
Claire Hilton’s new book makes a significant contribution to the growing body of fine historical publications by psychiatrists. It follows on sequentially from her earlier Civilian Lunatic Asylums During the First World War (Palgrave Macmillan, 2021) and builds upon its rather bleak conclusions. Meticulously researched from a range of sources, her latest work adds much to the historiography of the inter-war era, which has attracted increasing interest among historians of psychiatry. The period has hitherto been mainly characterised as one of large, sterile public institutions and entrenched poor practices. Hilton’s findings largely confirm such perceptions, albeit with some nuances.
The chapters cover five main areas, with clear interlinkages. Chapter 2 looks at the views and opinions of the public, and the currents of ideas, knowledge and prejudices that influenced care and treatment for mentally ill people within asylums newly redesignated as mental hospitals. Hilton highlights the ongoing tensions between motives of care and custody that have continued to the present day.
Chapter 3 examines patients’ experiences within the institutions, emphasising the regimentation and lack of individualisation to which most were subjected, alongside poor physical conditions, overcrowded wards and indifferent or harsh treatment by underqualified, poorly paid and overworked staff. Chapter 4 considers the challenges faced by doctors at a time of constrained resources, limited progress in knowledge and lack of consensus regarding effective treatment methods.
Chapter 5 explores the complex issues surrounding defensive, hierarchical and punitive institutional cultures, exacerbated by the restrictions imposed by national and local regulatory bodies. Hilton links this to the illiberal 1890 Lunacy Act and its adverse consequences. Chapter 6 shows how an increasingly vocal lobby demanded reforms in mental healthcare, finding expression in the public inquiry of 1922 and royal commission of 1924–1926, which led eventually to the significant Mental Treatment Act of 1930 and formalised arrangements for out-patient and voluntary treatment.
The study concludes by drawing clear parallels between the system’s profound shortcomings in the 1920s and the critical issues confronting mental health professionals and their patients one hundred years later. While elements in the history of psychiatry should be extremely instructive, the reader is left with the distinct impression that we have rarely used its lessons to best effect. Claire Hilton has done an important service in fully exposing a very uncomfortable period in that history, while reminding us of the serious shortcomings that still persist.

eLetters
No eLetters have been published for this article.