In the first decades of the nineteenth century, Prussia introduced agricultural reforms that gave peasants new freedoms, including the right to leave their farms and to marry whomever they chose. This detailed book by Sean Eddie provides an account of agricultural reform in Prussia and documents the conditions faced by serfs and nobles before, during, and after peasant emancipation. Scholars of German and East European economic history, agricultural economics, and economic development will benefit from reading this interpretation of the historical development of Prussian agriculture. The book succeeds especially in conveying both the variation and general patterns of feudalism in Prussia.
Eddie re-evaluates Prussian feudalism by “weighing costs against benefits,” arguing that previous literature has tended to moralize rather than analyze peasant subjection (p. 20). According to the author, on balance feudalism offered many benefits both to nobles and to peasants, and contrary to expectations, “those peasants subject to manorial authority fared much better than their ‘free’ neighbours” (p. 13). His argument emphasizes the institution of Konservation, or the noble's duty to support peasants during bad harvests or disasters. Eddie highlights Konservation's relationship to capital maintenance: peasants who provided their own capital received less support from nobles. Capital also determined how much rent peasants paid and how many rights they had. Nobles played a crucial role in the peasant economy by providing capital that peasants could not.
According to the author, his view that feudalism consisted of “mutual rights and responsibilities” stands in contrast to an old wisdom that peasants suffered due to “ ‘extra-economic’ coercion” (12), citing the example of Marxist historians Aston and Philpin's 1985 The Brenner Debate. Eddie could have provided more guidance on how his view contrasts with current literature: How many historians or economists today would disagree that serfdom provided peasants with some benefits?
Eddie next argues that, gradually, changes in market conditions persuaded peasants to desire more secure tenures in order to keep greater proportions of agricultural surplus. A numerical argument in Table 4 (p. 125) shows that peasants kept a large amount of surplus if agrarian conditions improved. Konservation steadily evaporated as peasants no longer needed to rely on insurance from nobles. Population growth probably hurt peasants who relied on the market for food, though the creation of new households stimulated the development of markets for finished goods, a comment on De Vries's industrious revolution.
The book provides a fascinating outline of the complex negotiations and compromises embodied in the reforms of 1811 and 1816. Eddie argues that the reforms arose from a combination of steadily deteriorating conditions in agriculture resulting from population growth, which was brought to a head by the Napoleonic wars. Serfdom could not survive any longer, but nobles had to be compensated for the lost value of labor. Thus, peasants paid a price for their new rights.
Eddie aims to reconcile the reality of the reform negotiations with accounts found in the literature. The October 1807 edict gave peasants new rights including the right “to move without penalty, to choose his farm, raise debts against it, sell the whole or parts of it, and bequeath it to an heir of his own choosing,” as well as the right to choose whom to marry and to choose a profession. However, the literature holds that the 1807 edict was a noble victory, since it gave nobles the right to enclose farms and freed nobles from Konservation duties. However, Eddie argues that in practice nobles still maintained Konservation, and the law caused confusion by giving peasants their personal freedom without altering tenure arrangements. The literature seems to view the further 1811 reform as one more nail in the peasants’ coffin, but Eddie argues that, on balance, the terms of the 1811 favored peasants. Finally, the 1816 reform simply aligned the law with reality and leaned more a bit toward the nobles only because the earlier reforms so favored the peasantry.
One of Eddie's major pieces of evidence that the 1811 edict favored peasants is that peasants mounted a small but positive response to the reform, while nobles complained loudly. Here Eddie cites official reports as well as noble and peasant petitions and letters from the archives. Eddie is careful to note that peasants had few deputies in the National Assembly and that one should exercise “due caution as to the bias” of his sources for peasant opinion (p. 220), and one wonders which peasants’ opinions are missing from the documents.
Comparisons to Scotland, France, and Austria presented in the book's conclusion illustrated how well peasants fared in Prussia's emancipation. Prussian reforms, according to Eddie, had comparatively radical results, even when compared to reform in France. Such comparisons could have especially enhanced the argument in Part II had they been woven throughout the narrative.
Eddie's work embodies a command of secondary literature and new use of archival sources from the Geheimes Staatsarchiv at Berlin-Dahlem. Much of the evidence for the discussion of negotiation of the terms of the reform, for example, comes directly from archival materials. The book demonstrates a command of secondary literature, but the presentations of archival material are much more compelling than some of the long summaries of other scholarship.
The book's impressive detail is sometimes overwhelming; readers may hunger for occasional simplifications for the sake of narrative. Part I, which presents key institutional details, is especially challenging. For example, the author's definitions of the several kinds of tenure that could be found in Prussian farms are complicated and a bit confusing (see, for example, p. 37), and the author refers to the German terms throughout the book. Beginning paragraphs of sections and chapters provide some summary, but more emphasis could have been placed on those details that become crucial in later parts of the argument.
Freedom's Price combines archival materials and secondary literature to present a provocative account of Prussia peasant emancipation. The book is sure to stimulate lively debate from scholars interested in the causes and consequences of agricultural reforms.
