In ethnomusicology, there is still a lack of really useful, spot on teaching material available despite a recent flurry of publications that are meant to address this problem. Teaching ethnomusicology to music students demands that they need to develop some familiarity with cultural contexts that are usually very unfamiliar to them. Reading up on cultural background, listening to recordings, transcription and analysis, video, supplemented with hands-on perfomance work, is probably the best we can provide as teachers without taking our students on a field trip.
To my mind, Worlds of Music: An Introduction to the Music of the World's Peoples (Jeff Todd Titon, General Editor), is probably the most successful book used in any introduction to music cultures of the world. It ran to a fourth edition in 2002. Analytical Studies in World Music (ASWM herein), edited by Michael Tenzer, might be said to take up where Worlds of Music leaves off. It presents music theory and analysis on a world stage and tells us how composers and performers in various cultural contexts make music. The book is broad ranging in its theoretical treatment of music analysis and in terms of its cultural reach, with chapters on Iranian sung poetry, Bulgarian music, Javanese and Balinese gamelan music, Afro-Cuban drumming, flamenco, Chinese opera, South Indian classical music, and modern American chamber music. Tenzer notes some way into the introduction that: ‘This is a book of analyses, not a study of debates about analysis or an argument for a particular method’ (p. 12). In this review, I touch lightly on that debate, because I am more interested in how we might use this book in the classroom.
Tenzer's argument is clear and well informed. I have no difficulty with my students engaging with his views. However, it is a great pity that he feels obliged to take ten pages to explain why he has chosen to use Western methods of transcription and analysis in approaching these musics, and how the book goes some ways toward combining both insider and outsider viewpoints in discussions of the structure of music. In a defence of his thesis, he is exemplary. He poses the central question on which this book must ride in ethnomusicology: ‘Is it at all right to analyse music independent of its political, geographical, or cultural distance from the analyst or reader? Shall we allow ourselves to become absorbed in music's sound, conceiving of it as if in isolation from the world?’ (p. 5). Fortunately, in terms of the music cultures under the microscope here, the contributors do not lose sight of any of these elements. We are in safe hands as experienced researchers tell us about the different ways in which they met with the minds behind the music they write about. Structural analysis and theoretical modelling came out of intense training and discussion with musicians in situ. But how does Tenzer achieve coherence out of such a diverse range of musical ideas and provide a narrative thread for the book?
Tenzer's main linking structure in the book is periodicity, of which he says: ‘In music, periodicity has long signified repetition or restatement, literal or transformed, of all kinds – of beats, rhythms, motives, melodies, structures, timbres: virtually any musical elements can create an element of stability through return or constancy, and such stability will always be in dynamic dialog with change’ (p. 22). Tenzer allows his contributors to focus on aspects of what he calls ‘the qualities of periodicity’ (pp. 25–7) and the tensions between contrasting periodicities. Part One focuses on ‘sectional periodicities’, providing a model of the interplay between poetry, song and ritual in performance. Stephen Blum notes the juxtapositioning and tensions that arise when poetic and musical metre meet in bardic songs from Xorasan, the North-Easternmost province of Iran. The two recorded performances which he analyses make up the first two tracks on the ASWM CD. Blum skilfully builds up a complex analysis of the structural basis of sung poetry and the sequencing of syllables, instrumental patterns, and melodic progressions, which also create rhythmic consequences and effects. Donna Buchanan and Stuart Folse base their analysis upon improvised instrumental dance tunes (hora) which provide the musical basis for Bulgarian celebrations. A horo is spun through musical improvisation within one of two contrasting frameworks: songs of varying lengths and shorter, transitional passages known as otsvir. Improvisation also takes place within symmetrically arranged periods known as kolena, which are inspired by either the song or the transitional passage. One of their informants notes that ‘Every horo is like an experiment’ (p. 90). Buchanan and Folse conclude that the internalisation of ‘stylistic vocabulary’ leads to the creation of new melodies which are ‘woven through metered time and modal space, sonic places to and through which instrumentalists travel on the crest of the musical lines they create’ (p. 90).
Peter Manuel discusses the unwavering twelve-pulse cycle in flamenco called compas (‘period’), in which there are sharp contrasts of length and musical elements between the song forms (copla) and the guitar interludes (falseta) that overlay it. He focuses on one song form, soleares and unpacks a convincing analysis of the dynamic interplay between the guitar and vocal parts. In conclusion Manuel notes that: ‘a flamenco piece is not a closely, precisely structured formal composition, like a pop song or a classical composition. Rather, it is a typical product of oral tradition in being a loose, informal entity, in which fragments may be freely inserted, verses repeated or altered, and overall length and structure treated with flexibility’ (p. 115). In their chapter on Cuban bata drumming, Robin Moore and Elizabeth Sayre focus on elements of constant change in songs that are layered over drumming in Cuban bata performance. There are moments of ‘true structural shift’ (p. 29) in the interlocking drum patterns but constant changes in the songs with melodies of different lengths, call and response, and rhythmic improvisation resulting from the interplay of voice and drums. Moore and Sayre note that ‘in five brief minutes’ their recording of Afro-Cuban religious music ‘has required many words and diagrams to explain them’ (p. 154).
The second part of the book is made up of three chapters: Central African Aka Polyphony, Balinese gamelan (percussion orchestra), and Javanese gamelan. The three chapters are linked by a concern for strict periodicity (rigorous and unchanging cycles) exemplified by the 12 beat cycle of Aka singers, and discursive periodicites where ‘a single cyclic entity narrates . . . a journey through processes of temporal expansion and contraction developed and sanctioned by the culture’ (p. 28). Part Three deals with the problem of ‘Linear Composition in Periodic Contexts’ where gradual change, ‘the counterpart to period structure’, is carried in melodic, harmonic or some other form. In Jonathan Stock's analysis of a Shanghai opera scene, the singer varies metre and phrasing thus dissolving local patterns of repetition, even if ‘overall periodicity and symmetry is apparent when the whole is considered from a birds-eye view’ (p. 30). One can hear this happening to the tala rhythmic cycle in Robert Morris's recording of a South Indian varnam (‘etude’). In William Benjamin's analysis of Mozart's K.543 Piano Concerto No.17 in G Major (Movement 1) there are ‘myriad linkages, elisions, extensions, and contractions that wreak havoc’ (ibid). In a more extreme example, John Roeder still find elements that provide for pattern and form in Elliot Carter's Enchanted Preludes, a piece that rewards several listenings and readings, accompanied as it is by a fascinating analysis (and an appendix which shows possible pitch errors in the scores!).
The book is brought to life through an incredible range of illustrative material. The very many musical examples work well as an aid to understanding the concepts behind each musical (and cultural) analysis. Some of them are easier to understand than others, it has to be said, but all provide useful, engaging and challenging models for the reader (particularly for the student). For those of us who might use this book in the classroom, the visual aids (transcriptions, photographs, line drawings) are an absolutely essential addition to the written text. They do not clutter the proceedings but appear at appropriate and necessary points in the book. The CD does its job well, presenting a rich variety of colourful sounds, textures, timbres, instrumentation and vocal styles to the listener. It is carefully synchronised to the flow of analytical work in the chapters. The CD in itself presents another welcome and even stand alone resource with detailed contents notes. There is just enough listening material here to complement the often long and involved work in the chapters (providing useful ‘time out’ in class, I would guess), the more straightforward analyses having less recording time than others, such as the two gamelan tracks and the recording of Chinese opera. But there were moments in my listening to the CD, when I wished the shorter musical snippets could have been placed in the setting of a longer recording. This is, of course, easier wished for than done when compiling a disk, not just for copyright reasons, but because each track must be tightly coupled to each analysis.
One criticism that might be levelled at the book is that a type of ethnomusicological canon appears to rear its ugly head in the types of music chosen for analysis: gamelan music, Aka polyphony, South Indian classical music and Chinese opera (plus two chapters on American chamber music) make up seven of the eleven chapters in the book. Fortunately, Tenzer tries to break the mould by including sung poetry form Iran, Bulgarian dance music, a flamenco solea and Afro-Cuban bata. Tenzer argues convincingly for the inclusion of all the musics analysed here, and one notes, of course, that edited collections are notoriously difficult to assemble. In the end, all of these chapters do seem to work well together and create a solid foundation which is also enabling of comparative analysis. That said, I was rather surprised to find no popular music analysis in the book. Indeed, writings in popular musicology were conspicuous by their absence. Why no mention of Richard Middleton, Allan Moore or Philip Tagg, for instance? I cannot see how one can leave them out of a discussion of analysis, especially in the context of a book with global dimensions. I realise some limits have to be imposed but this might give the impression that the book is rather narrow despite its ‘worldness’, and that somehow, still, there are only certain types of music that are worthy of analysis - the very thing Tenzer tries to avoid. What is more, the musics analysed seem to exist in a world without popular music. Of course, they do not. If one can stretch to Mozart and Cowell why not one or two chapters on popular music? Flamenco may loosely be interpreted as filling this gap. I can only see the theory in the book benefiting from an injection of popular musicology. Perhaps we need another book, called Analytical Studies in the Popular Musics of the World?
From my experience of university music teaching, ASWM would seem highly appropriate for second and third year music/music education courses, building on a first year of Worlds of Music and providing a long thin study through a module supplemented by other ethnomusicological volumes that use musical analysis to varying degrees (see, for example, Rice, Reference RICE1994; Nettl, Reference NETTL and RUSSELL1998). It could feature at postgraduate level too. Tenzer is not writing for the musically illiterate, embryonic or developing reader: one is expected to be able to understand quite complex notations and some of the writing is theoretically dense, but putting myself in the shoes of some of my students reading the book, I did not find any of the chapters incomprehensible. The book must surely feature in any advanced music theory and analysis course, and is also a lively resource for composition teaching. However it is used, I am confident that ASWM will become a recognised teaching tool. I am in no doubt about the excellence of the chapters as lessons in musical analysis, whether one is in agreement with such an approach or not – and students should be encouraged to make up their own minds on that point. Michael Tenzer, ethnomusicologist and composer, cleverly sets the book up as a self-reflective project, in which we see the contributors grapple with the problem of trying to understand somebody else's music, as cultural outsiders. The journey towards understanding the music of another culture is not an easy one, whatever route one takes and whatever tools of analysis one employs.
