What was the experience of the ancient brothel like for clients and for prostitutes? Was the business a profitable one for the owners? These are among the questions this welcome new book addresses in the context of the most extensive discussion we have to date of Pompeii's famous Purpose-Built Brothel (PBB).
Despite its importance, this edifice, with its Pompeian address of 7.12.18–20, has received intense scrutiny only in recent decades. This trend began just over a quarter century ago with a pathbreaking contribution by Andrew Wallace-Hadrill, who called attention to its usefulness for the identification of brothels in general.Footnote 1 The monograph under review, with its wealth of both information and speculation about this building, marks a significant development and will no doubt encourage further scholarly attention.
What the book offers is above all a series of reflections on themes of distinct importance. Among the most prominent is the idea that the ground floor of the PBB is not just the best-attested but the sole example of a brothel surviving in our material evidence. Equally significant is the point that this was not a low-end establishment, as many believe, but operated as a more elegant house of courtesans. Yet other discussions of interest center on the lines of sight and erotic frescoes on the ground floor, as well as the function of the upstairs level. The single most valuable contribution of the book perhaps lies in its examination of the material finds, which treads new and promising ground.
In a brief introduction Levin-Richardson sets forth some fundamentals of her methodology, which is based on restrictive criteria for the identification of possible brothels.Footnote 2 Reliance on the co-presence of all three of Wallace-Hadrill's benchmarks (“1. masonry bed in a small room easily accessible to the public; 2. sexually explicit frescoes; 3. cluster of sexually explicit graffiti”) results in the emergence of the PBB as the only brothel that can be identified as such both at Pompeii, it seems, and in the entire Roman world. But while Wallace-Hadrill was writing in a climate of scholarly opinion which seemed to push the totals of Pompeian brothels ever higher, Levin-Richardson's attention to the social and economic aspects of the sale of sex might have benefited from a more expansive consideration of possible venues. Her approach promises a payoff smaller than desired by anyone hoping that the first book dedicated to the PBB might help us recognize other brothels in the archaeological record.
Chapter 1, “Architecture”, offers much of interest. Levin-Richardson draws comparisons between the size of the masonry beds, which she terms “platforms,” in the cellae of the ground floor of the brothel and that of Roman beds/couches recovered from other contexts.Footnote 3 The evidence, as she presents it,Footnote 4 does not seem to support the inference that two (or more) individuals routinely dined and drank on these (see 25).Footnote 5 The author appears to assume that the owner(s) of the brothel preferred masonry beds in order to sustain an atmosphere of elegance and comfort in the cellae. A more persuasive motive is perhaps that they were easier and cheaper to maintain than any obvious alternatives, testifying to a high volume of use by prostitutes and clients.Footnote 6
These details are worth mentioning because in my view they represent a tendency on the author's part to make the PBB seem like a nicer place than it was likely actually to have been. There is a risk of romanticizing the experience of prostitution in this locale through ascription of such behavior as “cuddling” or the exchange of “witty banter” between customers and prostitutes, given the lack of evidence for such activities on site (see 13, 116, 128).Footnote 7 Another example is the idea that prostitutes and customers formed “an affective community” (63). So also, perhaps, the author's preference for describing the pimps who, despite the lack of evidence, it is reasonable to assume operated the brothel, with the euphemism “managers” (see, for example, 36). This brothel was a site of violence, especially sexual violence, so rendering its atmosphere, in my view, darker and less pleasant than what Levin-Richardson seeks to present.Footnote 8 This book might have done more to illuminate the cruelty characteristic of Roman prostitution.
One of the most original contributions of the volume is the detailed discussion of lines of sight on the ground floor. The more numerous of these would have operated internally, that is, between the different cellae and the corridor. But the most interesting one involves the visual axis running between the doorway 19 on the street with the modern name Vicolo del Balcone Pensile and Cella B, one of the five rooms on the ground floor that are equipped with masonry beds. The author engages in a robust round of speculation over the role of surveillance and control of the movements of clients and prostitutes notionally exercised by the occupant of that room.Footnote 9
This interesting discussion might also have taken account of possible differentials in lighting. Daylight, meaning above all bright Mediterranean sunshine, seems likely to have privileged the view out over the view in, while the darkness of night may have reversed this advantage, especially if there were an artificial source of light within. Even so, the view might have been blocked at any time by closing the door to the street or the curtain to the cella. A potential client may in the best of circumstances have gained only a glimpse of what lay inside. This raises the possibility that the person (or persons) controlling the visual axis was in a position to manipulate the view, the access, and even the sexual interest of passersby. The idea is a tantalizing one, but sadly lies beyond proof.
The next chapter (Chapter 2, “Material Finds”) is devoted to the objects found on the main part of the ground floor. The examination of this assemblage of artifacts, along with those linked to the upper floor and its approach, must rank among the most important contributions of the book. The author confronts a double challenge: first, none of the dozen items under study has ever been photographed or can be located for examination today; second, their findspots (all but one of these objects were recovered from the same room, Cella FFootnote 10) may reflect urgent measures taken in the face of the city's imminent doom and not everyday practice, rendering them less serviceable for drawing conclusions about their function than one would like. Levin-Richardson's inclination to identify some items with serving the purpose of bodily care as opposed to the preparation and consumption of food and drink in some respects sits crosswise with her argument that the ground floor offered visitors more than sex. This is because, as she recognizes, there is a zero-sum relationship between the time clients spent engaged in the latter and in any other conceivable activity. But even if we were able to identify with certainty the function and original location of every item, they are simply too few in number to allow for much by way of definitive conclusions about the typical operation of the ground floor of the PBB. Are we really to believe that in the normal course of things, this establishment sported only a pair of glass cups, one glass bottle, and a single terracotta lamp? And yet – for these types of objects – that, regrettably, is what we have remaining.Footnote 11
In Chapter 3, “Graffiti”, Levin-Richardson asserts that graffiti in the brothel show that its walls served as a “community message board” (61–63), arguing that some of the epigraphs that
. . . include greetings, show multiple hands at work, or convey conversations in progress speak to the time that individuals spent creating, reading, and responding to these messages. This outlay of time and effort has implications – like the distribution of graffiti – for the economics of the brothel. Rather than aiming to get clients in and out as fast as possible, the brothel allowed individuals to linger, peruse previous graffiti and perhaps experience moments of discovery at new additions, and to leave one's mark (63).
This is to place a great weight upon what appears to be only a small percentage of the epigraphs preserved for this site. Levin-Richardson might have been clearer about exactly which examples she bases her claim on. From the context these appear to number no more than about a dozen, though she may intend more. For a moment, one might step back and contemplate a bigger picture, insofar as this presents itself to us. The impression of a coin in the plaster of a wall in Cella F shows a date of 72 CE.Footnote 12 This allows scholars to date the final phase of the PBB to the period from 72 until its destruction in 79. So at one point (14) the author also cites the same span of time for this final ancient renovation, though elsewhere (44, 173 n. 69) she dates it precisely to 72.
This date, as an approximation, is serviceable for many purposes. But when it is a matter of estimating numbers of clients and their relative frequency, we do better to inquire more closely. The first point to make is that 72 is a terminus post quem, meaning, of course, that this is the date the coin was minted, not necessarily when it was impressed into wet plaster on the wall. This could have happened just a few months or even days before the city's destruction. If so, it would add considerable weight to Levin-Richardson's argument. On the other hand, the renovation might have occurred closer to 72, and/or only in that room. Either of these latter possibilities would reduce its utility for her purpose. To be clear, none of this proves that Levin-Richardson is wrong in her claims concerning the brothel's operation, but only suggests that this particular dataset has inherent limitations.
Chapter 4, “Frescoes”, discusses the well-known series of eight paintings in the PBB with depictions of erotic themes. Six, one of which is damaged, show a series of heterosexual couples having sex. A seventh depicts a man and a woman gazing at a painting, itself presumably representing a sex act, while an eighth features a likeness of Priapus with two erect phalluses. The eight panels are all found in the main corridor of the ground floor, located above the level of the lintels of the doorways to the cellae and clearly visible to any visitor to this part of the brothel.
In this chapter, Levin-Richardson makes a bold argument: it is not the presence, but the absence, of certain features in the art that was designed to be erotically stimulating to the male customers of the PBB. Here she grapples with the dominant opinion, first advanced by John Clarke, that views these paintings as representations of luxury, expressing an upper-class sexual esthetic for the benefit of low-status clients and standing in contrast to the more austere physical appointments of the brothel itself. She sets forth three points in response: “ . . . that the absence of certain problematic sexual acts, explicit poses, and markers of status in the brothel's frescoes would have facilitated viewers’ experiences of desire” (65). Although Clarke hardly ignores the first two, they are not foundational for his argument that the representation of luxury in the hallway contrasts with the poverty of actual conditions in the cellae. In fact, he shows that the single erotic panel, apart from that depicting Priapus, without a sexual act as its main subject most dramatically and successfully communicates a sense of upper-class refinement.Footnote 13 A similar conclusion flows from the other, more explicit paintings, namely, that they depict a version of sexual experience that is consistent with the goal of creating the impression of an elite sexual ambience. This would suggest that Levin-Richardson's arguments, which bear considerable interest, actually support Clarke's thesis.Footnote 14
As for her third point, about markers of status, Clarke has already offered abundant evidence to the contrary, but it is possible to say a bit more. Toward the end of Chapter 4 Levin-Richardson asserts that the point was to obscure the status of the painted figures so as to encourage “ . . . clients of any status to identify with, or objectify, the figures” (78), which she also describes as renderings of “generic individuals” (65). This is a more difficult argument to advance than it might at first seem. The paintings successfully convey the sense of a lifestyle of leisure and luxury in which fit, attractive, youthful individuals are shown having sex in upscale surroundings. Levin-Richardson relies heavily on the omission of slaves/servants, who, in the conventions of Roman painting, serve as markers for the high status of the principals (78–79). At best, this is an argument from absence, but not even their absence is guaranteed. One of the frescoes (5) portrays a woman standing fully clothed next to a bed. As Clarke points out, it is impossible to rule out her status as a servant.Footnote 15
Despite the attempt by the author to close the gap in luxury between the representations on the wall and the reality of the stalls (see 77), important differences remain, even if we limit our focus to one key item. The boxy, unyielding masonry beds, even with the minimum of painted decoration at least some once seem to have featured (red ribbons: 26), simply cannot compete with the delicate and refined appearance of the beds in the frescoes.Footnote 16 These masonry beds no doubt sported some form of coverings, but of course these have long since disappeared, making it impossible to compare this feature with the rich appointments of the beds in the paintings.
Toward the end of her argument the author advances another point regarding status, suggesting, “ . . . the fact that the female figures in the frescoes also lack clear status markers meant that a male client would not have to fear expressing desire for individuals who were off-limits in real life, such as elite girls and married women” (79, note omitted). Roman status was ideally expressed through clothing: you were what you wore. The challenge in this case, of course, is that we confront a group of figures who are mostly nude or at least scantily clad. What evidence we have for status in these paintings regards instead personal adornment, fashion accessories, and general ambience. All of this suggests, to be sure, an elite atmospheric.
The author's argument, moreover, betrays a misunderstanding of the Augustan adultery law. Criminals were punished by this statute for acts, not thoughts or their expression. Contemplating sex with a respectable woman was not a crime, and such fantasies went unpunished. It is important to recognize that the lex Iulia de adulteriis coercendis legitimized prostitution, which in the legislator's conception acted as a bulwark against the acts it criminalized. Commitment to the role of commercial sex in the safeguarding of chastity both predates Augustus, as a famous anecdote concerning Cato the Elder illustrates, and is hardwired into his law on adultery.Footnote 17 From a policymaker's perspective, male clients at the PBB were performing their civic duty. Whatever fantasy served this purpose was all to the good, provided it remained a fantasy, of course. No Roman was going to be punished under the criminal law for thinking dirty thoughts in a brothel.
At the root of the difficulty lies a failure to grasp the implications of the fresco program's presentation of the idea of sex with higher-status women to the male clientele.Footnote 18 This aspiration, broadly speaking, was an important attraction of the PBB. The brothel functioned as a kind of male fantasy camp in which the idea, however remote the actual prospect, of sex with a higher-status woman, meaning the opportunity to enjoy and humiliate her, was one of the draws. Caligula's installation of a lupanar on the Palatine sought to bring the aspiration to life. The use of brothels as trysting places itself raised the possibility for a prospective client of an encounter on site with a woman who was not a prostitute. It was not just sexual pleasure that attracted men to such places, but the idea of transgression, seasoned perhaps by a certain degree of risk. So the fantasy of sex with upper-class women comes to be reflected in brothel decoration in a manner perfectly consistent with the law, social values, and the perceived needs of clients. Clarke's verdict on the PBB's frescoes must stand: “These are all artistic constructions that point to environments far removed from the realities of the lupanar. In half the paintings in the lupanar, illustration of sexual positions was a secondary consideration. Instead, they encode fantasies of upperclass sexual luxuries for viewers who could not afford them.”Footnote 19
In Chapter 5, “The Upper Floor”, Levin-Richardson offers a survey of the evidence from this part of the PBB, which has been relatively understudied compared with the downstairs. Giuseppe Fiorelli was the first to suggest that this too functioned as a brothel. He made this argument in 1862, soon after he uncovered the building, citing a bronze bell found in the doorway to this second story in the context of certain literary evidence.Footnote 20 Levin-Richardson counters that bronze bells have been found in a number of buildings of various types at Pompeii (81). Fiorelli does not in fact claim that such bells are found only in brothels, and it is worth keeping in mind that this is, after all, the upper floor of an establishment securely identifiable as a brothel like no other from antiquity.
Fiorelli has managed to generate some confusion on the subject. He garbles the quotation of a Latin source in support of his argument for an association of bells with brothels, perhaps because he is citing this from memory, alleging that its author was the Carolingian scholar Paul the Deacon: includebant in angusto prostibula et admittentes tintinnabula percutiebant, ut eo sono illarum iniuria fieret manifesta.Footnote 21 Levin-Richardson accepts the attribution and bravely attempts to translate this nonsensical text, but to little purpose.Footnote 22 She and Fiorelli are wrong about not only the wording but the author and work. This is not Paul the Deacon, but Landolfus Sagax, who produced his Historia Romana around 1000.Footnote 23
The literary evidence aside, the heft of the book's argument concerning the upper floor is that because evidence for none of Wallace-Hadrill's three criteria of brothel identification is found there, this is more likely to have been a residence,Footnote 24 though “prostitution cannot be ruled out” (81). This premise is consistent with the approach taken throughout the volume, which is to privilege those criteria not only for the identification of brothels but even for the definition of such.
While the ground floor is lavishly photographed, we have no photographs for the upper story. The vital question of the date of construction does not arise. No measurements are given of the individual rooms, and important details are ignored. While there are occasional indications of autopsy, for the most part the author relies on the accounts and reconstructions of others.Footnote 25 Regarding the reconstruction of the walls on this floor, the author advances a position that seems to attribute key aspects of this to Antonio Sogliano, who supervised the first modern restoration of the PBB in the early 20th c., as opposed to Amedeo Maiuri, who oversaw the second.Footnote 26 This argument is plausible, but a few of the details, especially among those stuffed into an endnote (184 n. 15), require more discussion.
It is convenient to take the next three chapters, on “Male clients”, “Female prostitutes”, and then “Male prostitutes,” together. One is struck by the sheer amount of speculation in this part of the book, speculation that is in general clearly marked as such, using language that, though sometimes awkward, serves to my mind as an honest reflection of the state of our knowledge. To her credit, the author rejects the theory that women patronized the PBB as clients (129). There is no plausible basis for such a speculation.
One also finds an apparent self-contradiction in these pages. While initially Levin-Richardson stresses (99) the diversity of status of the brothel's clients, she later seems to view them as “of (roughly) equivalent status” (106). This confusion might have been avoided by pointing out that while the customers were of different legal statuses, including slaves, freeborn, and – very likely – freedmen, they all appear to share a low social status.
A similar difficulty arises with the author's theory that clients enjoyed in the PBB's ground-floor cellae an opportunity to indulge in ways of consuming alcohol she identifies as to “drink like free men” (101). Here again, however, it seems that social, rather than legal, status offers the crucial distinction. Elite practice was strongly marked by conviviality in a manner difficult to postulate for this venue.Footnote 27 Drinking alone, or with one's female sexual partner,Footnote 28 in a small, dark, and largely undecorated cella does not seem to approximate or even attempt to mimic this experience. If Levin-Richardson is correct about the specifics, the phenomenon might shed light on a non-elite, or even anti-elite, practice. The true difficulty remains the paucity of evidence for eating and drinking in the PBB, as highlighted by the author herself.
Levin-Richardson repeatedly reminds us that we cannot be certain who wrote the graffiti in the PBB (115, 119–20, 122). This praiseworthy caution does not prevent her from conjecturing that the brothel's female prostitutes produced a great number of these epigraphs. Lack of space forbids consideration of the debate over Roman literacy that has raged for over three decades.Footnote 29 One question in particular seems worth asking, however. If we postulate that female prostitutes, many of them slaves or ex-slaves, in a town like Pompeii were able both to read and to write graffiti, who would rank among the truly illiterate?Footnote 30
So what have we learned about the PBB? At one point the author characterizes a particular line of argument as “a thought experiment” (137). This label can in fact fairly characterize much of the volume, especially the last few chapters. One can disagree with the results, but on the subject of speculation the author merits a stout defense. In my opinion this element adds considerable value to the book. It is of great heuristic benefit, even where one finds oneself in disagreement. As it stands, this work is both “good to think with” and, notwithstanding my reservations, fun to read. The richness of conjecture, along with the impressive collection of data that the author has put at our disposal, are among its strongest assets.
A caveat worth registering all the same concerns, if not the sheer amount, the structure of some of the speculation, where the validity of one surmise depends on another holding true. In particular, the theory that the PBB functioned as a house of courtesans rests on a complex scaffolding of suppositions. Also worth observing is that throughout the conclusion a number of conjectures offered earlier in the book, and clearly indicated as such, are presented as facts. Two instances may suffice. First, “[t]he opposition between high-class courtesans who offer conversation, companionship, and drink, on the one hand, and low-status brothel prostitutes who offer only sex, on the other, is thus shown to not accurately reflect [sic] the reality of Roman sexual labor” (144). Next, “[a]s we have seen, prostitutes’ bodies were put on display for the pleasure of clients; they had to perform emotional labor by writing greetings to their clients or chatting them up while drinking with them or shaving them; they performed ideological work by writing boasts about their clients’ sexual prowess (or by having their voices used for such boasts); and they performed the physical labor of sex, shaving, and hauling water” (145).
This book emerges in the final analysis less perhaps as a traditional monograph that steadily pursues a single argument than as a bold and provocative contribution to an open-ended conversation among scholars. The manner in which it pursues its main claims (see 5) is perhaps in part a product of the author's “systematic” approach to describing the brothel, but it hardly gets in the way of presenting a series of interpretations that deserve particular attention.Footnote 31 Levin-Richardson asserts that the PBB operated as a house of courtesans along the lines of what we find in authors such as Athenaeus or Lucian.Footnote 32 Whatever one makes of this claim about its precise nature,Footnote 33 her attempt to elaborate a ‘business model’ is itself a shrewd move, in my opinion. Out of nowhere, however, she expresses a lack of confidence in this particular model's ability to thrive.Footnote 34 Given the ample evidence for the lucrativeness of the Roman sex trade, including the participation of elite investors, and the success of a tax that seems to have outrun the wildest expectations of its instigator, the emperor Caligula, one wonders whether this was the only brothel in the empire that did not turn a profit. More to the point, perhaps, if the business model was unsuccessful, why not change it?
The dust jacket of the book offers a reproduction of a painting of the exterior of the PBB by Gregorio Prieto. The image shows three women without clothing – or at least topless – on the balcony of the brothel's upper story, which is itself depicted as without a roof or an external wall that is more than waist high. This choice of illustration is a puzzling one, since the representation contradicts several arguments advanced in the book. One is that the upper floor was not used as a brothel, another is that the women who worked onsite presented themselves as courtesans, and a third concerns the reconstruction of the balcony, which most think was enclosed by a roof and an external wall with windows. This is not a book to judge by its cover.
