What would it mean to produce the definitive book on a poetic oeuvre that is broken up into many small pieces, rejoices in paradox, and flaunts its own insubstantiality and lack of sustained focus? The last attempt at a synthetic treatment of Martial's Epigrams was J. P. Sullivan, Martial: The Unexpected Classic (1991). Recent books on Martial — W. Fitzgerald, Martial: The World of the Epigram (2007), and now Rimell's — do not claim to sum him up or cover his entire output. The reason derives at least in part from the putative nature of the work under examination. For R., the essence of Martial's epigrammatic genre resides in the contradictions created by multiple juxtapositions and diverse points of view. Epigram inherently resists summary, since each brief poem interacts in complicated and unpredictable ways with neighbouring poems in the collection, with its intertexts, and with aspects of the social world it represents. R.'s book, in keeping with her view of the dissonant, uneven poetics of epigram, offers no unitary scheme of argument: rather, the book's chapters afford a loose framework for investigating clusters of associated themes and concepts.
Martial's Rome, then, resembles its subject in resisting easy summary, but an approximate characterization of each chapter's nexus of concerns will nonetheless provide a helpful starting point. An introductory chapter outlines R.'s approach, maps out the critical landscape, offers a preview of chapters to come, and includes a brief informational summary of Martial's life and literary output. In ch. 1, ‘Contagion and copyright: the city as text’, the violation of corporeal boundaries, crossing of limina, and touching and contagion amid the turba of Rome are viewed in relation to the workings of miscellany within the epigrammatic collection and the dynamics of plagiarism and literary forgery. Ch. 2, ‘Vigor mortis: living and dying’, argues that Martial's treatment of the themes of life and death relates to epigram's dual status as ephemeral, sub-literary trifle and inscribed, enduring memorial. In this chapter and passim, R. calls attention to Martial's ‘wicked commentary on literary fame’ (2) and rewriting of Augustan literary monumenta.
Ch. 3, ‘Poetic economies: figuring out Martial's maths’, explores Martial's interest in parodoxes of scale and numerical value both in everday urban life (money transactions and gift exchange) and in poetry (metrics, poetic beginnings, numbering of books, the aesthetic tension between tiny distich and imperial cosmos). Ch. 4, ‘Mundus inversus: Martial's Saturnalia’, examines the epigrammatist's explicitly Saturnalian collections — Xenia, Apophoreta, Book 11 — and traces the articulation of Saturnalian poetics throughout his oeuvre. Here R. stresses not only Martial's use of the Saturnalia as emblem of epigram's licentia, but also epigram's under-appreciated tendency to limit and put a damper on Saturnalian fun. In ch. 5, ‘The space of epigram’, R. shows how Martial's restlessly mobile viewpoint and paradoxical manipulations of space and scale destabilize oppositions between Rome and not-Rome, urban and rural, nostos and exile. Especially valuable here is an analysis of Book 12 that takes seriously the book's movement between Rome and Spain as a thematic element rather than a byproduct of its publication history.
Martial's Rome has many merits. Its central insight is the sheer contradictory heterogeneity of Martial's epigrammatic poetry. R. accordingly has little patience for attempts to impose hermeneutic tidiness on Martial's oeuvre. The excellent discussion of book ordering includes a bracing rejection of predictable efforts to make Martial into an architect of a unitary liber on the model of the Augustan poets (12, 22, 49–50). In general, commentary on critical trends tends to be razor-sharp: ‘just as the boom in Ovidian criticism in the 1980s and 1990s coincided, not entirely by accident, with the popular digesting of post-structuralist and post-modernist thought in the humanities, so Martial seems to suit an academe grappling with what comes after the post-modern’ (2). As befits a book intensely aware of its own place in the history of recent critical fads, Martial's Rome offers a highly sophisticated approach to the vexed question of ‘the real’ in Martial's Epigrams, resorting neither to the outdated evasions of persona theory, nor to unfettered textual constructionism. R. complains of ‘classicists’ tendency to do either texts or history, either “intertextuality” or cultural poetics’, whereas Martial's poetry is such that ‘we must talk about the sociality of the poetic book, and the poetics of the textual city’ (13).
A major problem with Martial's Rome is that the interpretations of individual epigrams are highly uneven, and in some cases, unconvincing. The degree of resemblance required to meet the threshold of an ‘allusion’ has always been a thorny methodological question, but too many of the Ovidian allusions cited by R. seem unusually tenuous, and the interpretations questionable (e.g., 92–3, 135–6). It is hard to accept the special significance R. reads into the unremarkable fact that Martial composed the two opening poems of Book 10 in elegiac couplets: ‘suitably, we notice, 10.1 and 10.2 are written in elegiacs, the metre that (especially after Ovid) looks most “bitty” — couplets jigsawed together, each one a lopsided partnership of “the one” and “the other”, hexameter and pentameter, or two hexameters, the second cropped to fit’ (67). A further problem is the book's punishingly difficult prose. R.'s allusive manner will be frustrating if you are not already a specialist in Roman poetry, and, ideally, a specialist in Martial with a minor field in Ovid. Finally, there is a mismatch between the book's title and its content: plenty of epigram, but not as much Rome, empire, and ideology as the title suggests. The term ‘ideology’ is not defined, discussed, or very much used throughout the book. There is little extended discussion of the emperor and his empire, and Rome is typically evoked as a generalized urban environment. Ch. 5 explores the ‘space of epigram’, but discussion of specific urban places and structures, besides the Flavian amphitheatre, is rare.
At some level, Martial's Rome is about the aesthetics of epigram: social and political phenomena are consistently viewed through the prism of epigrammatic aesthetics rather than the other way around. But it appears that there was pressure to make the project more political in emphasis; hence the framing terminology of the title. Despite these reservations, I find much to admire in the book's critical intensity and vigour. It will now be harder to make the usual generalizing statements about Martial, and harder to maintain a reductive view of his poetry. Martial's Rome will be valued at least as much for what it dismantles as for what it creates.
