The lightning rod is now over 250 years old. Set against the background of electrified kisses, electrical orreries, and other philosophical entertainments of the mid-eighteenth century, it can assume an air of self-evident, modern utility. However, as the editors of Playing with Fire have shown, this apparent straightforwardness is largely an effect of historiography. Afforded iconic status by proponents of Enlightenment, the lightning rod has dropped out of more recent accounts of eighteenth-century electrical science. Thus, while linear narratives of invention, dissemination and triumph over superstition are no longer credible, few alternative ‘histories of the lightning rod’ have appeared. The editors present this volume as a starting point, bringing together eleven papers read at a conference at the Bakken Museum in Minneapolis in 2002. Contributions range from the mid-eighteenth century to the early twentieth, and cover episodes in the history of lightning and the lightning rod from Britain and western Europe, Mexico and North America.
The editors have divided the papers into four groups, loosely based on chronology and focus. Papers in the first section deal with specific social, cultural and climatic conditions in which lightning rods were introduced in Italy (Paola Bertucci), the German Empire (Oliver Hochadel) and Mexico (Fiona Clark) in the second half of the eighteenth century. Relationships between natural philosophers, political authorities and ‘the public’ play a prominent role here. Perhaps more specific to the contested spread of lightning rods in this period is the importance of climate in forming local identities, as in Clark's account of the introduction of the lightning rod in late eighteenth-century Mexico City; and that of weather as an uncontrolled phenomenon that could influence official policy, as in Hochadel's account of the ‘dry fog’ (p. 45) that hung over Europe in the summer of 1783. These three papers show how the gradual spread of the lightning rod was shaped by local circumstances. In doing so, they offer valuable alternatives to models of change based on dichotomies such as ‘centre’ and ‘periphery’ or ‘Enlightenment’ and ‘superstition’.
The second section deals loosely with politics and representation at the end of the eighteenth century. Using English and French examples respectively, R.W. Home and Peter Heering both discuss the changing criteria by which electrical experiments were judged authoritative in the late eighteenth century. In both cases, experiments that appealed to large audiences for credibility lost out to the growing power of the expert. Heering attributes this to attempts to model knowledge production on a political ideal, while Home offers his interpretation as an alternative to a ‘political’ explanation. Taking a considerably different approach, Christian Fuhrmeister argues for a connection between the spread of the lightning rod and other electrical technologies on the one hand, and a new political iconography of lightning on the other. The arena of visual culture – specifically, of political prints – emerges in Fuhrmeister's paper as a vital resource for understanding the cultural repercussions of developments in technology and natural knowledge.
Papers in the third section portray thunderstorms as both good and bad for business in nineteenth-century America, where the installation of lightning rods was becoming a commercial concern. Arwen Mohun traces their transformation from custom-made devices designed by local elites and educated farmers to commercially designed and patented products. The rods underwent a corresponding change in appearance and significance. Elizabeth Cavicchi contrasts the processes of commercial design and patenting of lightning rods with the improvised devices used by telegraphers. These men protected their signals and equipment from lightning with ‘lightning arresters’ (p. 193) worked out through an iterative process of trial and error. These two papers offer an engaging picture of the diverse material cultures that emerged from nineteenth-century commercial interests attempting to profit from, and protect against, the destructive power of the environment.
The fourth and final section brings together papers on the technologies used to investigate, capture and defend against the effects of electricity in the laboratory and in the environment. Willem D. Hackmann explores the basis of conceptual connections between laboratory models that simulated lightning strikes and other phenomena of atmospheric electricity in the eighteenth century. Paolo Brenni's paper spans two centuries, and focuses on technologies used directly to measure, manipulate or even capture the power of both ‘fair-weather electricity’ (p. 231) and lightning bolts. The final contribution to the collection, by C.B. Moore, G.D. Aulich and William Rison, reports the conclusions of experiments on the effectiveness of Benjamin Franklin's favoured pointed tips compared to rods terminating in other shapes. As a closing paper, it implies fascinating questions about the ongoing relationship between form, rationale and function in a technology such as the lightning rod, which has been in use for over 250 years.
Contributors to this volume include historians, art historians and historians of science, and physicists, engineers and meteorologists. Despite the somewhat fragmented nature of the book as a whole, this wide range of backgrounds and perspectives confirms the potential of objects to structure interdisciplinary research. Playing with Fire will be of interest to historians of science and technology, as well as to those concerned with the interplay of human relations, technology and the environment.
