Despite its brevity in existence, the Qara Khitai empire played a pivotal role in history, albeit largely unknown. Indeed, although it was integral in the demise of one empire (the Seljuk) and its rise in two others (the Khwarazmian and the Mongol), for most historians Qara Khitai has remained shrouded in mystery. In addition, because it existed in Central Asia, neither wholly in the Islamic world nor in the realm of Chinese studies, few scholars have paid it serious attention. Thus, it is fortunate that Michal Biran of Hebrew University, one of the few scholars whose expertise spans both the Islamic and Chinese fields of history, can fill this lacuna.
The volume is divided into two parts, each consisting of six chapters. The first part is a narrative history of Qara Khitai. In this section, Biran examines the political history of the empire from its origins in Yelü Dashi's, the empire's founder, flight from China into Central Asia. Biran argues that the Khitans who fled first to Mongolia and then to present day Kazakhstan and Kirghizstan initially planned to return to China and revive the Liao Empire, which had succumbed to the Jurchen tribes of Manchuria in 1126. Eventually, it became apparent that such a revival was impossible and the Qara Khitai focused it efforts on Central Asia. Ultimately this led to the battle of Qatwân against the Seljuk Sultan Sanjar and his defeat in 1141. Although the impact of the battle outside of Central Asia is well known—the demise of the Seljuk Empire, legends of Prester John, and so forth—it was also critical to the establishment of the Qara Khitai.
Biran does a thorough job in creating a well-written and researched narrative. Indeed, it is one of the few complete narratives in English besides Bartold's classic Turkestan Down to the Mongol Invasion. Not only does her narrative update Bartold's, but she also challenges many of the points raised by Bartold, both analytically and chronologically.
The narrative ends not with the overthrow of the last Gurkhan, the title used by the Qara Khitai, but rather with the arrival of the Mongols and the death of Güchülüg, the Naiman prince who overthrew the Gurkhan in 1219. It is a logical ending as all evidence indicates that Güchülüg had every intention of setting himself up as the new Gurkhan had the Mongols not intervened in the region.
The second section examines aspects of the cultural and institutional history of Qara Khitai. The fourth chapter of the book examines why the Qara Khitai continued to use Chinese features, particularly in the administration of the empire, outside of China and while ruling a non-Chinese population. In this chapter, Biran clearly demonstrates that the Confucian bureaucratic tradition was not a monolithic structure. Indeed, although the Liao and later the Jin adopted aspects of it, the government of north China was considerably different from that of the Song dynasty. Whereas in the south the government was based on the civil service exams and bureaucracy with the emperor ideally serving as the ultimate power, in the northern dynasties the government was still based on the emperor, but his relations with officials were mainly personal rather than bureaucratic. Although Chinese elements were adopted, inner Asian traditions remained very integral to the Liao as well as the Jin. Biran's point comes down to the fact that in order to maintain their legitimacy in the Inner Asian world and to maintain hopes of reviving the Liao dynasty, these “Sino-Khitan” elements had to be maintained.
As with most inner Asian empires, two groups comprise the population: nomadic and sedentary people. In chapter 5, Biran examines the Qara Khitai's relationship with the nomads. The importance of this relationship cannot be overstated because the nomads comprised much of the army. Furthermore, through these ties, the Qara Khitai could exert influence into the steppe, thus furthering their legitimization while also countering that of the Jin.
In the final chapter, Biran examines Islam in Qara Khitai. Although the Mongols are often cited for their religious toleration, they were by no means alone in practicing this policy. Indeed, the Qara Khitai, who practiced Buddhism and their traditional religion, saw the benefit in not interfering in the religious practices of their new subjects, whether nomadic or sedentary. Combined with their practice of maintaining local rulers, the Qara Khitai, although infidels to the Muslim populace, were not viewed as oppressive rulers for most of the empire's existence.
In this chapter Biran also investigates other reasons why the practice of jihad was lax. This is an important question as the Qara Khitai empire brought a large area of dar al-Islām under the rule of infidels, who unlike the various Turkic groups who moved across the Syr Darya in previous decades, had no interest in Islam. This discussion also leads into an interesting discourse on religious undercurrents within the region. In the waning days of the Qara Khitai, religious persecution under Güchülüg, according to many sources, instigated numerous revolts, which led many to welcome the armies of Chinggis (Genghis) Khan. Biran argues that underlying tensions exacerbated the situation and that the rebellion was not necessary for religious reasons. Finally, Biran discusses why the Qara Khitai never adopted Islam and argues convincingly that it is because they maintained their ties to their Sino-Khitan traditions.
The Empire of the Qara Khitai includes four appendices. The first discusses the names Qara Khitai and the Western Liao. The second consists of several very good maps related to the Liao empire, in addition to the regions of the Qara Khitai empire. The third appendix is a series of tables outlining not only the rulers of Qara Khitai but also surrounding dynasties. Finally, there are tables listing the administrative titles used within the empire. This table is of great use considering the variety of sources used in the study. Thus, one has the appropriate title and all of its synonyms.
Biran's work is both original and insightful. Anyone studying Central Asia or inner Asia, or premodern states that deal with borderlands, whether religious or economic, will benefit from this work. It should be an essential addition to any library. Biran's mastery of both the Islamic and Chinese sources, with a large number of Russian and English secondary sources thrown in, makes this a complete and balanced study so that scholar from Islamic, Chinese, or inner Asian studies will not find the work as esoteric as Qara Khitai often seems.
