The post-Suharto era proved conducive for the expansion and re-examination of Indonesian history and historiography, both academic and popular. There emerged a veritable ‘history industry’ in the past 10 years as hundreds of titles have appeared that relate one way or another to history and memory. One characteristic of this development, as one may expect, is the dominance of the popular-type as opposed to the academic or scholarly ones.
Entitled Unfinished nation: Indonesia before and after Suharto, the book under review here is one in the more recent batch of work on this subject. By foregrounding the role of mass mobilisation politics in the nation-building process, it offers a provocative interpretation of the history of twentieth-century Indonesia, as it goes against the grain of much of Indonesia's mainstream nationalist historiography.
Max Lane asserts that Suharto did not just fall from power. He was pushed out of it, not by the elite and foreign forces, as many believed, but by the consciously developed protest movement – he calls aksi – that involved the participation of the Indonesian masses. He then draws a link between this anti-Suharto movement and other movements that preceded it, tracing the origin to as far back as the mass organisations that developed in the early 1900s. By doing so, he forcefully argues for, without unfortunately the corresponding adequate demonstration of, the centrality of mass movement in the process of nation-building, which he equates to the national revolution itself. If revolusi nasional is commonly referred to in conventional historiography as the period of armed and diplomatic struggles against the Dutch from 1945 to 1949, and Sukarno often sought to appropriate it to refer to the struggles during his time, Lane expands the scope of the concept to encapsulate the entire process of nation formation and transformation that Indonesia underwent from the early 1900s up to the mid-1960s. This process was aborted, so he claims, by the counter-revolution spearheaded by Suharto's New Order. Anyone familiar with Pramoedya Anata Toer's novels will easily recognise the provenance of these ideas. Often sidelined in the mainstream accounts of the development of Indonesia's nationalist historiography, Pramoedya's historical ideas, whose influence the author acknowledges generously, have found an extended and accessible expression, appropriation and elaboration beyond the pages of his novels.
To what extent mass politics in fact contributed as an engine of nation-formation is crucial to the assessment of the book. The author's answer to this question, spelled out in detail in Chapters 6–9, is probably among the most debatable among his assertions. Against the backdrop of the sizeable amount of literature on nation- and/or state-building in Indonesia that focus on the role of the state, the relative weakness of the civil society, and the political and intellectual elites in the process, the alleged centrality of the role of the masses in this process is certainly not easy to demonstrate convincingly. One may raise a valid question, for instance, as to whether the purported huge membership of mass organisations from the 1900s to the 1990s can be a reliable measure of mass involvement in what he calls revolusi nasional. The book, I am afraid, starts and ends up asserting too much. Be that as it may, the book is important for forcing a re-thinking of this question.
This book is not a work of academic history and it does not seem to pretend to be anyway. Anyone who expects tightly substantiated assertions, packed bibliography, conscientious documentation of sources, and a demonstration of familiarity with a wide range of literature, is bound to be disappointed. Written with journalistic flair, with a prose both engaging and engaged, it would be wrong to dismiss the book offhand on account of its journalistic character. The author displays intimate knowledge of the situation on the ground. As he observes political developments in Indonesia at a close range, even knowing personally some of the key players, he offers a wealth of information and insights that a serious analyst could ignore only at one's own peril.
To appreciate the potential long-term significance of this book, allow me to cite a possible parallel case in Philippine historiography. For long before the 1950s, the Philippine Revolution of 1896 had been thought to be a handmade of the bourgeois nationalists — as an offshoot of the ideas of the propagandists such as José Rizal, Marcelo Del Pilar, Lopez Jaena and others. The role of the masses had been downplayed. The publication of Teodoro Agoncillo's book The revolt of the masses in 1956 helped pave the way for the radicalisation of nationalist consciousness. Along with Renato Constantino's The past revisited and the continuing past, Agoncillo's book had instilled in the minds of the young generation the idea of the masses as an engine of historical change. It constituted a shift in the mindset that had an enormous impact on shaping the political landscape in the Philippines since the 1960s. Given the difference in the context, it may be too much to expect that a similar break would happen in Indonesia. What seems reasonable, given the increasing fascination with the left-leaning ideas within the growing circles of students and intellectuals in Indonesia, is that if and when the historiography of the leftist ideas in Indonesia is finally written, Lane's book would occupy a space not only as a populariser of Pramoedya's historical ideas, but as a creative appropriation in its own right of the Marxist analysis.
Indonesian studies in general have been known for being lukewarm to class analysis. Aside from the work of a few notable scholars, one would be hard pressed to find studies that are suffused with Marxist approaches. Things have begun to change in the post-Suharto years as the stigma attached to left-leaning approaches and ideas, while remaining very strong in public, has nonetheless begun to show signs of abating at least within certain intellectual circles. That this book was written is in itself a sign of the time. It is a welcome addition to the growing corpus of work in this genre.
