The rapid development of wireless technology broadcasting in the 1920s had huge implications for industry, the military, national and international politics, and civil society. In the Indian summer of the British Empire, the development of shortwave radio in particular promised new and efficient ways of maintaining the geopolitical order and imperial power. The possibilities arising from this new technology placed radio science and engineering – and the radio industry spearheaded by Marconi – at the centre of powerful new networks of communication and control that spanned the civil and military spheres. The state became a major patron of wireless science and technology, and radio scientists and engineers – and their training – became central to the interwar project to modernize the empire.
The 1920s also saw the development of ionospheric research in the empire's universities and industrial laboratories. Prompted by anomalies in the propagation of radio waves across the Earth's surface, the London- and Cambridge-based physicist Edward Appleton and his students (among many others) drew on traditions of atmospheric, terrestrial, experimental and mathematical physics to map the electrical structure of the atmosphere, much as Rutherford and his disciples were contemporaneously mapping the structure of the atom. Appleton's work on the elaboration of the ionosphere's electrical characteristics, and the 1924 proof of the existence of the long-conjectured ‘Heaviside–Kennelly layer’, would earn him the 1947 Nobel Prize in Physics. Radio physics also, of course, helped ensure the viability of the imperial communications project by offering the prospect of understanding and control of potentially disruptive natural forces.
Aitor Anduaga asks the obvious question: to what extent did the demands of empire, the military, industry, and other users and promoters of wireless and broadcasting shape the apparently ‘pure’ science of ionospheric physics? Daniel Headrick and C. Stewart Gillmor have covered some of the relevant ground before, but Anduaga claims to be taking a new approach. Pulling together for the first time a large but disparate secondary literature, and building on a huge amount of primary research on both published materials and archives, he uses a series of case studies to explore the development of interwar ionospheric research in tandem with the wider technical and educational aspects of radio, in Britain but also in Australia, New Zealand and Canada, and across universities and technical colleges, industry, the military and government agencies.
The picture that emerges is fascinating. Anduaga shows the significance of earlier scientific traditions, not least meteorology and atmospheric electricity, in shaping the practices of ionospheric science, and the role played in framing the organization of wireless research after the Great War by powerful state institutions such as the Imperial Communications (Sub)Committee of the Committee of Imperial Defence. Industry, too, played a key role; Marconi's development of shortwave wireless in the mid-1920s and the subsequent contract for an imperial communications chain raised profound issues about the security of wireless versus cable communication, private versus public provision, and control of a key political and military system. Meanwhile, as broadcasting burgeoned, the ongoing technical development of valves and other hardware linked researchers with common interests and shared skill sets in universities, industry, and the military and civil services. Appleton and his cohorts moved effortlessly across these sectors, in what looks like an instance of what Eisenhower would later identify as the military–industrial–academic complex.
These researchers also traversed the empire, carrying instrumentation and skills from site to site and globalizing the ionosphere in the process. Australia and New Zealand imported a British model of radio research organization through their leading physicists' close links with Appleton and Cambridge. Australian scientists also maintained close links with G.M.B. Dobson at Oxford in the closely allied pursuit of mapping atmospheric ozone – an international study whose results came to define the boundary between the upper and lower atmosphere and so the respective patches of radio-physicists and meteorologists. In these aerial turf wars, the Marconi Company again played a leading role as a key transnational actor, not least through its domination of patents and its imperial subsidiaries' training schools, which promoted radio education and research. It is salutary to be reminded that although radio later came to be regarded as central to Australian nation-building aspirations, it had at least as much to do with Marconi as with ‘state’ science.
Although the topic addressed is extremely important, the source material rich and the argument full of potential, Wireless and Empire is, it must be said, often a frustrating read. A curiously stilted prose style and occasionally baroque phraseology make the narrative rather difficult to follow at times. Referencing is inconsistent and not always reliable. In these respects neither the author nor the reader has been well served by the publisher, who should surely have subedited the work before seeing it through to print. Another source of trouble is Anduaga's somewhat blurred analytical focus. He veers uneasily between business history, institutional history, intellectual history, history of technology and history of technical education, without much of a feel for the structure and bureaucratic politics of the ‘state’ or the deeper significance of debates about technoscience. He tends to include long passages of uncritical biography which sit uneasily with his more general emphasis on ‘structural factors’. His chapters on New Zealand and Canada are thin by comparison with the more extended treatments of Britain and Australia, and weaken the comparative analysis. A curious ‘postscript’ reads more like an elementary literature review, and in fact acts as a historiographical prelude to a long ‘epilogue’ on the ‘realist interpretation of the atmosphere’ (previously published as a research paper). These latter elements operate in a different analytical register from the rest of the book and subtract from its coherence.
Notwithstanding these problems, the sheer volume of information presented in the book means that it will be indispensable to everyone interested in early twentieth-century science in Britain and its empire, as well as to those studying the history of wireless culture and strategic communications. If not the last word on the topic, Wireless and Empire is a most welcome addition to the literature.
