Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-fvjsw Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T20:04:20.541Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Analogies and differences between the stability of an isolated pancake vortex and a columnar vortex in stratified fluid

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  11 May 2016

Eunok Yim*
Affiliation:
LadHyX, CNRS, École Polytechnique, F-91128 Palaiseau CEDEX, France
Paul Billant
Affiliation:
LadHyX, CNRS, École Polytechnique, F-91128 Palaiseau CEDEX, France
*
†Email address for correspondence: eunok@ladhyx.polytechnique.fr

Abstract

In order to understand the dynamics of pancake shaped vortices in stably stratified fluids, we perform a linear stability analysis of an axisymmetric vortex with Gaussian angular velocity in both the radial and axial directions with an aspect ratio of ${\it\alpha}$ . The results are compared to those for a columnar vortex ( ${\it\alpha}=\infty$ ) in order to identify the instabilities. Centrifugal instability occurs when $\mathscr{R}>c(m)$ where $\mathscr{R}=ReF_{h}^{2}$ is the buoyancy Reynolds number, $F_{h}$ the Froude number, $Re$ the Reynolds number and $c(m)$ a constant which differs for the three unstable azimuthal wavenumbers $m=0,1,2$ . The maximum growth rate depends mostly on $\mathscr{R}$ and is almost independent of the aspect ratio ${\it\alpha}$ . For sufficiently large buoyancy Reynolds number, the axisymmetric mode is the most unstable centrifugal mode whereas for moderate $\mathscr{R}$ , the mode $m=1$ is the most unstable. Shear instability for $m=2$ develops only when $F_{h}\leqslant 0.5{\it\alpha}$ . By considering the characteristics of shear instability for a columnar vortex with the same parameters, this condition is shown to be such that the vortex is taller than the minimum wavelength of shear instability in the columnar case. For larger Froude number $F_{h}\geqslant 1.5{\it\alpha}$ , the isopycnals overturn and gravitational instability can operate. Just below this threshold, the azimuthal wavenumbers $m=1,2,3$ are unstable to baroclinic instability. A simple model shows that baroclinic instability develops only above a critical vertical Froude number $F_{h}/{\it\alpha}$ because of confinement effects.

Information

Type
Papers
Copyright
© 2016 Cambridge University Press 
Figure 0

Table 1.Growth rate for different domain sizes $R_{max}$ and $Z_{max}$ for $m=2$, ${\it\alpha}=0.5$, $F_{h}=0.5$ and $Re=10^{4}$ for mesh sizes $S_{max}=0.075R$ and $S_{min}=0.004R$.

Figure 1

Table 2.Growth rate for different minimum and maximum mesh sizes $S_{min}$ and $S_{max}$ for $m=2$, ${\it\alpha}=0.5$, $F_{h}=0.5$ and $Re=10^{4}$ for $R_{max}=8R$ and $Z_{max}=6{\it\Lambda}$. The number of triangles is also indicated.

Figure 2

Figure 1.Growth rate (${\it\omega}_{i}/{\it\Omega}_{0}$) and frequency (${\it\omega}_{r}/{\it\Omega}_{0}$) spectra for a pancake vortex (${\it\alpha}=1$) (○: for symmetric and   for antisymmetric modes) and for a columnar vortex (${\it\alpha}=\infty$) ( ) for $m=0$, $F_{h}=0.5$, and $Re=10^{4}$. The mode (C,0) corresponds to the most unstable mode of the columnar vortex.

Figure 3

Figure 2.Real part of the radial velocity perturbation Re($u_{r}$) of (a) antisymmetric mode (0,1) and (b) symmetric mode (0,3) of figure 1. The radius $r$ and height $z$ are rescaled with the radius $R$ and half-height ${\it\Lambda}$ of the base vortex, respectively. The dashed line represents the contour where the Rayleigh discriminant ${\it\Phi}$ vanishes. The dotted line indicates the contour where the angular velocity ${\it\Omega}$ of the base vortex is $0.1{\it\Omega}_{0}$.

Figure 4

Figure 3.Contours of ${\it\Phi}/|{\it\Phi}_{min}|$ for ${\it\alpha}=1,F_{h}=0.5$. The regions where ${\it\Phi}$ is negative are shaded. The contour interval is $0.2$.

Figure 5

Figure 4.Growth rate (${\it\omega}_{i}/{\it\Omega}_{0}$) and frequency (${\it\omega}_{r}/{\it\Omega}_{0}$) spectra for a pancake vortex for ${\it\alpha}=0.5$ (○: for symmetric and   for antisymmetric modes) and for a columnar vortex ( ) for $m=1$, $F_{h}=1/3$ and $Re=10^{4}$. The modes (C,1,1) and (C,1,2) correspond to modes of the columnar vortex whose frequencies are the same as the modes (1,1) and (1,5), respectively.

Figure 6

Figure 5.Real part of the radial velocity perturbation Re($u_{r}$) of modes (a) (1,1), (b) (1.5), (c) (1,4) and (d) (1,7) of figure 4. The dotted line indicates the contour where the angular velocity of the base vortex is ${\it\Omega}=0.1{\it\Omega}_{0}$. The dashed line represents the contour where the Rayleigh discriminant ${\it\Phi}$ vanishes.

Figure 7

Figure 6.Comparison between the (a) radial $u_{r}$ and (b) azimuthal $u_{{\it\theta}}$ velocities of the eigenmodes (C,1,1) of columnar (thick grey lines) and (1,1) of pancake vortices (light black lines) in figure 4. ——; real and - - -; imaginary parts.

Figure 8

Figure 7.Same as in figure 6 but for the modes (C,1,2) and (1,5).

Figure 9

Figure 8.Growth rate (${\it\omega}_{i}/{\it\Omega}_{0}$) and frequency (${\it\omega}_{r}/{\it\Omega}_{0}$) spectra for a pancake vortex (${\it\alpha}=1.2$) (○: for symmetric and   for antisymmetric modes) and for a columnar vortex (${\it\alpha}=\infty$) ( ) for $m=2$, $F_{h}=0.5$ and $Re=10^{4}$. The modes (C,2,1) and (C,2,1) correspond to modes of the columnar vortex whose frequencies are the same as the modes (2,1) and (2,3), respectively.

Figure 10

Figure 9.Real part of the radial velocity perturbation Re($u_{r}$) of (a) mode (2,1) and (b) mode (2.3) of figure 8. The dotted line indicates the contour where the angular velocity of the base vortex is ${\it\Omega}=0.1{\it\Omega}_{0}$. The dashed line represents the contour where the Rayleigh discriminant ${\it\Phi}$ vanishes.

Figure 11

Figure 10.Comparison between the (a) radial $u_{r}$ and (b) azimuthal $u_{{\it\theta}}$ velocities of the eigenmodes (C,2,1) of columnar (thick grey lines) and (2,1) of pancake vortices (light black lines) in figure 8. ——; Real and - - -; Imaginary parts.

Figure 12

Figure 11.Same as in figure 10 but for the modes (C,2,2) and (2,3).

Figure 13

Figure 12.(a) Growth rate and (b) frequency of the most unstable modes of each instability type as a function of ${\it\alpha}$, for $F_{h}=0.5$ and $Re=10^{4}$. Centrifugal modes: ; $m=0$, ; $m=1$, ; $m=2$; Shear mode: , $m=2$.

Figure 14

Figure 13.Real part of the radial velocity perturbation Re($u_{r}$) of the most unstable mode for different aspect ratios: centrifugal instability for $m=2$ for (a) ${\it\alpha}=0.5$, (b) ${\it\alpha}=1$, (c) ${\it\alpha}=2$ and shear instability for $m=2$ for (d) ${\it\alpha}=1$, (e) ${\it\alpha}=2$ for $F_{h}=0.5$ and $Re=10^{4}$. The dotted line indicates the contour where the angular velocity of the base vortex is ${\it\Omega}=0.1{\it\Omega}_{0}$. Note that the vertical scale is not scaled by ${\it\Lambda}$ as before but by $R$.

Figure 15

Figure 14.(a) Growth rate and (b) frequency as a function of $F_{h}$, for ${\it\alpha}=1$ and $Re=10^{4}$. Centrifugal modes: ; $m=0$, ; $m=1$, ; $m=2$; shear mode: , $m=2$. The dashed lines show the asymptotic formula (5.8) and (5.9).

Figure 16

Figure 15.Real part of the radial velocity perturbation Re($u_{r}$) of the most unstable modes for different Froude numbers: for $m=1$ for (a) $F_{h}=0.06$, (b) $F_{h}=0.14$ and (c) $F_{h}=0.25$, for centrifugal instability for $m=2$ for (d) $F_{h}=0.4$, (e) $F_{h}=1$, (f) $F_{h}=1.5$ and for shear instability for $m=2$ for (g) $F_{h}=0.1$, (h) $F_{h}=0.25$ and (i) $F_{h}=0.4$ for ${\it\alpha}=1$ and $Re=10^{4}$. The dotted lines indicate the contour where the angular velocity of the base vortex is ${\it\Omega}=0.1{\it\Omega}_{0}$.

Figure 17

Figure 16.(a) Growth rate and (b) frequency as a function of $Re$, for ${\it\alpha}=0.5$ and $F_{h}=0.5$. Centrifugal modes: ; $m=0$, ; $m=1$, ; $m=2$. The dashed lines show the asymptotic formula (5.8) and (5.9).

Figure 18

Figure 17.Real part of the radial velocity perturbation Re($u_{r}$) of the most unstable mode for different Reynolds numbers for $m=1$ for (a) $Re=10^{3}$, (b) $Re=2\times 10^{3}$ and (c) $Re=10^{4}$ and for $m=2$ for (d) $Re=8\times 10^{3}$, (e) $Re=3\times 10^{4}$, (f) $Re=10^{5}$ for ${\it\alpha}=0.5$ and $F_{h}=0.5$. The dotted lines indicate the contour where the angular velocity of the base vortex is ${\it\Omega}=0.1{\it\Omega}_{0}$.

Figure 19

Figure 18.Growth rate (${\it\omega}_{i}/{\it\Omega}_{0}$) and frequency (${\it\omega}_{r}/{\it\Omega}_{0}$) spectra for different Schmidt numbers: (a) $Sc=1$, (b) $Sc=7$ and (c) $Sc=700$ for a pancake vortex for ${\it\alpha}=0.5$ (○: for symmetric and   for antisymmetric modes) and for a columnar vortex ( ) for $m=0$, $F_{h}=0.5$ and $Re=10^{4}$.

Figure 20

Figure 19.Real part of the radial velocity perturbations Re$(u_{r})$ of the mode (a) (0,1) for $Sc=7$ and (b) (0,1) and (c) (0,3) for $Sc=700$ for $m=0,F_{h}=0.5$ and $Re=10^{4}$. The dotted lines indicate the contour where the angular velocity of the base vortex is ${\it\Omega}=0.1{\it\Omega}_{0}$.

Figure 21

Figure 20.Growth rate (${\it\omega}_{i}/{\it\Omega}_{0}$) and frequency (${\it\omega}_{r}/{\it\Omega}_{0}$) spectra for (a) $m=1$, ${\it\alpha}=0.5,F_{h}=1/3,Re=10^{4}$ and (b) $m=2$, ${\it\alpha}=1.2,F_{h}=0.5,Re=10^{4}$ for pancake (discrete symbols) and columnar (continuous lines) vortices for different Schmidt numbers: ○,  : $Sc=1$; ▵,  : $Sc=7$ and ▫,  : $Sc=700$.

Figure 22

Figure 21.Maximum growth rate (a) and corresponding frequency (b) of centrifugal instability as a function of $\mathscr{R}=ReF_{h}^{2}$ for pancake vortices for $m=0$ (red symbols), $m=1$ (blue symbols) and $m=2$ (green symbols) for different control parameters. The grey lines show the theoretical prediction (5.8) and the black lines correspond to numerical results for a columnar vortex for $F_{h}=0.5$ and various $Re$ for $m=0$ (solid lines), $m=1$ (dashed lines) and $m=2$ (dotted lines). The different symbols correspond to: ● various $Re$ for ${\it\alpha}=0.5,F_{h}=0.5$; ▪ various $F_{h}$ for ${\it\alpha}=0.5,Re=10^{4}$; ▲ various $F_{h}$ for ${\it\alpha}=1,Re=10^{4}$; $+$ various $F_{h}$ for ${\it\alpha}=0.5,Re=3\times 10^{4}$; $\times$ various ${\it\alpha}$ for $F_{h}=0.5,Re=10^{4}$; ♦ various ${\it\alpha}$ for $F_{h}=0.5,Re=5\times 10^{4}$.

Figure 23

Figure 22.Growth rate for $m=2$ for a columnar vortex as a function of the rescaled axial wavenumber $kRF_{h}$ (a) for different Froude numbers $F_{h}$ at fixed $Re=10^{4}$: - - $F_{h}=0.1$;   $F_{h}=0.35$; —— $F_{h}=0.5$;  , $F_{h}=1$. (b) For different Reynolds numbers $Re$ at fixed $F_{h}=0.5$:   $Re=2\times 10^{3}$;   $Re=5\times 10^{3}$; —— $Re=10^{4}$.

Figure 24

Figure 23.Growth rate of the most unstable shear (coloured filled symbols) and centrifugal (grey open symbols) modes as a function of $F_{h}/{\it\alpha}$ for different $F_{h}$ for fixed ${\it\alpha}$ and $Re$:  ${\it\alpha}=0.5$, $Re=10^{4}$,   ${\it\alpha}=0.5$, $Re=3\times 10^{4}$;  ${\it\alpha}=1$, $Re=10^{4}$;  ${\it\alpha}=1.2$, $Re=10^{4}$ and   for different ${\it\alpha}$ for $F_{h}=0.5$ and $Re=10^{4}$; ♢ for ${\it\alpha}=0.5$ and constant buoyancy Reynolds number $\mathscr{R}=ReF_{h}^{2}=2.5\times 10^{3}$.

Figure 25

Figure 24.Growth rate as a function of $Re$ for $m=2$ for ${\it\alpha}=1.2$, $F_{h}=0.5$:   most unstable centrifugal mode;  most unstable shear mode.

Figure 26

Figure 25.Growth rate (${\it\omega}_{i}/{\it\Omega}_{0}$) and frequency (${\it\omega}_{r}/{\it\Omega}_{0}$) spectra for a pancake vortex (○: for symmetric and   for antisymmetric modes) for (a) $F_{h}/{\it\alpha}=1.49$ (b) $F_{h}/{\it\alpha}=1.67$ for the same parameters $m=2,{\it\alpha}=0.5$ and $Re=10^{4}$.

Figure 27

Figure 26.Real part of the radial velocity perturbation Re($u_{r}$) for $F_{h}/{\it\alpha}=1.49,m=2,Re=10^{4},{\it\alpha}=0.5$ of the modes: (a) CI (2,2a) (b) BI (2,1a) (c) BI (2,3a) (see figure 25a). The thick dashed line represents the contour where the Rayleigh discriminant ${\it\Phi}$ vanishes. The dotted line indicates the contour where the angular velocity of the base vortex is ${\it\Omega}=0.1{\it\Omega}_{0}$. The potential vorticity radial gradient along isopycnal changes sign on the double dotted dashed lines.

Figure 28

Figure 27.Real part of the radial velocity perturbation Re($u_{r}$) for $F_{h}/{\it\alpha}=1.67,m=2,Re=10^{4},{\it\alpha}=0.5$ of the modes: (a) GI (2,1b), (b) GI (2,5b) and (c) CI (2,8b) (see figure 25b). The thick dashed line represents the contour where the Rayleigh discriminant ${\it\Phi}$ vanishes. The thick dash dotted line delimits the regions where the vertical gradient of total density $\partial {\it\rho}_{t}/\partial z$ is positive. The dotted line indicates the contour where the angular velocity of the base vortex is ${\it\Omega}=0.1{\it\Omega}_{0}$. The potential vorticity radial gradient along isopycnal changes sign on the double dotted dashed lines.

Figure 29

Figure 28.Growth rate of the most unstable BI modes as a function of (a) $F_{h}/{\it\alpha}$: for ${\it\alpha}=0.4$  , ${\it\alpha}=0.5$   and $F_{h}=0.74$  for $Re=2\times 10^{4}$ and (b) as a function of $Re$ for ${\it\alpha}=0.5$ and $F_{h}=0.74$ for different azimuthal wavenumbers:  (red) $m=0$,   (blue) $m=1$,  (green) $m=2$ and  (black) $m=3$.

Figure 30

Figure 29.Isopycnals of the base vortex for ${\it\alpha}=0.5$ for different Froude numbers (a) $F_{h}/{\it\alpha}=1.33$, (b) $F_{h}/{\it\alpha}=1.49$, (c) $F_{h}/{\it\alpha}=1.67$. The vertical gradient of total density $\partial {\it\rho}_{t}/\partial z=0$ vanishes on the thick dashed line - - - (red) in (c). The dotted lines   indicate the contour where the angular velocity of the base vortex is ${\it\Omega}=0.1{\it\Omega}_{0}$. The potential vorticity radial gradient along isopycnals changes sign on the double dotted dashed lines.

Figure 31

Figure 30.Stability diagram for ${\it\alpha}=0.5$ as a function of $Re$ and $F_{h}$ for different azimuthal wavenumber $m$: (a) $m=0$, (b) $m=1$, (c) $m=2$. The symbols indicate: ● centrifugal instability, ▪ shear instability, ▵ baroclinic instability and $\times$ stable. The solid lines represent the thresholds for centrifugal instability: —— $F_{h}^{2}Re=10^{3}$ for $m=0$; $F_{h}^{2}Re=16$ for $m=1$; $F_{h}^{2}Re=1.6\times 10^{3}$ for $m=2$. The dashed line - - - in (c) is a fitted curve to numerical results and shows the threshold for shear instability. (d) Schematic diagram of stability for all azimuthal wavenumbers. —— CI threshold for each $m$; - - - shear instability (SI) threshold for $m=2$;   BI and   GI threshold. Note that for $m=1$, due to the bending mode which is unstable in the long-wavelength limit, the CI threshold is also marked with bending mode (BM).

Figure 32

Figure 31.Growth rate (${\it\omega}_{i}/\tilde{{\it\Omega}}_{0}$) and frequency (${\it\omega}_{r}/\tilde{{\it\Omega}}_{0}$) spectra of the base flow (7.2)–(7.3) for different azimuthal wavenumbers: ▵ $m=1$; ▫ $m=2$; ○ $m=3$; ♢ $m=4$; ▿ $m=5$; $\oplus$ $m=6$. Filled symbols indicate the prediction of (A 15) and open symbols show the numerical results for $\tilde{{\it\Omega}}_{0}=1$, $\tilde{{\it\Omega}}_{1}=0.01$, $R=5$, $H=2$, and $N=1.2$ for $Re=10^{4}$.

Figure 33

Figure 32.(a) Theoretical radial velocity of the displacement mode (${\it\Omega}$) and (b) real part of the radial velocity perturbation Re($u_{r}$) of the displacement mode for $m=1,{\it\alpha}=0.5,F_{h}=0.5$ and $Re=10^{4}$. The dotted line indicates the contour where the angular velocity of the base vortex is ${\it\Omega}=0.1{\it\Omega}_{0}$.