The unpardonable distortion of nineteenth-century American melodrama depicts a frail heroine, tied to railroad tracks by a mustached villain and abandoned to her fate. Only at the very last moment is she rescued from the crushing wheels of a locomotive by a robustly male hero who saves the day. But this misconstrued scene never existed and altogether inverts the central, most popular episode from Augustin Daly's 1867 Under the Gaslight. In that drama's fourth act, Laura Courtland, locked for her own protection in a railway toolshed, witnesses Snorkey, a one-armed Civil War veteran, bound by the drama's villain to the rails in the path of an approaching express train. Laura seizes an “American axe” (11), hacks her way free of the shed and, as the train's headlamp appears onstage, severs the ropes binding the mutilated man. In Under the Gaslight there is no male assistance—no active–passive binary of hero and heroine. The rescuing agent is female, a “true woman” (136, emphasis in Hughes): assertive, brave, self-reliant. Yet in 1867, she is still decades away from enjoying suffrage; Snorkey tells us as much: “And these are the women who ain't to have the vote” (Daly, qtd. in Hughes 118).
The event in which Laura's courage and initiative are demonstrated richly enacts the particular circumstances of nineteenth-century gender and political issues. These issues, and theatre audiences' various readings of this landmark “sensation scene,” constitute one of the core subjects of Amy Hughes's superb study of American melodrama. Through her identification and penetrating analyses of key Victorian melodramatic sensation scenes, and her critical grasp of telling cultural details informing these scenes, Hughes directs our gaze to stage performances and dramatic texts that earlier scholars skated over. Immaculately researched, fluent, lucid, and unpretentious, Hughes's intense concentration on specific scenes, with emphasis on their cultural content and contexts, imparts a method of enquiry that reaches well beyond this study.
In successive chapters, Hughes focuses upon three noted sensation scenes: Laura Courtland, her axe, and the on-rushing locomotive (Chapter 4); the quadroon Eliza, in Uncle Tom's Cabin, fleeing with her child from slave catchers and their bloodhounds across the broken ice floes of the Ohio River to the safety of the northern states (Chapter 3); and the spectacle of the raving drunkard, the monster at the family hearth, performed by male actors, some of them reformed (or only intermittently reformed) alcoholics, each acting the paroxysms and hallucinations of delirium tremens, and seeking to dissuade theatre patrons from strong drink (Chapter 2). Underlying all of these sensations, Hughes notes undeclared yet explicit pressures for widespread reform and the establishment of national “norms” regarding temperance, the abolition of slavery, and female suffrage. Citing Victorian dramatists' disregard for Aristotelian priorities, Hughes notes the ocular nature of these appeals, in which the visual overrides and augments most verbal arguments (40).
In her first and second chapters, “The Body as/in/at the Spectacle” and “The Delirium Tremens: Spectacular Insanity in The Drunkard,” Hughes identifies the actor's body as the site of conflict. Setting appears almost immaterial in the spectacle of the drunkard, although the meaner the disheveled room, the more the actor—always male—spoke to his degradation. The actor, drawing on and graphically exhibiting his own experiences of bodily agonies, cramps, choking thirst, and delusions, enacted how addiction destroyed the home, alienated him from his family, and brought poverty, ostracism, and even madness (a female affliction) upon those who sought to love and support him. Such performances of the “DTs” were the nadir of the drunkard's trajectory (69–77). However, temperance melodrama promised eventual recovery, sobriety, the reestablished family, a healed community, and even modest prosperity. Hughes identifies two actors, Harry Watkins and John B. Gough, who performed onstage and lectured from the platform, in both instances drawing on their own experiences of alcoholic excess, dementia, and precarious sobriety. Both attained notoriety when they fell off the wagon, and both made their recoveries the stuff of further drama and testimony (78–85).
Hughes employs a different approach to examine Uncle Tom's Cabin; because there were several prominent adaptations of Harriet Beecher Stowe's novel and because the play has both extensive ante- and postbellum stage histories, Hughes, in her chapter “The Fugitive Slave: Eliza's Flight in Uncle Tom's Cabin,” focuses not on actors but on play variants. Critically, she explains that national law identified escaped slaves as stolen property and pointed to the fugitive slave's culpability in stealing herself (87). Eliza and her husband George would thus have been read as thieves by rural and regional audiences, but less so by the abolitionist-leaning audiences of New York State who were the play's primary witnesses (90–1). Hughes again emphasizes the singularity of female desperation and courage as Eliza subjects herself to a passage across the ice that her male pursuers refuse similarly to attempt (91).
As Eliza is partly identified by the prop baby she carries, and partly by the widely advertised pack of bloodhounds pursuing her, so Laura Courtland is partly identified by her axe. Hughes anatomizes this implement, describing its progression from a clumsy British tool into the well-balanced “American axe” that cleared forests and became the fetishized symbol of Abraham Lincoln, “The Rail-Splitter”—“not merely a utilitarian tool but a potent symbol of masculinity and nationalism” (148). Gallery audiences so anticipated Laura's escape from the shed that they chanted, “The axe! The axe!” as the noise of the approaching train grew louder (150–1).
If, quite reluctantly, I must find oversight in this splendidly abundant study, it is in Hughes's neglect of the incidental music on which melodrama depended. Music, too, had a role in the audience's reception of sensation. Spectators heard as well as saw, and what they heard colored their emotional responses—even if they were unaware that they had been influenced. Sheet music for these plays is accessible and merits eventual consideration.
Jeffrey Mason, Bruce McConachie, and John Frick have previously explicated the plays' forms, contents, and reception, and whereas Hughes acknowledges and values their informed insights, she has nonetheless charted her own course and has reached different, sometimes challenging, conclusions that draw on impeccably precise and carefully detailed readings of American life and culture. In addition to its function as a study of theatrical praxis, Spectacles of Reform is a mature cultural history, essential far beyond the theatre scholar's bookshelf. I am awed by the acuteness of Amy Hughes's vision, her method of querying text, production, and performance. I optimistically assume others will similarly profit from her instruction.
