Despite the divergence in systems in the helping professions, clinical supervision has become the cornerstone of quality improvement in counselling, and remains an essential component in training helping professionals (Lambert & Ogles, Reference Lambert, Ogles and Watkins1997). Clinical supervision is widely accepted as an essential component in high-quality mental health and rehabilitation services (Edwards et al., Reference Edwards, Cooper, Burnard, Hanningan, Adams, Fothergill and Coyle2005; Herbert, Byun, Schultz, Tamez, & Atkinson, Reference Herbert, Byun, Schultz, Tamez and Atkinson2014). As early as 1978, it was observed that clinical supervision was the most important component in the preservice preparation of rehabilitation counsellors (Scofield & Scofield, Reference Scofield and Scofield1978), and continued professional development of practicing professionals (Herbert et al., Reference Herbert, Byun, Schultz, Tamez and Atkinson2014; Maki & Delworth, Reference Maki and Delworth1995; McCarthy, Reference McCarthy2013), and therefore essential for ensuring that quality services are provided to consumers of rehabilitation programmes.
Despite the importance of clinical supervision in doctoral-level training in rehabilitation (Herbert & Bieschke, Reference Herbert and Bieschke2000) and the requirement that rehabilitation counsellor supervisors receive training in supervision (Commission on Rehabilitation Counselor Certification, 2010), actual training in supervision is often limited or nonexistent (Herbert & Richardson, Reference Herbert and Richardson1995; Pearson, Reference Pearson2004). The purpose of this study was to ascertain the current state of clinical supervision in doctoral-level rehabilitation counselling training programmes. This study reviewed ‘supervision’ and ‘clinical supervision’ syllabi from universities that have doctoral-level supervision courses, searching for common themes across syllabi. The research questions were as follows:
1. How many doctoral-level rehabilitation counsellor education programmes offer courses on clinical supervision?
2. What commonalities exist between doctoral level supervision course syllabi across programmes in rehabilitation counselling?
Method
Procedures
Rehabilitation counselling programmes were identified using the National Council on Rehabilitation Education (NCRE) Institutional Membership Directory (National Council on Rehabilitation Education, 2013) (n = 96) and additional programs were identified using the Council on Rehabilitation Education list of accredited graduate programmes (Council on Rehabilitation Education, 2013) (n = 12). Of these, 25 had affiliated Ph.D. programmes. A majority of these programmes were located in the United States, although programmes in Canada and Australia were included in the sample. Recruitment emails were sent to the directors of each of these 25 rehabilitation affiliated Ph.D. programmes. Follow-up emails were sent approximately two weeks later. Lastly, programmes which did not respond were contacted by telephone, to increase response rate. Emails and calls inquired about the provision of a doctoral-level supervision course at the institution and requested a copy of the most recent supervision course syllabus. Among the 25 programmes, 16 programmes (64%) responded to the recruitment contact. 11 of these programmes (69%) reported offering clinical supervision courses and 8 of those 11 programmes (73%) shared their syllabus.
Data Analysis
To analyse the syllabi, each of the four authors individually analysed the rehabilitation counselling supervision syllabi and developed codes that identified themes based on similarity of concepts and frequency in each syllabus across participating programmes. Only items that were similar and appeared more than once were codified. After analysing the syllabi and developing codes separately, the authors convened to discuss the themes as a group. Themes were kept, renamed or discarded based on the consensus of all four authors. In the rare event that themes were not initially the same, the syllabi were revisited and discussed together to achieve consensus.
Results
In response to research question one, how many doctoral-level rehabilitation counsellor education programmes offer courses on clinical supervision, of the 64% (n = 16) of programmes that responded to our initial inquiry, only 11 (69%) offered doctoral-level supervision courses. Using the eight syllabi shared by the programmes (32% of the 25 programmes identified), we analysed their contents to address research question two. In response to this question, what commonalities exist among doctoral-level supervision course syllabi across programmes in rehabilitation counselling, we found five notable connections. Some of the course objectives were similar across syllabi. The most commonly indicated themes (n = 4, 50%) were that students develop a personal supervision philosophy and that students learn to supervise master's students. In a few cases, the syllabi broke the supervision experience into group, live or individual supervision sessions. The acquisition of Skills and Knowledge was indicated in three (38%) of the syllabi used in this study. Other themes included the following: Cultural Differences, Ethics, Roles of Supervisors, the Supervisory Relationship, Evaluation and Research in Supervision. Each of these were indicated in two (25%) of the syllabi analysed. To achieve these objectives, three-fourths of these eight programmes (n = 6, 75%) included experiential training with master's students (the supervised supervision of master's students) as a course assignment, while a paper detailing the student's supervision philosophy was included in five (63%) of the syllabi. One-third (n = 3, 38%) of the syllabi required that students lead a class seminar, and the same number (n = 3, 38%) required that students share a journal article and/or conduct an article critique.
Many of the class topics addressed in the syllabi were similar across institutions. Class time was spent on Ethics (n = 5, 63%), Evaluation of Supervision (n = 5, 63%), Models of Supervision (n = 5, 63%), Understanding the Supervisory Relationship (n = 4, 50%) and Organising the Supervision Experience (n = 4, 50%). Technology, Teaching, Researching, Interventions and Individual Supervision were indicated in two(25%) of the syllabi.
Broadly, six (75%) of the syllabi used Bernard and Goodyear's (Reference Bernard and Goodyear2013) text for the course, and when looking at the syllabi as a whole, only four (50%) of the syllabi mentioned multicultural supervision.
Discussion
Section H of the CRC Code of Professional Ethics for Rehabilitation Counselors (2010) emphasises the need for training in supervision. The themes identified in this study address specific requirements of the Code in the following areas: (1) the ‘acquisition of skills and knowledge’ theme relates to the Code's requirement that rehabilitation counsellor educators be skilled teachers and practitioners (H.6.b); (2) development of a personal philosophy is related to students’ welfare and self-growth experience (H.7.b); (3) the theme on cultural differences addresses the Code's requirement that supervisors attend to the role of cultural diversity; (4) the ‘Ethics’ theme directly relates to Section H.6.d of the Code; (5) the themes of ‘Roles of supervisors’ and ‘Supervisory relationship’ address Section H.3 requiring supervisors to serve as role models; (6) the ‘Evaluation’ theme addresses section H.5a that describes the types of evaluations in which trainees should be subjected to. While the CRCC indicates these requirements are necessary for the development of competent rehabilitation counsellors, not all of these areas are addressed in every syllabus that was reviewed and it is unclear if they are addressed at all in programmes without a supervision class.
The lack of provision of supervision classes at the doctoral level (only 69% in our sample) is disconcerting, given the well-documented importance of supervision in counsellor training (Edwards et al., Reference Edwards, Cooper, Burnard, Hanningan, Adams, Fothergill and Coyle2005; Herbert & Richardson, Reference Herbert and Richardson1995; Lambert & Ogles, Reference Lambert, Ogles and Watkins1997; Maki & Delworth, Reference Maki and Delworth1995; Scofield & Scofield, Reference Scofield and Scofield1978) and in the requirements of the CRC Code of Ethics (Commission on Rehabilitation Counselor Certification, 2010). Similarly, the findings reveal that there is a lack of emphasis on multicultural training in supervision, despite a growing body of evidence about the importance of clinical supervision in multicultural competence (Inman, Meza, Brown, & Hargrove, Reference Inman, Meza, Brown and Hargrove2004; Robinson, Bradley, & Bret Hendricks, Reference Robinson, Bradley and Bret Hendricks2000), the benefits of supervisors' multicultural supervision competence on the development of supervisees' multicultural counselling skills (Pope-Davis, Reynolds, Dings, & Nielson, Reference Pope-Davis, Reynolds, Dings and Nielson1995), and the effect of multicultural competence on supervisory working alliances and supervision satisfaction (Inman, Reference Inman2006).
Recommendations
It is clear that supervision training is an important part of counsellor training (Edwards et al., Reference Edwards, Cooper, Burnard, Hanningan, Adams, Fothergill and Coyle2005; Herbert & Richardson, Reference Herbert and Richardson1995; Lambert & Ogles, Reference Lambert, Ogles and Watkins1997; Maki & Delworth, Reference Maki and Delworth1995; Scofield & Scofield, Reference Scofield and Scofield1978) and a requirement according to the CRC Code of Ethics (Commission on Rehabilitation Counselor Certification, 2010). Given this, we would like to present suggestions for how to train doctoral-level rehabilitation students in supervision.
The Center for Credentialing and Education, affiliated with the National Board for Certified Counselors (NBCC), provides a master's level counsellor supervision credential, the Approved Clinical Supervisor (ACS) (Center for Credentialing and Education, 2015). Requirements to become an ACS include having earned an approved master's degree, having specific licensure or certification as a counsellor, and having either taken a graduate course in counsellor supervision or completed 30 workshop hours that provided training in supervision. Applicants also must have completed 100 hours of supervision and 1,500 hours of counselling after completing their master's degree.
However, for doctoral students completing rehabilitation counsellor education programmes, we propose slightly more stringent requirements. Using information gleaned from the syllabi we studied, we propose the following:
1. Doctoral students should have at least two consecutive courses in clinical supervision.
2. Consistent with ACS standards, doctoral students should accrue at least 100 hours of clinical supervision experience consisting of individual, group and when possible, live supervision.
3. This supervision experience should be supervised by an experienced supervisor.
4. Supervision course content should include but not be limited to topics of ethics, models of supervision, the role of the supervisor and the supervisory relationship, evaluation of supervision, research in supervision, technology in supervision, cross-cultural supervision and organising the supervision experience.
5. Assignments in the supervision course should include but not be limited to the supervision of practicing counsellors or counsellors in training and the development of a supervision philosophy.
While these recommendations are not exhaustive, they provide an initial framework for the provision of doctoral-level supervision training.
Limitations
This study has limited generalisability due to a small sample size, given that only 69% of the programmes contacted responded; we do not know anything about the provision of supervision in 31% of the doctoral-level rehabilitation programmes identified. Additionally, while analysing syllabi is a practical way to identify what students are learning on the topic of clinical supervision, a syllabus does not provide a comprehensive picture of what occurs in the classroom.
Implications for Teaching and Research
Considering these limitations, researchers need to conduct in-depth qualitative research (i.e. interview or case studies) to gain a better understanding of the potential barriers and challenges that may impede training programmes and faculties in providing supervision training to future rehabilitation counsellor educators. Because of the recognition that clinical supervision is an essential component of rehabilitation counsellor educator training (Lambert & Ogles, Reference Lambert, Ogles and Watkins1997), all rehabilitation counselling doctoral programmes should offer courses in clinical supervision. Additionally, multicultural supervision training should be strengthened in the curricula to ensure sound and culturally appropriate services are provided to clients and guarantee the professional development of the trainees. Nevertheless, the findings from this study provide formerly unknown insight into the state of supervision training in rehabilitation counsellor education and can provide a much-needed framework for further research on the topic.
Acknowledgements
This manuscript adheres to the Commission on Rehabilitation Counselor Certification Code of Ethics as well as the American Counseling Association's Code of Ethics regarding research and publication. Given that the study used archival data (syllabi), Institutional Review Board approval was exempt.
Funding
Dr. Pebdani's work on this paper was funded by the U. S. Department of Education, NIDRR Postdoctoral Advanced Rehabilitation Research Training Grant no. H133P080008.
Disclosure of Interests
We have no conflicts of interest to report.
