It would be hard to find anyone in the field who hasn't done it at least once, or more likely on multiple occasions: dipped into a favorite Restoration and eighteenth-century stage chronicle to recover just the right factoid or anecdote to suit the narrative under construction without reflecting either on the contemporary standing of the source or meditating on the historiographical value, intent, and effect of that work as a whole. In his useful and illuminating study, Writing the History of the British Stage, 1660–1900, Richard Schoch clears a space for us to consider the works from which we draw those anecdotes not simply as storehouses to be raided but rather as substantive histories in their own right. Working meticulously through the archives, Schoch sounds these texts both for what they indicate about the state of the art of theatre history in their time and for the ways they constitute theatre as a subject worthy of historical investigation. He thus offers us not just “a history of British theatre history” (1) but also a treatment of these texts that considers them “less as neutral sourcebooks and more as valid interpretations of the theatrical past” (3).
Schoch's volume is divided into nine chapters, plus an introduction, prelude, interlude, and postlude offering broad overviews of how the methods, practices, and forms of theatre history responded over time to larger historiographical movements and sensibilities. Concentrating on works that “best illustrate … the major historiographical developments of their time,” he attempts to demonstrate “why historical writing took the shape that it did at a certain time and in a certain place” (11–12). Schoch begins his study with a chapter on early printed dramas and the lists of plays for sale assembled by Restoration booksellers. Working through a discussion of Francis Kirkman's 1671 catalog, which compassed more than eight hundred plays, Schoch makes a convincing case for considering these understudied play lists, and the printed texts they indexed, as some of the first “conveyors of theatre historical information” (66). Schoch then continues with a chapter on James Wright's Historia Histrionica (1699). Where other scholars have treated this text as a mere source of information, Schoch emphasizes the deep awareness of changing performance practices that lies behind Wright's account of the English stage. This line of thought is extended as well in Chapter 4, where Schoch argues that John Downes's Roscius Anglicanus (1708) was the first to develop a historical awareness of acting genealogies and hence an understanding that, in the act of performance, live theatre also constitutes its own embodied archive.
Across the chapters, Schoch traces not only the immediate reception of the historical works in question but also how the information they conveyed was corrected and supplemented in later editions and theatrical compendia. In one of the most fascinating cases, Chapter 3 explores the paths taken by various annotated copies of Gerard Langbaine's An Account of the English Dramatick Poets (1691) to show how the vastly overwritten and interleaved pages featuring transcriptions, updates, and edits of successive generations of scholars created a legacy of “amalgamated commentaries” (137). In similar fashion, Chapter 5 traces the various iterations of the Biographia Dramatica (1782), which had its origins in David Erskine Baker's The Companion to the Play-House (1764), to demonstrate how the changing content over three editions provides us with a material “index to the changing practice of British theatre history” into the early nineteenth century (165). Here as well as in Chapter 6, which explores the fate of Robert Dodsley's attempt at a narrative history in his “Preface” to A Select Collection of Old Plays (1744), Schoch reveals a “move away from antiquarian collectivity toward the predominance of the solo scholar” (165).
This shift is much lamented in Schoch's study, and his treatment of Edmond Malone and John Payne Collier in Chapters 8 and 9 reflects Schoch's view that, in their isolated grandeur, these giants sacrificed readability to obsessive documentation. Even as their methods took earlier antiquarian mania to its logical conclusion, their emergence also marked the end of the collaborative approach to theatre history so palpable in those earlier works, and drove live performance, if not entirely off the page, at least to the margins of the documentable page.
Highlighting the paucity of grand narratives and lost opportunities for generating interpretations from massive accumulations of facts, Schoch situates Colley Cibber, whose stature and contributions have also been recently reevaluated by Elaine McGirr (Palgrave Macmillan, 2016) and Julia Fawcett (University of Michigan Press, 2016), as the exemplary figure whose Apology (1740) illustrates the road not taken in British theatre history. Extolled here both for his engagement with live theatrical performance and for the strategically self-deprecating narrative style that enabled him to elevate theatre as a subject of history, Cibber models “the need for historians to perform for their readers” (247; original emphasis).
At least three motifs emerge over the course of the study. First, Schoch repeatedly observes the compulsion to smooth over ruptures produced by the English Civil War and to draw lines of continuity between the contemporary moment and earlier periods in theatrical production. Second, Schoch consistently distinguishes between the history of the stage as a history of texts or as a history of performance, and clearly favors the latter over the former. Third, while he recognizes that antiquarians “pioneered the navigational tools that we still rely upon today” (39), he regrets that that mania for discovery often precluded the development of more compelling narrative accounts of the British stage. This last point brings us to one of the few shortcomings of this volume: Schoch's own failure to provide a satisfying, historiographic explanation for this absence. But that should not distract us in any way from the overall achievement represented here.
Indeed, this study is ultimately a valuable meditation on what it means to practice theatre history and to think about the genealogies of historical practice that we have inherited and have made part of our own embodied repertoire. It invites us, moreover, to think about how the histories we write today not only reflect current assumptions about the practice, but also about how those works will be viewed, used, and construed by those in the future who follow in our footsteps.
