This book provides a comparative analysis of how women have fared in three very different neighboring states: Pakistan, Afghanistan, and Iran. The author's aim is to examine whether shared cultural, religious, and social characteristics translate into similar policies and outcomes, and if not, what other variables are involved (p. 4). The author's main focus is state legislation, and the strength of this book lies in its accounts of the impact of legislation on individual women. Less space is dedicated to the specific historical and political factors at play in the formation of each state or regime and their impact on gender politics. In her discussion, therefore, legislation related to gender is somewhat divorced from the wider social and political context in which it occurs. The author does not engage with conceptual issues despite the extensive and sophisticated body of literature that exists on issues of Middle Eastern state formation, colonialism, Westernization, modernization, nationalism, gender, and Islamism.
Throughout the book, the author states that concepts such as social justice, equality, freedom, and popular sovereignty are Western in origin and have no history in the non-Western world (e.g., p. 183). This approach has been subject to extensive criticism yet has remained prominent largely outside academia as part of a political project that seeks to justify intervention in the Middle East on the basis of bringing democracy, women's liberation, and freedom to the region. Other than repeated descriptions of Muslim-majority societies as conservative, backward, and patriarchal, there is no discussion of the broader political impact of issues of gender, conflict, and religion in the region.
Although this is a book that is focused on the politics of gender in Muslim-majority societies, there is very little analysis of Muslim women's organizations. Where they are mentioned, the discussion of them is brief with few details on how they were formed, the shape of their politics, or the background of their participants and leaders. The lack of focus on women as historical agents with politics in their own right is partly due to the book's overwhelming focus on the legislation itself. Missing is the impact of this legislation on women across geographies, classes, the religious/secular spectrum, ethnicity, and political orientations. It thus tends to homogenize women as a group and treat them as passive victims of patriarchal laws and practices.
Because women are portrayed as passive objects, there is also no mention of how women in the region resist patriarchal gender laws. For example, in the chapter on Afghanistan under the Taliban, the author lists and rightly condemns the gender laws enacted by that regime (pp. 134–35). However, there is no mention of the well-documented, widespread resistance to the Taliban, such as the network of underground girls schools that were set up by women in direct contravention of laws banning female education. The author asserts that there was little resistance to the Taliban, providing only one example in which women publically removed the burqa.
The treatment of religion and culture is similarly brief and homogenizes extremely diverse groups, intellectual trends, and movements. The “mullahs” are assumed to be a homogenous group (p. 27) and there is no recognition of the existence of competing religio-political outlooks, differing interests, class divides, or relationships to specific regimes. For example, the author argues that all Iranian “mullahs” opposed Reza Pahlavi Shah's mandatory removal of the headscarf in 1936 (p. 191), whereas opposition to the shah was in fact multifaceted and complex. Much of the upper-class religious establishment connected to the regime advocated quietism or approved the legislation, while some of those opposed to the shah either supported unveiling or came from areas of the country where veiling was uncommon.
The author does concede that religion alone is not solely responsible for women's oppression in Muslim-majority countries, and at points she discusses the relationship between patriarchy, politics, the nature of the state, and the interpretation of the shariʿa (p. 51). However, in her use of terms such as “traditional culture” or “conservatism,” the author shows little appreciation for the fact that in the Middle East, as in the West, ideas of what constitutes traditional culture or strands of political or social conservatism are not timeless or ahistorical but rather relatively recent political constructs.
The book's final chapters touch on the impact of widespread poverty, conflict, and war on women in these countries. Interestingly, the author quotes female Afghan activists who are critical of the policies of the Afghan government and the forces occupying that country (p. 149). The words of Malalai Joya are not analyzed but are worth returning to here:
The only change that can make us hopeful about the future is the strengthening and expansion of a national anti-fundamentalist and democracy-loving movement. Such a movement can be built only by Afghans. And while we want the world's support and solidarity, we neither need nor want Nato's occupying forces. (p. 159)
This book contains some fascinating accounts of state legislation. However, it is hampered by its lack of analysis of the pressing issues of war, poverty, state, and patriarchal gender relations, which are not static but evolving in a changing political climate.
