In the traditional conception, those colossi of Victorian scientific naturalism, Thomas Henry Huxley and John Tyndall, wielded unconstrained power and potency as they swept away the old Anglican elite and reshaped the nineteenth-century world in their professionalizing, technocratic image. More recently, historians have shown that the scientific naturalists' claims to speak on behalf of science were in fact contested at almost every turn, and by a wide range of different groups, from Presbyterian North British physicists and aristocratic Anglicans with a taste for spiritualist experiments, to popularizers able to win the public ear, to feminist anti-vivisectionists, as well as socialists and idealists. Anne Dewitt's fascinating Moral Authority, Men of Science, and the Victorian Novel adds another group to the list of those who challenged the cultural authority of Huxley and Tyndall: novelists.
Dewitt's argument is that Huxley and Tyndall's well-known contention that the practices of science could instil a broader moral excellence, one founded on scientific scepticism and supplanting Reformation dogma by relying on justification by verification rather than faith, was contradicted by their simultaneous endeavours to make science the preserve of a specialist and professional elite. It was, according to Dewitt, writers of fiction who, from the 1880s, launched the most sustained critique of this paradoxical position. Their novels, she proposes, challenged the limits of scientific knowledge, aligned moral insight with their female characters, and claimed moral cultivation as the exclusive preserve of fiction. Previous scholarship on scientific naturalism and the novel has tended to view writers such as George Eliot, Thomas Hardy and H.G. Wells as merely endorsing the new understandings of nature articulated by Huxley and his cohorts. Dewitt, however, begins by aligning her book with recent criticisms of the prevailing ‘one-culture model’ of science and literature scholarship, and her largely convincing account of how these late Victorian novelists contested the cultural authority of the scientific naturalists adds further nuance to our understanding of the ‘ranking and differentiation’, rather than mere mutuality, of nineteenth-century science and literature (p. 7).
Novels written during the scientific naturalists' rise to power, such as Elizabeth Gaskell's Wives and Daughters (1864–1866), were still content to equate science with moral probity, and to allow inclusive scientific activities like natural-history collecting to be integral to their courtship plots. Indeed, ‘careful attention to the seemingly insignificant’ continued to afford a credo for both natural history and the realist novel (p. 68). By the time of Eliot's Middlemarch (1871–1872), though, the scientific aspirations of Tertius Lydgate had become less unequivocally beneficial to his or others' moral character, and instead it is Dorothea Brooke – whose myopia contrasts with Lydgate's microscopical expertise – who becomes the novel's moral exemplar. Eliot's ‘critique of scientific professionalization’ as narrowing empathy and moral engagement was informed, in part, by her experience of her partner George Henry Lewes's difficulties in gaining admission to the mid-Victorian scientific community, but the narrative pattern established in Middlemarch, Dewitt proposes, became increasingly dominant over the remainder of the nineteenth century (p. 83).
Hardy's astronomical tragedy Two on a Tower (1882) is the novel that is most apposite for Dewitt's putative narrative pattern. In it, the courtship and scientific plots are briefly intertwined, with Swithin St Cleeve and his clandestine fiancée Viviette permitted physical closeness only by their nocturnal astronomical observations. The revelation of the brutal indifference of the cosmos, however, precipitates the subsequent separation of the two plots, as Swithin's opting for a career as a professional astronomer ‘entails, simultaneously, the sacrifice of Viviette and the hardening of his moral character’ (p. 16). Anti-vivisection novels similarly, if usually with less nuance, present professional expertise as antithetical to moral sensitivity, and as a profound threat to women and domestic relations (many of the impressive range of non-canonical novels Dewitt has uncovered depict the wives of men of science becoming the unwitting subjects of their husbands' amoral vivisections). Wells was responsible, of course, for perhaps the most famous anti-vivisection novel, The Island of Dr Moreau (1896), but he had also been an ardent student of Huxley's at the Normal School of Science, and was convinced by his mentor's message that science could have broader moral and social benefits. Dewitt confronts this seeming contradiction by suggesting that what Wells found problematic with science, including that of Huxley, was its increasing withdrawal from the public sphere and exclusion of all but a small cadre of experts. Wells's ambivalence is registered in his fiction by his inability to accommodate personal relationships in his scientific romances of the 1890s, and the critique of scientific (and aesthetic) autonomy in his realist novels of the early twentieth century. For Wells, as for Hardy before him, it is the novel itself that can instil the moral qualities that science has abnegated.
Dewitt's need to identify an archetypal narrative pattern in a range of different novels from a period spanning four decades can sometimes make her literary readings seem a little reductive, or at least not fully attentive to all the complexities and nuances of the individual fictions. That aside, Moral Authority, Men of Science, and the Victorian Novel presents a largely compelling argument that will be of considerable interest to historians of Victorian scientific naturalism. Dewitt's well-written and absorbing book is also another nail in the coffin of the simple ‘one-culture model’ of science and literature scholarship.
