It has been over two decades since Kuwaiti sociologist Haya al-Mughni published her groundbreaking analysis, Women in Kuwait: The Politics of Gender (London: Saqi Books, 1993). Although academic articles and chapters on women's issues and the politics of gender in Kuwait have appeared since then, full-length studies have been few and far between; Helen Mary Rizzo's Islam, Democracy, and the Status of Women: The Case of Kuwait (New York: Routledge, 2005) is the exception. For those within the field of Kuwait and/or Gulf studies generally and Arab feminism more specifically, the publication in 2013 of two books on women in Kuwait has been a welcome addition to the literature. Both Meshal al-Sabah's Gender and Politics in Kuwait: Women and Political Participation in the Gulf and Alessandra L. González's Islamic Feminism in Kuwait: The Politics and Paradoxes (New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2013) explore the recent history of women's movements in Kuwait, with the latter book focusing on the rise of Islamic feminism based on a sociological analysis of cultural elites within Kuwaiti society. Al-Sabah's study, while also exploring the rise and effects of Islamic feminism in Kuwait, adopts a more varied perspective by examining a range of complex forces within the country, in addition to Islam and Islamism.
Gender and Politics in Kuwait neatly summarizes the history of women and politics in Kuwait from the 1960s—the decade of its independence and most rapid development—until 2012. Al-Sabah identifies the 1990 Iraqi invasion of Kuwait and the subsequent 1991 war of liberation as pivotal to Kuwaiti women's struggle for enfranchisement, although, paradoxically, not in the ways anticipated soon after liberation. Instead of providing a catalyst for immediate change, as expected by many, the invasion precipitated a rise in government-supported Islamist groups, including Islamist women's groups such as the Islamic Care Society (ICS). These influential groups pushed hard against the enfranchisement of women and against other rights long taken for granted by Kuwaiti women (e.g., the right to education, to work, to drive, to dress as desired) (p. 53). Al-Sabah demonstrates how the struggle for women's rights stalled for over a decade as a result of the influence of the ICS and other Islamist political groups (supported by elites worried about losing their grip on power through the enfranchisement of women of all classes) (p. 54). This is despite promises made by the Kuwaiti government in exile during the invasion, the active and well-recognized role played by Kuwaiti women in the resistance movement, and U.S. pressure after the liberation. It was not until 2005, a full fourteen years after Kuwait's liberation, that women gained the right to vote and to stand for parliamentary election. Al-Sabah untangles the reasons for this delay, providing a clear perspective on the convoluted politics of Kuwaiti governance (p. 55).
In fact, al-Sabah's ability to maneuver adeptly through the constantly shifting terrain of loyalties and interests within Kuwaiti politics—from those of the ruling family and the National Assembly to those of the electorate itself—is what makes Gender and Politics in Kuwait such a riveting read. While the narrative will not be surprising to those familiar with the subject, al-Sabah's highlighting of often-overlooked connections between unlikely allies over the course of decades (for example, ruling elites with Islamists or Islamists with reformists) at the expense of women's interests is a necessary reminder of that narrative's thorny specifics. Al-Sabah identifies the “divide and conquer” method utilized by the government, even in the decades before the invasion, as the most systematically applied technique to retain power and the most successful in preventing women from gaining traction within politics (p. 63). Divisions within Kuwaiti society, as Anh Nga Longva has convincingly argued in her anthropological study Walls Built on Sand: Migration, Exclusion, and Society in Kuwait (Boulder, Colo.: Westview Press, 1997), are not only central to the way the government maintains power but also crucial to the way Kuwaitis (men and women alike) think of themselves. As such, shifting away from exclusionary politics in Kuwait—detrimental to women, Shiʿa, non-Kuwaiti migrants, bidūn, and other minority groups—is an inherently arduous task.
Al-Sabah, who does not reference Longva's seminal study, makes a similar claim. He argues that although Kuwait's constitution and government structure (which divides power between the ruling al-Sabah family, the elected National Assembly, and the judiciary) is at least potentially democratic, it has tended to perpetuate rather than to alleviate social, economic, and political divisions. As al-Sabah explains,
Maintaining a consensus often involved playing one side off against the other, or creating artificial divisions between different groups. Many of Kuwait's power struggles were class-based, including battles between richer urbanites and poorer tribal cultures; this particular division was intensified by the doctrinal and cultural differences between the Shiʿi and the Sunni majority. . .The shifting alliances, and the rise and fall of various pressure groups, often left women's rights groups vulnerable in a political maelstrom, and they became pawns in political games (p. 50).
Longva argues that overcoming these oppressions necessitates a transformation of long-entrenched social stratifications. Al-Sabah similarly suggests that to address current social divisions and political and economic inequities requires the expansion of the struggle for women's rights to include equal rights for all, Kuwaiti and non-Kuwaiti alike.
Gender and Politics in Kuwait will appeal both to the general reader wishing to learn more about gender issues in Kuwait, as well as to the specialist looking for a text that covers familiar ground clearly and rigorously. Al-Sabah convincingly relates current stalemates to recent and less recent history, and his claims are well supported by studies, newspaper articles, and interviews; Arabic language sources are not included, however. Al-Sabah is equally unflinching in his criticism of the mistakes and miscalculations made by various groups wielding power—from the ruling family to the Islamists, from women's groups to an apathetic population accustomed to generous social benefits. His aim is to excavate the layers of Kuwaiti society and its politics without reducing any of its sometimes-confusing complexity as a way to further the democratizing process in Kuwait. While al-Sabah contextualizes Kuwait both regionally and globally, he also seems to suggest that Kuwait's exceptional and deep-rooted experiments with democracy—the fact that it “followed a different course from other members of the GCC”—make it a model for Islamic (as opposed to Western) democratization in the region (pp. 3, 7). His analysis of the rising role of youth movements and media networks in the democratizing process in both Kuwait and the region more widely is timely and persuasive.
Al-Sabah's study is thorough. It is organized by topic and follows a loose chronology. This structure enables an effective analysis of the major forces involved in the struggle for and against women's rights. The narrative generally moves from 1991 to 2009 and beyond, but at points there are chronological disjunctures that make the text slightly disjointed and result in unnecessary repetition. For example, the final chapter of the book, “The Long Road to Success: Women in Kuwaiti Politics 1991–2009,” includes much of the material already discussed in previous chapters and seems somewhat ill-placed after the detailed discussion of the future of gender and politics in Kuwait in the chapter directly preceding it. However, this is a minor concern and does not detract from the overall excellence of al-Sabah's book.
