The term “postcolonial” has at times been criticized for indicating a linear temporality reproducing the illusion that colonialism is over (e.g., Ella Shohat, “Notes on the ‘Post-Colonial,’” Social Text 31/32 [1992]: 99–113). These two books offer excellent analyses that invoke the term, not to announce the end of colonialism but to demonstrate its lingering effects on the contemporary political, social, economic, and cultural landscape.
In Political Theories of Decolonization, Margaret Kohn and Keally McBride use “postcolonialism” broadly, including in the term “the critique of colonialism, the movements for national liberation, and the ongoing struggles with the legacies of colonialism” (p. 8). Hence, the book examines not only those thinkers who specifically target formal colonization (e.g., Franz Fanon, Mohandas Gandhi, Aimé Césaire) but also those who criticize Western hegemony and domination more broadly understood (e.g., Ayatullah Khomeini, Subcomandante Marcos). What holds together the analysis of this wide array of thinkers and actors is the focus on the “problems of founding a new state out of the violent vestiges of the old order” (p. 11). Authoritarianism, civil and ethnic conflict, and political instability have characterized many postcolonial states, and the theories of decolonization analyzed by Kohn and McBride shed light on why this has been the case.
The authors clearly explain why these problems need to be understood as legacies of colonial institutions and practices. Chapter 4, on the state of emergency in colonial and postcolonial Kenya, offers crucial insights in this regard (a slightly different version by Kohn is also printed in the volume edited by Jacob Levy and Iris Marion Young). Reading the literary works of Kenyan author Ngugi wa Thiong'o together with the postcolonial critique of Achille Mbembe, Kohn and McBride make a convincing case for understanding “state of exception” as the “inner logic” of colonialism—one that “continues to structure postcolonial states and undermine popular government” (p. 79). Ngugi's works, for example, demonstrate how “the illiberal and antidemocratic measures” that were introduced by the British during the state of emergency declared in Kenya in response to the Mau Mau uprising (e.g., arbitrary detention) were incorporated into the laws of the postcolonial state (p. 89).
The question of founding also takes us to the tensions, paradoxes, and problems in some of the decolonization narratives. As Fanon's reflections on the dangerous illusions that can be created in the process of a revolutionary struggle highlight (pp. 70–72), the founding narratives that were necessary for the struggle against a colonial power can end up hindering self-rule and democratic citizenship after liberation from colonialism. And not all anticolonial positions seem to be equally promising for democratic rule. Take, for example, Ho Chi Minh's invocation of a revolutionary morality that would form “a monolithic whole” between the government and the people (p. 66), or Ayatollah Khomeini's depiction of revisionist scholars of Islam as “the servants of imperialism” (p. 51). Both of these founding narratives, envisioning the liberated nation as a unified entity with no room for difference and dissent, illustrate the need to critically scrutinize the assumptions and conclusions of some decolonization narratives. As Kohn and McBride adopt an interpretive approach aimed at understanding anticolonial theories and programs on their own terms, however, they at times shy away from such a critique. For example, the authors offer no assessment of Khomeini's attack against more syncretic approaches that interweave Islamic and European traditions. More surprisingly, despite their attentiveness to the syncretism of anticolonial thinking elsewhere, they invoke Khomeini's position as an example that questions the privileging of hybridity in postcolonial theory (p. 54).
A distinctive feature of Political Theories of Decolonization is its focus on “the voice of the colonized” (p. 4). Kohn and McBride differentiate their approach from that of comparative political theory by suggesting that the latter takes the works of non-European thinkers as “representative of distinct cultural perspectives” (p. 6) and fails to capture the “syncretic character” of anticolonial thinking (p. 7). Equally important is the authors' attentiveness to the multiple, and at times contradictory, messages and programs offered by theories of decolonization (pp. 12, 153). Despite these methodological clarifications, however, certain questions remain unanswered. Especially important are those related to the representation of the “voice of the colonized”: Which texts and authors get to be selected as representative of that voice, and why? And how do we listen to and represent that voice? Some of these challenging problems have been addressed by postcolonial theorists, especially in the wake of Gayatri Spivak's groundbreaking essay “Can the Subaltern Speak?” (in Cary Nelson and Lawrence Grossberg, eds. Marxism and the Interpretation of Culture, 1988, 271–313). But since Kohn and McBride distance their project from the strand of postcolonial theory that addresses these questions (in fact, they mention Spivak's work but then state that their focus is not “the relationship between knowledge and power” [p. 6]), this methodological issue is left unaddressed.
Yet questions related to representation seem to be central to projects that aim to give an account of the collective agency and imagination of the colonized subjects, as several essays in Colonialism and Its Legacies highlight. Dipesh Chakrabarty's essay directly addresses the challenging methodological questions faced by these projects. Reflecting on peasant nationalism in colonial India, Chakrabarty alerts us to the danger of objectifying subaltern agency by reducing it to a set of individuated acts and losing its collective dimension (p. 216). He also adds that the possible epistemic violence in projects aiming to represent subaltern agency cannot be avoided by simply refraining from the task of translation or interpretation (p. 217). Chakrabarty proposes an approach that centers on Hayden White's notion of “middle voice,” which requires “staying on th[e] cusp—that is by refusing to either objectify or go native” (p. 217).
Bhikhu Parekh's essay raises crucial questions about who gets to be represented as the “voice of the colonized.” Parekh turns our attention to the interesting case of Hindu and Muslim middle classes and dalits who recognized the violence of British colonialism but also saw it as a force for regenerating India. Kohn and McBride underline that many theorists of decolonization rejected liberal ideas and practices entirely (pp. 12, 24), but what do we do with the voices of those colonized subjects who are exceptions to this norm? Parekh's essay suggests that those voices should also be included: “[I]t would be wrong to dismiss Hindu colonial supporters as collaborators or ideologically brainwashed colonial victims,” as they were also “genuinely patriotic” (p. 179).
Ofelia Schutte's essay on José Martí also emphasizes the need to attend to the divergent voices raised against colonialism. Unlike what most postcolonial theory suggests, Schutte argues, not every theory of decolonization is articulated in opposition to the ideals of Enlightenment, especially its “grand narratives” of emancipation (p. 182).
If the essays by Chakrabarty, Parekh, and Schutte speak to the challenges of representing the “voice of the colonized,” several other essays in the volume complement, and at times complicate, the problem of founding examined by Kohn and McBride. In particular, the essays by Taiaiake Alfred, Pratap Bhanu Mehta, and the late Emmanuel C. Eze urge us to engage more critically with anticolonial narratives in order to understand their long-term effects. In his essay on “Wasáse,” Alfred argues that not every decolonization strategy is equally acceptable in indigenous struggles: “How you fight determines who you will become when the battle is over” (p. 82). Mehta's essay addresses the question of founding by analyzing the paradoxes and problems of decolonization strategies centered on representation in societies with heterogeneous religious and ethnic compositions. On the one hand, the idea of creating a “collective will” representative of the people was central to decolonization projects (pp. 152–53). On the other hand, the question of who gets to be represented in that collective will gave rise to serious problems in societies “where groups think of themselves as permanent majorities or permanent minorities” (p. 158). Eze's essay on W. E. B. Du Bois's notion of “double consciousness” also invites a more critical engagement with the key concepts and ideas of anticolonialism. Du Bois's term is useful, Eze argues, only if it is invoked historically and sociologically to capture a condition revealing the “deformations in the social body” (p. 240). But he cautions us against its metaphysical and psychological overtones (pp. 236–37) and criticizes postcolonial theorists who celebrate it as an ideal of democratic subjectivity (pp. 238–40).
The rest of the essays in Colonialism and Its Legacies approach the topic by diversifying and expanding our understandings of Enlightenment and modernity. The essays by Sankar Muhtu and Jennifer Pitts “pluralize the very idea of Enlightenment,” to use Muhtu's terms (p. 17), as they challenge its monolithic understanding as a discourse justifying colonial practices. Muhtu presents Diderot's views on commerce to illustrate the dissident voices within the Enlightenment, and Pitts turns to the works of Adam Smith and James Dunbar to recover a notion of “development” that challenges the differential treatment of non-Europeans (p. 41).
Vicki Hsueh's essay also offers insights into the alternatives that can be found in the past, but it is more of a cautionary tale about the perils of holding those alternatives as models for contemporary thinking. Examining the treaties negotiated between William Penn and the various Lenape and Susquehannock tribes in the seventeenth century, Hsueh criticizes scholars of multiculturalism for taking treaty constitutionalism as a model for cross-cultural dialogue without looking at the unequal, exclusionary, and indeterminate aspects of these treaties (p. 71).
The essays by Enrique Dussel, whose work is analyzed by Kohn and McBride, and Jessé Souza expand our understanding of modernity by challenging Eurocentric frameworks. Dussel rejects the insular understanding of European modernity as an “autopoietic” event restricted to developments on that continent only (p. 98), and instead situates it within a “world-system” by locating its origins in the discovery of Amerindia in 1492 (pp. 103–5). Souza's essay offers crucial insights into the problems of “peripheral modernity,” as it demonstrates that social inequality in countries such as Brazil results not from a “premodern and personalist inheritance” but instead from the peculiar processes of modernization introduced by capitalist expansion in the periphery (p. 121).
To conclude, both of these books offer clear, persuasive, and insightful analyses demonstrating that formal processes of decolonization did not end colonialism. The authors need to be commended for reminding political scientists that the challenging questions about global justice, democratic citizenship, and human rights can no longer be addressed without a careful examination of colonialism and its legacies.
