We have long recognized that the women's movement of the late nineteenth century coincided with a multiplicity of reform movements in the name of the domestic sphere. Through the Women's Christian Temperance Union (WCTU), British and American women took the posture of missionaries as they sought to bring restraint to men's systemic patterns of alcohol use, prostitution, and domestic violence. We know that by the early twentieth century, Frances Willard and the WCTU advanced a sophisticated critique of patriarchy and joined the movements for both women's suffrage and collective bargaining in the United States. However, most of our stories on the rise of the first-wave feminism follow the suffragists, labor activists, libertines, birth control activists, and other “modern” women who opposed patriarchy. Why didn't Christian women reformers play a larger role in the rise of the feminist movement?
In her A New Gospel for Women, Kristin Kobes DuMez begins to address this frequently overlooked question. The book is a rigorous intellectual history of Katharine Bushnell, the woman physician, theologian, and WCTU evangelist. It explores the development of Bushnell's ideas about the sexual double standard, sexuality, empire, patriarchy, and Western Christianity. We learn that many WCTU reformers were serious critics of both patriarchy and Victorian moralities. In fact, in DuMez's reading, despite the fact that Bushnell served the American cultural empire, her work in India and China led her to critique “the fiction of Western moral superiority” and “dismantle the discourse of civilization that had elevated both Christianity and Western culture above all other traditions” (75). The next three chapters delve into Bushnell's exegesis of frequently cited passages on patriarchy and women's submission. Readers consider how and why Bushnell made such scriptural reinterpretations, and why these conclusions sounded radical to many Protestants, but conservative to many other feminists. In sharp contrast to the skeptics (like Elizabeth Cady Stanton) who dominate most of our first-wave feminist history, evangelical feminists accepted the new, fundamentalist defense of the canon and the inerrancy of scriptures. In the final chapters, Bushnell examines why Bushnell's ethics of sexual restraint, coupled with her popular book and correspondence course, God's Word to Women (1921), did not receive a more enthusiastic reception in either the feminist movement or the Protestant churches.
The book's narrative and accessible prose make a clear and convincing case that Bushnell worked tirelessly against the Victorian patriarchy. First, DuMez turns our attention away from tired debates about reform, gender, and colonialism, and proves that the Willard-era WCTU did important, international advocacy against the sexual double standard. Bushnell invested most of her adult life in working to combat the vices of prostitution because she believed that the sex industry celebrated male freedoms at the expense of women. She challenged condescending Victorian elites as she insisted that the so-called fallen women who worked as prostitutes were not inherently dangerous to society. She fought to end laws that tested and penalized only women (not men) for spreading sexually transmitted diseases. And she critiqued the way Western Christianity created the gender norms that oppressed women in Asia.
Second, the book provides a compelling case for how resistance to birth control flowed from feminist convictions. Bushnell believed that sexual “restraint” was the best way to keep men from retaining all effectual power in the home and in society. Contraception, Bushnell believed, reduced the meaningfulness, of sex; it forced a wife into the “humiliating position of a mere ‘vessel,’ to receive the excreta of the male” (174). In the absence of contraception, Bushnell believed, women had more control within courtship and marriage; moreover, men who engaged in extramarital sex took on the same risk as their women partners. DuMez sees Bushnell's advocacy for Christian womanhood and marriage outside of patriarchy as prophetic and subversive, especially for fellow Protestant women.
Finally, DuMez convinces readers that we need to think about reform-minded Protestant women as caught between two movements at the start of the twentieth century: the feminist movement and its celebrated unorthodoxy in the figures of Elizabeth Cady Stanton and Margaret Sanger; and the reform-minded evangelical movement, which was quickly fracturing between fundamentalists and modernists.
Because the social gospel movement collapsed during Bushnell's lifetime, one is less convinced that Bushnell's evangelical feminism had any real hope of building momentum. By the 1920s, only radicals insisted on the value of social equality. Moreover, historian Betty DeBerg suggested that fundamentalists' new endorsement of patriarchy was not incidental to their new insistence on the submission of women.Footnote 1 Rather, the fundamentalist movement was a deliberate response to Christian women reformers like Katharine Bushnell. If this is true, the fundamentalist movement was much more than an obstacle to Bushnell's popularity; it was a deliberate effort to silence her and others like her. Why, then, was Bushnell so faithful to these church communities that sought to silence her? We know that Bushnell abhorred contraception, but why was this disagreement from other first-wave feminists enough of a chasm that she could not align with them in her old age?
One concludes the book unsure if Bushnell ought to be categorized as a feminist at all. The mark of the feminist movement was its willingness to create bonds among women for cross-class solidarity. Yet, despite the fact that Frances Willard and the WCTU army addressed the concerns of working women, we do not see Bushnell taking any stance on lynching, women's labor, child labor, or other working-class concerns. To the contrary, the upper-class, white single woman appeared more comfortable working to reform women, especially in China and India. Her opposition to the sex industry, mandatory screenings, and contraception—despite being transnational concerns—appear to be her primary method of expressing her rejection of patriarchy.
Another reading of Bushnell would characterize her as an elite, single Victorian who did not see the future of upstanding Victorian women tied to that of working-class women. If Bushnell was truly supportive of cross-class solidarity and a future without birth control, why did she not work with Catholic activists like Father John Ryan in defending a family wage?Footnote 2 When we see Bushnell investing more time in reforming poor women than she does in working as their ally, we wonder if Bushnell was truly a nineteenth-century reformer who supported the Victorian racial and class order. Put another way, one is not convinced that Bushnell's opposition to birth control was the most important reason she was rejected by the new feminist movement. What did Bushnell believe about women's wage work, working women's motherhood, socialism, the Great War, women's role in peacemaking, or the League of Nations? DuMez does not address these concerns, so a reader assumes that Bushnell had no interest in the coalition building required to build an expansive, international women's movement.
We need a good deal more research on the role of religion within the development of American feminism. DuMez jumpstarts us with an important discussion on the fact of conservative evangelicals who not only railed against the sex industry, but rejected patriarchy with a “conservative hermeneutic” and original Greek. The book appeals primarily to scholars of conservative evangelicalism and historical theology. But, even if Bushnell's feminism should be widely critiqued, the book should also become part of the canon of biographies of early twentieth-century activists. In order to truly understand the history of women, gender, and reform, we need to know more about the folks like Bushnell who sat on the margins of the feminist movement.
