This book's central theme is ‘the relationship between asceticism — especially philosophical asceticism — and the rejection of slavery and of social injustice’ (231). In order to establish this nexus, the book provides rich documentation for the articulation of ideas about slavery from Classical antiquity, through ancient and late antique Judaism, and all the way to the Christian thinkers of the fifth century. This approach of wide chronological scope, that deliberately bridges the gap between Classical and Late Antiquity, and between pagan, Jewish and Christian writers, is the hallmark of the scholarship of Ilaria Ramelli, who is widely recognised for her many publications in this vein.
The culmination of R.’s exposition comes in the last three (of seven) chapters, focusing on Gregory of Nyssa and his intellectual and social context. The Cappadocian's stance on the rejection of slavery as an institution is based on his ideal of social justice, which is rooted in the theological argument that all humans are created by God equal and free. His radical concern for the fate of the poor results in the view that ownership of property and especially personal wealth are tantamount to theft. R. then goes on to elaborate how slavery is treated with either neutral indifference or outright rejection by Christian individuals, ascetic groups of men and women, and large communal monasteries.
R.’s argument begins with the ancient Sophists as the preamble to her discussion of Plato, Aristotle and the Stoics. Plato advocated the equality of all humans. For him, the perfect philosopher is the perfect ascetic who also practises justice. Aristotle, by contrast, postulated that some people are slaves ‘by nature’ (physei), including people of certain ethnicities and women. Epictetus insisted on the shared kinship of all human beings and, like Seneca before him, was aware of the potential role-reversal of slaves and slave owners, as the result of manumission or captivity. The communities of Therapeutae and Essenes based their explicit rejection of slavery on the strong link they established between the equality of all humans and justice.
Two main concepts recur throughout the book: ‘moral slavery’, i.e. the enslavement of the individual to one's passions, an idea present in Plato and followed by the Stoics, and slavery ‘by nature’, Aristotle's view that some people are born to be slaves, a view that did not find many followers among later thinkers. While the notion of slavery by nature was invoked to explain and justify the practice of slavery (called by R. ‘legal’ or ‘juridical’ slavery), the notion of ‘moral slavery’ belongs in the conceptual realm. The concept of slavery was used by different authors in different kinds of literary contexts as an intellectual tool ‘to think with’ about a wide variety of issues, from the control of emotions to relations to the divine. Christian writers articulated ideas of slavery in conjunction with their discussion of God's creation of mankind, human sinfulness and eschatology.
Moral slavery, as R. is keen to point out, can be overcome by the practice of virtue, or, as she calls it, ‘philosophical asceticism’ — as articulated by Plato and the Stoics, who propagate a detachment from worldly values and material possessions and advocate indifference to honour and wealth (often displayed by the ownership of large numbers of slaves). Whenever communities are formed to enact these values and live a life of renunciation of private property combined with practices of physical discipline in food, sex and sleep — whether Neopythagorean, Neoplatonic or indeed the Therapeutae and Essenes described by Philo and Eusebius — R. sees an intricate and essential link between their asceticism and their rejection of slavery.
R.’s work fits into a general trend of scholarship on the pre-modern Euro-mediterranean world in recent decades, that pays greater attention to Late Antiquity and includes Christian authors among historically relevant material. Ch. 7 (‘Nazianzen and Other Late Antique Ascetics: Asceticism and Renunciation of Wealth and Slave Ownership’) offers rich and detailed material on slavery (and its rejection) in the context of Christian asceticism and monasticism, and pursues this aspect in greater depth than previous scholars who have dealt with ideas and practices regarding wealth and poverty, especially Peter Brown (Through the Eye of a Needle (2012), The Ransom of the Soul (2015), Treasure in Heaven: The Holy Poor in Early Christianity (2016), too recent to be considered) and, before him, Evelyne Patlagean (Pauvreté économique et pauvreté sociale à Byzance, 4e–7e siècles (1977), not mentioned). There is also a body of scholarship on asceticism in pagan, Jewish and Christian antiquity, acknowledged by R. through select publications (frequently her own), but I missed references to the important publications of Mariachiara Giorda, Alberto Camplani and Giovianni Filoramo. The historical phenomenon of slavery receives some treatment, inasmuch as R. is careful to establish for each of the authors she discusses whether he owned slaves, and how many (one or two personal household slaves seem acceptable, while a larger number would indicate unnecessary excess). Some of the basic literature on ancient slavery is taken into account, but there is no mention of Geoffrey de Ste. Croix's seminal study on poverty and slavery (The Class Struggle in the Ancient World: From the Archaic Age to the Arab Conquests (1981)) or of Michael McCormick (Origins of the European Economy: Communications and Commerce A.D. 300–900 (2001)), who gives evidence for the slave trade of the early Middle Ages, a phenomenon which R. seems to play down. In other words, this book is not (and does not intend to be) a coherent treatment of slavery as an historical phenomenon.
Instead, the book has merits analogous to an encyclopedia article in the Reallexikon für Antike und Christentum: a series of relevant authors and quotations relating to the theme of slavery across pagan, Jewish and Christian contexts. And it is an impressive array of authors that find coverage: the Sentences of Sextus (which, as R. notes, deserve to be more widely read), Christian authors not only in Greek and Latin, but also in Syriac (Bardaisan, Acts of Thomas, Aphrahat, Jacob of Serug), all the way to Aidan of Iona. This rich material is not easy to handle, however, because it does not follow a strict chronological sequence, regional focus or development of thematic strands. Origen's views, for example, which are often mentioned as an influence on Evagrius Ponticus, Eusebius and the Cappadocians, are treated on 91–2, 129–30 and 207–11. Lactantius and Ambrose appear after a detailed treatment of the Syriac authors on 147–51. The book is difficult to access for anyone not familiar with the ancient authors and their works, due to the absence of a bibliography of editions and translations of the sources. The bibliography of secondary literature, however, is extensive. The index of five pages is helpful in tracing authors and key concepts.
