Despite John Lewis Gaddis's turn-of-the-century prediction, historians have proved that there is still much to be learnt from American sources about US involvement in the Cold War. Richard H. Cummings, author of Cold War Radio: The Dangerous History of American Broadcasting in Europe, 1950–1989 (2009) and former director of security at Radio Free Europe, demonstrates in his new book that this is indeed the case. His book provides the first major study of the Crusade for Freedom, a subject which had previously been “just a historical reference note … to the linear history of the Cold War” (2). Utilizing recently declassified government sources, he documents how the US government, private industry and academia worked together to mobilize the American people, to raise financial and moral support for Radio Free Europe and support for the ideological crusade against communism. His account is detailed and provides a good overview of the Crusade's history at both a national and a local level, from the Crusade's origins in the late 1940s until its change of name in 1962. Documenting the decisions and developments of the Crusade's national body, the National Committee for the Freedom of Europe (NCFE), Cummings's study illustrates US government involvement in what was supposed to be a privately run campaign. Kept secret to prevent Radio Free Europe's association with a national US agenda, the NCFE received financial support from the CIA and direction from the State Department. Cummings, himself a former employee of Radio Free Europe, views the deception as “benign fraud,” believing that the Crusade “probably gave most Americans what they wanted anyway: pageantry, a feeling of belonging and contributing to a justified cause” (3). His study is the first to provide a full and in-depth exposé of the secret state involvement in the Crusade.
Whilst thorough, his account is a little dry. Developments are recalled with excessive and often inconsequential detail and reading the book feels rather like reading a fleshier version of the chronology that he includes in the appendices. Furthermore, his tome lacks any argumentative thrust, simply providing a blow-by-blow account of the Crusade's history. After briefly sketching the Crusade's origins, in the opening section, Cummings dedicates the rest of his study to the Crusade's annual campaigns. Each chapter is dedicated to one of these campaigns and divided into short, sharp sections which skip chronologically between developments at the national level, local campaign activities and developments at Radio Free Europe. Understanding that “there are too many local stories of civic duty and activities to be covered in one book,” Cummings manages to skilfully provide an overview of the Crusade's local activities (3). His samples demonstrate the truly national impact of the campaign, the consistent public support that the campaigns received, and the huge variety of campaign activities that Americans engaged with. However, as with the rest of his study, we must draw these conclusions ourselves. The tome is left unconcluded, as are the chapters, and Cummings makes no effort to analyse his findings. What was the impact of the Crusade for Freedom on ordinary Americans? Did the Crusade for Freedom satisfy its goals? Just how important a role did the Crusade play in the US Cold War effort? These are just some of the important questions that are not given explicit answers, omissions which devalue Cummings's study somewhat.
His study, however, satisfies his own goals. He adds to the Cold War historiography by correcting some previously inaccurate detail about the Crusade and Radio Free Europe and fills in some details garnered from his research. Correct that “there will never be only one book on the Crusade for Freedom” (3), he nevertheless could have offered an interpretation based on the evidence currently available. For those interested in understanding how the Crusade for Freedom developed, worked and ended, Cummings's study is of considerable use, but those keen to understand the effectiveness of the Crusade in the ideological battle against communism will have to wait, as that book is yet to be written. With a great wealth of material on the Crusade locked away in US government archives and great swathes of Crusade documents yet to be located, there is still much to learn about the Crusade for Freedom. Despite this study's obvious shortcomings Cummings's detailed documentation provides the first important tent pole in our understanding of the Crusade for Freedom. However, a more analytical approach is needed if we are to garner a greater understanding of the Crusade and its place within the US Cold War effort.
