Solon Solomon, in this book which is based on his master's thesis, presents quite an elaborate legal description on the justiciability of international disputes. The book provides a thorough legal analysis of the International Court of Justice's (ICJ) Advisory Opinion on Legal Consequences of the Construction of a Wall in the Occupied Palestinian Territory, 2004 ICJ Reports 136 (9 July 2004) (Advisory Opinion) from the Israeli perspective. The book attempts to balance the legal arguments by an analysis from the security standpoint as well as the justiciability dimension. It recognizes that the present approach to the settlement of disputes by the ICJ is indeed to perceive that each case before the ICJ has both legal as well as political dimensions, and that the ICJ focuses simply on the legal issue(s). Thereby, the presence of any political aspect to a dispute does not render an issue non-justiciable. The book strongly argues that there are certain issues that are inherently non-justiciable as justiciability stricto sensu. Thus, the Advisory Opinion has been examined from that perspective. It further argues about the clash of two important international law issues, i.e. the legality of settlements and the settler's right to life that renders it non-justiciable, as the ICJ is unable to uphold one principle over the other without being accused of adopting a biased attitude. It stresses that the ICJ's ruling on the illegality of settlements was not feasible due to a lack of crucial topographical evidence. The author has included the Israeli Supreme Court cases on the construction of the security fence, thereby providing a good comparative perspective.
The book has been divided into three chapters that deal with the justiciability doctrine, its nature and role in the adjudication of issues (Chapter 1), the justiciability doctrine and the Advisory Opinion on Israel's security fence (Chapter 2), and the Israeli Supreme Court and the security fence (Chapter 3). Chapter 1 attempts to provide a theoretical review of the justiciability doctrine that concerns the limits upon legal issues over which a court can exercise its judicial authority. The chapter fairly tries to address the contentious and rather controversial question of justiciability from an objective standpoint and argues that the civil law countries also observe the non-justiciability doctrine. It then proceeds with considering various aspects of justiciability and distinguishes it into lato sensu and stricto sensu; evaluates the legal and political side of justiciability; analyzes justiciability in some selected jurisdictions vis-à-vis the United States of America, Canada, Germany, and Israel; contextualizes it within the international legal order; and reviews the doctrine of justiciability in the framework of the institution of arbitration. The chapter further examines the practical application of the justiciability doctrine in the jurisprudence developed by the ICJ and its predecessor, i.e. the Permanent Court of International Justice. It then opines that the ICJ should have declined to provide the Advisory Opinion on the security fence in view of its political nature by using the non-justiciability doctrine.
Chapter 2 discusses and examines the practical application of the contentious and controversial doctrine of non-justiciability by applying it to the Advisory Opinion. It strongly contends that even though the case had a legal side, “yet in the balance between law and politics, the scales tend to tilt towards the latter”. The chapter further argues that the ICJ in fact hinted that if the fence was erected along the Green Line and not on occupied territory, it could have been considered legal. The author takes the position that since the legality of the fence was attached to the legality of settlements, the ICJ had no option except to align with one of the two rival narratives, i.e. either consider settlement illegal, uphold international humanitarian law, and protect Palestinians, or condone the existence of the fence and protect the right to life of Israeli settlers. In the author's view, even if the ICJ would have applied international law in these scenarios the outcome would have been substantially political in nature, and quite dependent upon how the ICJ chooses to consider these issues. The chapter further discusses the presence of a political nature which leads to the non-justiciability lato sensu due to the ultra vires character of the requesting resolution, the alleged bias of Judge Elaraby, the political motives behind the request, and its highly technical character, as well as the substantial lack of evidence on the route of the fence.
Chapter 3 elaborates the response and attitude of the Israeli Supreme Court to the ICJ Advisory Opinion and how it allowed the use of international law in the domestic sphere. Discussing two Israeli Supreme Court cases, the author opines that the Supreme Court by its coherent jurisprudence set the issue on a more realistic basis by disconnecting the legality of settlements and their protection, and hence avoided expressing a stance on the legality of Israel's settlement policy, and also managed to condone the security fence without condoning the Israeli settlement. The biggest strength of this book is its subject matter, i.e. the justiciability of the international disputes, as the author has painstakingly analyzed the justiciability of the Advisory Opinion as lato sensu and stricto sensu by referring to the international disputes that are suitable for adjudication. The international and domestic cases discussed in the book are quite useful in order to provide a thorough understanding of the issue, most importantly the Israeli point of view. The author has indeed made a strong case to illustrate that it is possible to bypass critical political questions by the national courts and yet allow the use of international law in the domestic sphere. As mentioned, the author provides an excellent comparison of Israeli domestic cases with the Advisory Opinion, making the book quite useful.
Overall, Solomon's book is an excellent contribution not only to understanding the Israeli perspective on the ICJ's Advisory Opinion on the construction of security fence, but also to identifying and analyzing the concept of justiciability and its ever-increasing relevance in any international disputes. It will indeed be a good addition to the library of anyone who is interested in the topic.
