly, even in texts that made gestures toward secrecy, privacy, and dissemblance, black women pointed to their own pain and trauma in a way that called attention to their bodily experiences. They did so in order to “make the world safer for Black women” by “exposing the personal nature of the struggles they experienced,” and thereby asserting their own humanity (9). Beyond that, Cooper argues that black women's embodied discourse enabled them to “mark possibilities and generative tensions that are sites of inspiration and theory production” (8).
In Cooper's deft analysis, Mary Church Terrell emerges as a three-dimensional woman rather than a caricature of the respectable clubwoman. Cooper reconsiders her as “part of a genealogy of Black women's pleasure politics … [and] a theorist of racial resistance and gender progressivism” (29–30). Describing Terrell as the first to express a theory of intersectionality in a memoir that explicitly discussed her social location as a black woman in a white and male-dominated society, Cooper also notes that Terrell's was the first full-length published “public leadership memoir” in what became a traditional form of “political autobiography” for black women who were public intellectuals (58). Perceptively focusing on Terrell's sense of humor, her discussion in her memoir of dating, marriage, and her love of dancing, Cooper persuasively argues that “Terrell's rebellious use of embodied discourse in her political autobiography created a context for her—and us—to think more expansively about how black women used their bodies in mischievous, subversive, and pleasurable ways to achieve both personal and political ends” (75).
Black women intellectuals have had a long tradition, Cooper asserts, of claiming their place in history through a process of “listing” in which they complied lists of prominent or notable black women. She argues: “this intentional calling of names created an intellectual genealogy for race women's work and was a practice of resistance against intellectual erasure” that black women still practice today (26).
Mary Church Terrell, the transgressive woman who enjoyed dancing, her body in motion, serves as a bridge in several ways to Pauli Murray, whose own questioning of her sexuality inspired her to think carefully about the expected “sexual and gender performances” of black women (88). The two women knew each other, with Terrell's decades-long civil rights and feminist activism serving as an inspiration for Murray. In fact, as a law student, Murray participated in a 1944 Howard University student-led protest to try to desegregate Thompson Cafeteria. A few years later, the elderly Terrell took up the fight again and, as Murray noted, “completed the struggle” (86). Murray subsequently pursued and expanded the struggle for gender and racial equality in the decades after Terrell passed away in 1954.
Beyond Respectability is an important book that takes black women seriously as intellectuals. Brittney Cooper's insistence on identifying and celebrating the embodied pleasure politics in black women's embodied discourse is a welcome and timely intervention.
