Partly occasioned by the 2005 centenary of his birth, Oppenheimer studies have boomed in the last few years. A string of new biographies by Gregg Herken, David Cassidy, Kai Bird and Martin Sherwin and others have offered important insights into this brilliant, cultivated, charismatic, yet deeply enigmatic character. Beyond the grim allure of his role as scientific director of the Manhattan Project, much of the enduring fascination with Oppenheimer lies in his iconic status as a science adviser and the symbolism of his fall from grace at the hands of the US Atomic Energy Commission (AEC) in 1954. To many he has become emblematic of the relationship between science and the post-war state.
Charles Thorpe's superbly engaging book is less a biography of Oppenheimer than a study of social identity and self-fashioning – the kind of analysis now familiar in the history of early modern science but rarer in twentieth-century work. Thorpe situates Oppenheimer at the centre of the cultural and ideological tensions of the post-war American polity. While the products of science were crucial to the emergent security state, the ideology of science was also crucial to the reconstruction of liberalism in the aftermath of the war. Yet while the bomb catapulted Oppenheimer to power, the awful ruins of Hiroshima and Nagasaki fatally compromised science's capacity to act as a unifying force. In this context, Oppenheimer tried simultaneously to enact the competing roles of ‘humanistic critic, technocrat and weaponeer’. In so doing, he embodied ‘the tensions between humanism and technological expertise that lie at the core of modern science and society’ (p. 10).
Within this larger framework, the central thrust of Thorpe's argument is that Oppenheimer was always putting on a performance, and fashioned different identities for himself at different times. Later in his career these different roles, accreted over many years and contexts, came increasingly to clash with each other. For Thorpe, the complexity of Oppenheimer's actions – and the consequences of the AEC hearing in 1954 – flow from this social schizophrenia.
The product of a privileged but emotionally repressed upbringing, the young Oppenheimer shaped his identity around his secular Jewishness and his physical frailty. While he developed a sophisticated cultural cosmopolitanism, theoretical physics emerged as his métier. He created a successful school of physics at Berkeley in the 1930s. Here his interest in Hinduism functioned as a form of ‘ornamental cultural capital’ (p. 54). He latched onto and emulated both the Sanskritist Arthur Ryder and Linus Pauling, and was in turn emulated by his own students. From 1936 he engaged with progressive Popular Front politics. Thorpe is less directly concerned than some of his other biographers with whether Oppenheimer was, or was not, a member of the Communist Party, and places more productive emphasis on Oppenheimer's self-fashioning through political involvement.
Thorpe takes a new line too on Oppenheimer's famously charismatic leadership. As he assumed a directing role in the Manhattan Project, Oppenheimer relied heavily on advice from Isidor Rabi, Robert Bacher and others on how to manage people and projects. At Los Alamos his charisma was performative, and played a key role in the construction of the laboratory's social order. His sprezzatura allowed him to mediate across the disparate groups and between civilians and the military – and thereby to control without seeming to do so. In this sense, Oppenheimer's charismatic leadership was a collective, co-constructed accomplishment. He was a made leader, not a born one.
His hegemonic charisma, coupled with the rigid regulation of workers' time through strict schedules, allowed Oppenheimer to suppress or redirect moral opposition to the use of the bombs. After the war, this same authority – which now began to approach ‘scientific messianism’ (p. 178) – made him the legitimate public voice of the atomic scientists and their concerns about nuclear weapons. But as the post-war security-state apparatus took shape with the onset of the Cold War, and as he tried simultaneously to advise the US government on new weapons and to represent the scientists' views in discussions of international arms control, it became less easy for Oppenheimer to manage his parallel discursive worlds.
The atomic espionage cases and McCarthyism of the early 1950s and his opposition to the H-bomb led to renewed suspicion of Oppenheimer. At the AEC hearings against him, his charisma and his reputation among his critics as a ‘scientific Svengali’ (p. 223) now became liabilities. Thorpe convincingly argues that Oppenheimer's critics cast doubt on his trustworthiness by undermining the coherence and consistency of his character. In this very public drama, the trial of Oppenheimer was part of a wider debate over the nature of scientific authority and the relationship between science, the security state and liberal democracy, including the proper conduct of the scientist as adviser.
After his excommunication, Oppenheimer reconstituted himself yet again, now modelling himself on Niels Bohr as a gnomic commentator on science, philosophy and culture. He continued to court the powerful and worked with the CIA-sponsored Congress for Cultural Freedom as an ambassador for the liberal democracy that had all but destroyed him. Defining and defending the position of the elite intellectual, he now presented himself as an embodied solution to the problems of cultural fragmentation made evident by his own biography. His oracular style was reinforced by his asceticism and his physical condition and comportment, which were often themselves ascribed moral meaning.
A partial rehabilitation by the award of the AEC's Fermi Medal in 1963 came late. By the time of his death in 1967, Oppenheimer had become closely associated with the image of the guilt-ridden nuclear scientist. For Thorpe, this final Oppenheimer was yet another performance, located now somewhere between tragedy and melodrama.
While many biographers have grappled with the complexities of Oppenheimer's character, Thorpe is the first to provide a thorough sociologically and culturally grounded analysis of this protean figure. The book's powerful, sophisticated and persuasive analysis adds new critical depth to our understanding of Oppenheimer. But he remains a symbol still: through him the book significantly changes the way we should think about post-war American science and twentieth-century science more generally.
