I. INTRODUCTION
Adherents of the sociological theory of the development of science assert that when conditions are right, discovery in the form of new theories, or perhaps even a new paradigm,Footnote 1 is inevitable. The fullest exposition of this theory of knowledge is presented in The Sociology of Science by Robert Merton (Merton Reference Merton1973). As empirical evidence for the inevitability of discovery and invention when conditions are right, Merton cites the “simultaneous and independent appearance of the same scientific discovery,” which he terms a “multiple” (Merton Reference Merton1973, pp. 352, 343-370).Footnote 2 Later, Merton provides an explanation for what he means by the right conditions with the following: “Such occurrences [the appearance of multiples] suggest that discoveries become virtually inevitable when prerequisite kinds of knowledge accumulate in man's cultural store and when the attention of an appreciable number of investigators becomes focused on a problem … ” (Merton Reference Merton1973, p 371).
This approach to the development of science piqued my interest as I read the macroeconomic thought of William Petty (1623-1687)Footnote 3 and Nicholas Barbon (1640-1698),Footnote 4 two late seventeenth-century English economists. The similarities in their macroeconomic notions led me to wonder whether their respective writings contained empirical evidence of Merton's thesis. In this study, I verify that Petty and Barbon's economic writings do indeed include multiple independent discoveries of economic concepts. Moreover, I offer a new hypothesis that strengthens the inevitability theorem.
II. ARGUMENTS AGAINST THE THEORY OF INEVITABLE DISCOVERY
The history of science has long had an antithetical hypothesis to the theory of inevitable discovery. That theory—sometimes dubbed the “heroic theory” of scientific discovery—holds that the acquisition of knowledge in a discipline is for the most part the result of the efforts of the undeniable genius of the great men and women of science. An example of this type of intellect in “political economy,” or what is now termed economics, would be the works of the great innovatorsFootnote 5 of the discipline, such as Adam Smith, Alfred Marshall, and John Maynard Keynes.
Merton attempts to reconcile these two apparently opposing theories by first admitting that there are obviously people of genius in every science. Then he notes that
… Great scientists will have been repeatedly involved in multiples. First, because the genius will have made many scientific discoveries altogether; and since each of these is, on the first part of the theory, a potential multiple, some will have become actual multiples. Second, this means that each scientist of genius will have contributed the functional equivalent to the advancement of science of what a considerable number of other scientists will have contributed in the aggregate, some of these having been caught up in the repeated multiples in which the genius was actually involved
(Merton Reference Merton1973, pp. 366–367).Consequently, the heroic theory of scientific discovery is not contradictory to the theory of existential factors in a society bringing about an environment conducive to inevitable discovery. On the contrary, the presence of repeated multiples in cases of true genius is empirical evidence for the hypothesis that scientific discovery is often the result of scientific genius. Therefore, Merton concludes that “Far from being incompatible, the two [the theory that the acquisition of knowledge is dependent on ‘existential factors’ and the theory that the acquisition of knowledge is contingent on genius in science] complement one another” (Merton Reference Merton1973, p. 366).
Nicholas Georgescu-Roegen rejects what he terms the “inevitability theorem” (Georgescu-Roegen Reference Georgescu-Roegen, Heinrich Gossen and Blitz1983, p. xiv), the origin of which he attributes to Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels (Georgescu-Roegen Reference Georgescu-Roegen, Heinrich Gossen and Blitz1983, p. cxxxiii, n). By implication he accuses Merton of harboring the notion of inevitability, because it (the inevitability theorem) underlies the Mertonian theory of multiples.
Georgescu-Roegen cites three reasons for his rejection of the Mertonian approach, the first two of which are duly noted by proponents of the idea. First, in some instances, the necessary existential factors for a discovery are present long before it is made. Merton acknowledges this problem when he renders the following: “This recurrent fact of long-delayed discovery raises distinctive problems for the theory advanced here [the theory of multiples], but these are not unsolvable problems” (Merton Reference Merton1973, p. 369).
Secondly, Georgescu-Roegen considers the proof necessary to validate the theory to be largely ex post facto in nature. William F. Ogburn and Dorothy S. Thomas note this when they concede: “We do not always know beforehand what the necessary constituent cultural elements are that go into the making of an invention” (Ogburn and Thomas Reference Ogburn and Thomas1922, p. 91; emphasis added). Georgescu-Roegen reiterates his criticism with the following analogy: “The inevitability theorem is tantamount … to a theory of mushrooms according to which the only way to find out whether a mushroom is poisonous is to eat it” (Georgescu-Roegen Reference Georgescu-Roegen, Heinrich Gossen and Blitz1983, p. xvi).
Georgescu-Roegen advances his third reason for rejecting the inevitability theorem with the following observation: “But the idea that people may think, write, compose music, paint, or sculpt above their time is in direct contradiction to the teachings of another discipline, known as the ‘sociology of knowledge’” (Georgescu-Roegen Reference Georgescu-Roegen, Heinrich Gossen and Blitz1983, p. xii; emphasis added). In the parlance of Georgescu-Roegen, the term sociology of knowledge is akin to Merton's theory of multiples. In his Preface to The Laws of Human Relations (Georgescu-Roegen Reference Georgescu-Roegen, Heinrich Gossen and Blitz1983), Georgescu-Roegen cities Hermann Gossen as the best example in economics of the phenomenon of people who write above their time. The third censure by Georgescu-Roegen is in the opinion of this writer not a valid criticism of Merton's thesis. The fact that a particular scientist may occasionally write above his time does not obviate the notion that when existential factors are ripe, discovery is inevitable, nor that this is the usual manner in which knowledge is acquired in a discipline.
Nevertheless, Merton's inevitability theorem is incomplete, and, therefore, he leaves himself open to the first two aforementioned criticisms from Georgescu-Roegen. As it is now constructed, the Mertonian theory deals only with factors that are necessary for inevitable discovery. However, the elements emphasized by Merton, namely, the presence of newly emerging existential elements in a society, may not be sufficient for the appearance of multiple, independent discoveries. An additional hypothesis is necessary to provide “sufficient conditions” for inevitable discovery and is presented in the succeeding section of this paper. The term “sufficient conditions,” as used here, is not meant in the strict mathematical sense, but rather indicates that multiple discoveries of scientific theories are more likely if such provisions are met.
III. DEFINING THE SUFFICIENT CONDITIONS FOR INEVITABLE DISCOVERY
Karl Mannheim exempted the “exact sciences” from any element of existential determination, but believed that existential factors played a prominent role in scientific discovery in what he termed the “cultural sciences” (Mannheim Reference Mannheim, Wirth and Shills1936, p. 243). Correspondingly, this research focuses on the acquisition of knowledge as it pertains to the social sciences. Accordingly, in his introduction to a collection of essays by Mannheim, Paul Kecskemeti provided the inspiration for a postulate that might provide the sufficient conditions necessary for inevitable discovery, at least in the social sciences. He did so when he observed that the social actuality cannot be “‘known’ in the same way as natural objects get to be ‘known’” (Kecskemeti Reference Kecskemeti and Kecskemeti1952, p. 31). Hence, a social scientist must substitute something knowable for the unknowable actuality. This surrogate has come to be referred to as a scientist's “conceptualized reality” (Jensen Reference Jensen1983). A formal rendering of the precept is provided by Hans Jensen with the following: “… as I view it, a conceptualized reality is an experimentally conditioned, subjectively conceived, factually structured, and mentally formulated approximation to, or image of, the actual socioeconomic order of the contemporary society” (Jensen Reference Jensen1983, p. 70).
Hence, it appears to me that for the inevitability theorem to be valid, both necessary and sufficient conditions must be present. The necessary conditions for scientific discovery are provided by unique existential factors that may arise in a particular society at a given point in time. The additional hypothesis providing the sufficient conditions essential for inevitable discovery is that two or more investigators experiencing those same existential factors conceptualize them in a similar manner. That is, they tend to interpret that which they conceive of as contemporary phenomena from the same point of view. This perspective would occur because they have been exposed to similar philosophical notions; in particular, identical ideas as to cause-and-effect relationships. Therefore, if and only if existential factors are ripe for new discoveries and a number of scientists share the same conceptualized reality, i.e., they wear the same kind of philosophically and conceptually tinted “intellectual spectacles,” does the inevitability doctrine hold.
The evaluation of this potentially more comprehensive model of the inevitability doctrine requires that the historian of thought select the proper time period and place, as well as the proper social scientists for consideration. The era under consideration should be one where new existential factors are emerging that necessitates new explanations, particularly novel notions of cause-and-effect relationships among the new socioeconomic phenomena which are arising. Subsequently, if it is apparent that unique socioeconomic conditions were emerging during the historical time period and place being scrutinized, necessary conditions for testing the new inevitability theorem will have been established. Then, if it can be shown that two or more contemporaneous social scientists did indeed share a similar conceptualized reality during that same historical period, sufficient conditions for testing the more complete inevitability theorem will have been demonstrated.
IV. IDENTIFYING THE APPROPRIATE HISTORICAL CONTEXT AND ECONOMIC PRINCIPALS
One such time period and place where newly emerging existential factors certainly seem to be evident is the second half of the seventeenth century in England.Footnote 6 The semi-feudal economic society that had previously existed was becoming one in which markets were evolving into the major economic force in society. Custom, as the principal allocator of goods and services, gave way to the institutions of the newly emerging capitalist system. During this historical era, both product and labor markets became increasingly competitive as employers and workers were freed from various government regulations and controls. For example, the establishment of industrial monopolies and governmental support of price-fixing by trade associations was abandoned in England. Also, the process of individual bargaining between employers and employees became the norm for the setting of wage rates and working conditions. Finally, the underlying condition absolutely necessary for the establishment of a capitalist system—property rights—became institutionalized as the common law triumphed over the prerogative courts. During this era, England was beset by persistent unemployment as the economy transitioned from artisan-labor to wage-labor. A situation arose akin to what Arthur Lewis has described as “economic development with unlimited supplies of labor” (Lewis Reference Lewis1954, p. 139).
These newly emerging socioeconomic phenomena required new explanations as to cause-and-effect, and help provide an explanation as to “why … so much seventeenth-century English science (as Merton claims) [was] geared toward economic … ends” (Shapin Reference Shapin1988, p. 595). Consequently, the last half of the seventeenth century in England furnishes the necessary conditions for the inevitability theorem to be operable in economics. The newly emerging existential factors, which were evident in society as capitalism arose in England, provided a milieu in which discovery should be likely.
As posited above, for discovery to be truly inevitable, sufficient conditions must also be present. Also, as intimated above, I assert that such conditions exist when two or more social scientists simultaneously formulate similar conceptualized realities. It is my contention that the two aforementioned English writers of pamphlets on economic matters, William Petty and Nicholas Barbon, did share equivalent conceptualized realities of the macroeconomy in the historical era under consideration, sometimes referred to as the mercantilist period.Footnote 7
In The Origins of Scientific Economics: English Economic Thought 1660-1776, William Letwin made an observation with regard to the intellectual backgrounds of William Petty and Nicholas Barbon that affected me “as if scales had fallen from my eyes,” to quote Jeremy Bentham (Bentham Reference Bentham1962, vol. 1, p. 268). Letwin put it this way:
His education [Barbon's] would seem of little relevance to his career were it not that two other of the principal economic writers of the period, Petty, and Locke, also studied medicine, as did still other contemporaries prominently involved in economic policy, such as Benjamin Worsley and Hugh Chamberlen. Perhaps, medicine, as it was then taught in the Lowlands, was one of the few academic disciplines that could appeal to energetic young men interested in the modern learning rather than the ancient, and ambitious ones, who wanted an education that could be put to work
(Letwin Reference Letwin1963, p. 49).Their parallel academic training may have predisposed Petty and Barbon to conceptualize reality in similar terms.Footnote 8 In addition, Petty and Barbon were both actively involved in business, which could have reinforced this tendency. Petty established an iron and copper works, as well as a fishing operation on his most significant property in County Kerry, Ireland (Hull Reference Hull1899, vol. 1, p. xxv). Barbon was a prominent London builder of his time, as well as being engaged in the fledgling insurance and banking industries. Therefore, their similar educational backgrounds and business experiences may have caused them to construct analogous concepts out of observed data.
Robert Merton has gone to the extreme of arguing that not only are facts constructed by individuals, but so are data themselves. He expressed the idea as follows: “Despite the etymology of the term, data are not “given” but are “contrived” with the inevitable help of concepts” (Merton in Stark Reference Stark1958, p. 106). The idea of contrived data is important because it makes the conceptualized reality of the scientist even more significant, in that it is not only critical in determining notions of cause-and-effect, but it is also consequential in concocting data.
The notion of concocted data is especially relevant in the present context, because during the time period under consideration—late seventeenth-century England—economics was in a pre-paradigm condition. A pre-paradigm situation is considered by Thomas Kuhn to be evidence of a discipline that is in an embryonic stage and “as a result, early fact gathering is a far more nearly random [and independent] activity than the one that subsequent scientific development [the existence of a paradigm in a discipline] makes familiar” (Kuhn Reference Kuhn1970, p. 15). As a result, data gathering is a somewhat selective process, and, therefore, more highly subject to the normative aspects of data gathering referred to by Merton. This situation is aptly described by the phrase “Everyman his own economist” (Johnson Reference Johnson1937, p. 3).
As further evidence of the independence of Barbon and Petty's economic thought, I offer the following. Barbon's only mention of Petty is a demographic inference drawn from burial records in the London Bills of Mortality, a reference in which he credits John Gra[u]nt (1620-1674) and Sir William Petit [sic] as being co-authors (Barbon Reference Barbon1685, p. 27). Petty makes no reference to Barbon, and undoubtedly was unaware of him or his writings because Barbon's seminal economic writings, A Discourse of Trade (Barbon Reference Barbon1690) and A Discourse Concerning Coining the New Money Lighter. In Answer to Mr. Lock's Consideration about Raising the Value of Money (Barbon Reference Barbon1695) were published after Petty's death in 1687. With that in mind, a brief summary and subsequent comparison of Petty and Barbon's conceptualized realities follow in order to ascertain whether their respective conceptualized realities are so similar as to constitute the kind of sufficient conditions postulated above for the inevitability doctrine to hold.
V. PETTY AND BARBON'S CONCEPTUALIZATION OF EXISTENTIAL FACTORS
Important economic actors in William Petty's macroeconomic world included merchants; artisans, who were skilled and self-employed workers; unskilled workers, who largely worked for wages; and the state, more specifically, the central government. The merchant was the central actor in Petty's mercantile economy, for it was he who engaged in the central process of trade. Merchants were skilled professionals, who possessed among other talents “[t]he dext[e]rous use of arithmetic and keeping accompts [sic] … [and] knowledge of weights and measures … (Petty Reference Petty1927, vol. 1, p. 192). Petty additionally distinguishes between three types of merchants.
The first two groups were involved in the gathering and dispensing aspects of trade, and Petty dichotomized them on the basis of whether they were engaged in international or domestic trade. He describes the role of the merchant involved in international trade as “manag[ing] the Exchange of our superfluous Commodities [output in excess of domestic consumption] with the same of other countries … [while] Retailers are needed to make the subdistribution into every Village of this Nation, and to receive back their superfluities [output in excess of local consumption]” (Petty Reference Petty and Hull1662, p. 28).
The third type of merchant was the shop-owning enterpriser in manufacturing. He was an employer of both the artisans and the unskilled workers. The gathering and dispensing activities of the international and domestic merchants helped to determine the aggregate demand for domestically produced goods, for the merchants were the intermediaries between the producers (manufacturing enterprisers) and final demanders.
The artisans contribute to the country's output by engaging in various and sundry manufacturing processes. Furthermore, their contribution was enhanced by division of labor. Petty notes this when he renders the following:
But the gain which is made by Manufacturers, will be greater … [if] each Manufacture will be provided into as many parts as possible, whereby the Work of each Artisan will be simple and easie; As for example: In the making of a Watch, If one man shall make the Wheels, another the Spring, another shall Engrave the Dial-plate, and another shall make the cases …
(Petty Reference Petty and Hull1683, p. 473).The laborers in Petty's macroeconomic drama were the unskilled workers, a group which included day laborers and propertyless farm hands. Thus, Petty writes: “Labourers are such as have no trade, whereunto common Husbandmen may be added” (Petty Reference Petty1927, vol. I, p. 183). There were landlords, from among the peerage and gentry who hired the common husbandmen, as well as propertied farmers who worked their own land and were called yeomen. Petty differentiates the artisan from the laborer on the basis that the former has a skill or trade and is self-employed, where the latter is unskilled and works for wages. For laborers to contribute to the national output, they first had to be employed and secondly had to be disciplined in order to be productive.
The last significant actor in Petty's macroeconomic drama is the central government, which he thought should be preeminent in a truly Hobbesian fashion. In manuscript 65 of The Petty Papers, he confirms this influence with the following passage: “The Words Soveraignity & Empire doe signify even as Large a Power as Mr. Hobs [sic] attributes to his Leviathan; That is to say, a Power & Right of doing all things that are naturally possible” (Petty Reference Petty1927, vol. 1, p. 219). What Hobbes laid down in theory, Petty, through some of his economic writings, tried to put in practice (Fitzmaurice Reference Fitzmaurice1895, p. 188).
Merchants, artisans, and laborers, as well as the peerage, gentry, and foreigners, were important as consumers of national output. The peerage and gentry were especially important in this regard. Petty wrote that “[i]ncrease of Trade depends upon [i]ncrease of People and luxury in their consumption …” (Petty Reference Petty1927, vol. 1, p. 247; emphasis added). Clearly, the peerage and the gentry were the classes in society most able to afford luxury goods. Foreigners were valuable as consumers of unsold domestic output.
The two primary institutions in Petty's conceptualized reality are the households and institutions of financial intermediation. Households are an important institution in his world because they are necessary to shelter and provide a place to work for people, whom Petty regarded as a productive resource.Footnote 9 In this respect, he offers the following: Fewness of People, is real poverty, and a Nation wherein [there] are Eight Millions of people, are more than twice as rich as the same scope of Land wherein [there] are but Four …” (Petty Reference Petty and Hull1662, p. 34).
Financial establishments were also a part of Petty's socioeconomic world. These financial intermediaries, which at the time were in their institutional infancy, were necessary to facilitate interaction between borrowers (merchants) and lenders (peerage and gentry) for the purpose of furnishing credit for goods in transit. In Quantulumcunque Concerning Money, Petty proposes a remedy for a lack of money: “We must erect a Bank, which well computed, doth almost double the Effort of our coined Money” (Petty Reference Petty and Hull1695, p. 446). Consistent with Petty's desire to see financial intermediaries flourish in England and/or Ireland were his proposals for a land registry, which would reduce the risk involved in a land bank by more precisely controlling the collateral. For example, he writes: “… [Then] the said lands shall not only become as money, but as a Bank of money, which is far more safe and commodious than coynes” (Petty Reference Petty and Hull1662, p. 78). In a similar vein, he proffers the following recommendation to King James II: “… erect a Registry of Lands, which may [in] effect coyne lands into mon[e]y” (Petty Reference Petty1927, vol. 1, p. 257).
William Petty conceived of a political economy that was governed by natural laws. That is, the characters in his macroeconomic drama were driven by natural propensities, which, in essence, set barriers to state action. Thus, Alfred Chalk surmises that Petty's “favorite thesis is that the natural laws of society are so powerful that they can never be circumvented by ‘positive’ laws” (Chalk Reference Chalk1951, p. 343). In that vein, when referring to laws limiting usury, Petty writes that “of the vanity and fruitlessness of making Civil Positive Laws against the Laws of Nature, I have spoken elsewhere, and instanced the several particulars” (Petty Reference Petty and Hull1662, p. 48). Similarly, in explaining why laws prohibiting the exportation of bullion may impoverish a nation, he writes that “[p]erhaps they are against the Laws of Nature …” (Petty Reference Petty and Hull1695, p. 445).
In Nicholas Barbon's macroeconomic world, artificers, merchants, and the state, that is, the central government, are the major economic players. The artificers and merchants produce and distribute the national output. He defines the respective roles of these actors thusly:
… The making is called Handy-Craft Trade, and the maker an Artificer; The selling is called Merchandizing and Seller a Merchant: The Artificer is called by several Names from the sort of Goods he makes. As a clothier, Silk-weaver, Shoo-maker or Hatter, etc. from [the] Making of Cloth, Silk, Shooes, or Hats; And the Merchant is distinguished by the Names of the Countrey he deals to, and is called, Dutch, French, Spanish or Turk[ish] Merchant
(Barbon Reference Barbon1690, pp. 1–2; emphasis added).Hence, Barbon separated the role of the artificer from that of the merchant. The artificer produced the national output, while the merchant was responsible for selling the goods.
The merchant is also a skilled worker in the Barbonian world, and, accordingly, must acquire proficiency in that art:
Because the Difference in the Qualities of Wares, are so difficulty understood, it is [necessary] that the Trader [merchant] serves an Apprenticeship to learn them; and the knowledge of them is called the Mystery of Trade; and in common Dealing, the Buyer is forced to rely on the Skill and Honesty of the Seller, to deliver Wares with such Qualities as he affirms them to have …”
(Barbon Reference Barbon1690, p. 12; emphasis added).In contrast to Petty, Barbon does not distinguish between skilled and unskilled workers, for he views all labor as possessing some degree of skill. As a result, the class that Petty separates as laborers are part of the artisan class in Barbon's perception—an inconsequential difference. The merchant class engages in the process of trading, which is essential in the Barbonian world. Whereas Petty subdivided merchants into three types, Barbon lumped them together into one group.
The artificers and the merchants, along with the peerage, gentry, and foreigners, are the consumers of national output. Barbon places special emphasis on the peerage and gentry's important role in consumption, for it is they who have the means to purchase “the Wants of the Mind … [which] are infinite” (Barbon Reference Barbon1690, pp. 14–15). Consequently, he suggests that “conspicuous consumption” by this group is an important aspect of aggregate demand:
Beside, There is another great Advantage to Trade, by Enlarging of Cities; The two Beneficial Expenses of Cloathing and Lodging are Increased; Man being Naturally Ambitious, the Living together, occasion[s] Emulation, which is seen by Out-vying one another in Apparel, Equipage, and Furniture of the House; whereas, if a Man lived solitary alone, his chiefest Expence, would be Food
(Barbon Reference Barbon1690, p. 68; emphasis deleted).Apparently, for the most part, the peerage and the gentry determine whether or not there will be sufficient demand to ensure full employment.
Nicholas Barbon considers the state to be a crucial actor, whose prominent functions should be aimed at protecting and increasing the nation's most important economic process, trade. In this regard, Barbon writes that “[t]he seat of such an Empire [one whose dominion is gained by sea], must be an Island, that this Defence may be solely in shipping; the same way to defend their Dominion as to enlarge it” (Barbon Reference Barbon1690, p. 58). Barbon, although in favor of a strong central government, does view individual freedom as being important to the process of trade. Hence, he advocates what he terms the Gothic form of government, which being similar to the English Monarchy of that era, because it “… is Best for Trade; for men are most industrious, when they are most free …” (Barbon Reference Barbon1690, p. 51). The aspect of self-interest is implicit in Barbon's conceptualized reality, because he considers individual freedom to be an important attribute of a prospering economy.
The two prominent institutions in Nicholas Barbon's macroeconomic world are households and the embryonic financial institutions—the same organizations that populated Petty's milieu. Households are important in the Barbonian macroeconomic world for two reasons. First, they are necessary to shelter the people which Barbon pays heed to when he writes that “[h]ouses are Hives for the People to breed and swarm in, without which they cannot increase” (Barbon Reference Barbon1685, p. 26). Households were significant because Barbon, like Petty, regarded people as being a component of national wealth: “[T]he People are the Riches and Strength of the Country, And it is not much more [of an] Advantage to a Prince, to have a Title to Lands, in Terra Incognita, As to Countries without People” (Barbon Reference Barbon1690, p. 55). Secondly, most of the work was done in households by artisan-laborers. In this regard, he writes that “[h]ouses are the Places where the Artificers make their Goods, and Merchants Sell them” (Barbon Reference Barbon1690, p. 69).Footnote 10
The second group of consequential institutions in Nicholas Barbon's conceptualized reality was the fledgling establishments of financial intermediation. As with Petty, Barbon saw that these intermediaries were essential in providing the liquidity necessary for merchants to finance goods in transit. In fact, Barbon, seeing the need for financial intermediation and consistent with his entrepreneurial proclivities, founded a land bank with a partner, John Asgill. Barbon and Asgill announced that they would grant loans secured by mortgages at 3 ½ percent interest and that they would pay 2 percent interest on deposits (Horsefield Reference Horsefield1960, p. 198).
Ostensibly, there is one minor distinction between Petty's and Barbon's perception of the political economy. William Petty believed strongly that natural laws governed the workings of the economy, much as they governed the workings of nature. That is, the economic actors were imbued with certain innate desires, which governed their behavior. The writings of Nicholas Barbon do not exhibit any explicit belief in natural law. However, the motivations of the Barbonian economic actors can be implicitly interpreted as emanating from some type of natural propensity. Hence, Barbon favors the Gothic form of government because it permits individual freedom, where apparently these natural propensities can best be acted upon to the benefit of the economy.
Upon close examination, the differences between Petty and Barbon's conceptualized realities appear insignificant. Within these two economists' respective macroeconomic worlds, the same actors play similar roles with the same or similar institutional framework as a backdrop. Accordingly, sufficient conditions have been established to test the new inevitability theorem.
VI. ARE THERE MINI-MULTIPLES IN THE MACROECONOMICS OF PETTY AND BARBON?
Jurg Niehans, while noting that “[t]he existing literature on multiple discoveries in economics used the ‘case study’ approach [an in-depth analysis of one or two cases of potential multiple discovery] … in contrast uses the ‘overview’ approach [an analysis of many cases of potential multiple discovery with a corresponding sacrifice of some detail] pioneered … by Ogburn and Thomas and continued by Merton …” (Niehans Reference Niehans1995, p. 2). Limiting himself to what he calls “‘pure theory,’ at the exclusion of ideas, empirical findings and policy doctrine” (Niehans Reference Niehans1995, p. 2), Niehans uses the overview approach in citing forty examples of multiple discovery in economics, from Torrens and Ricardo's theory of comparative cost to the present (Niehans Reference Niehans1995, pp. 19–21).
In the following discussion, I will use the overview approach, in that I will be comparing several macroeconomic theories of William Petty and Nicholas Barbon, but without the sacrificing of necessary detail. In other words, I will be examining whether or not their respective individual theories constitute what I term “mini-multiples.” I am defining mini-multiples as simultaneous independent discoveries found within the respective bodies of literature of two or more economists.
The first theories to be compared will be Petty and Barbon's respective hypotheses regarding the impact of money on real variables. Here, the two early economists have identical theories, in that they both maintained that money was non-neutral—Petty had an additional theory regarding the “velocity of money,” which is absent from Barbon's writings. Not surprisingly, in lieu of his medical training, Petty in a famous medical metaphor described money as the “Fat of the Body-politic … [of which] too little makes it sick” (Petty Reference Petty1691a, p. 113). Then, in query 25 of Quantulumcunque Concerning Money, Petty estimates the money necessary to drive the nation's trade (Petty Reference Petty and Hull1695, p. 446). Barbon's conception of the non-neutrality of money is stated explicitly in various places in A Discourse Concerning Coining the New Money Lighter (Barbon Reference Barbon1695 Preface, pp. 25, 91–94). Barbon's own business affairs probably led him to the conclusion that an elastic money supply was necessary to efficiently drive a nation's trade, and, subsequently, that paper money collateralized by land would be required to ensure that supply.Footnote 11
William Petty and Nicholas Barbon both harbored underconsumptionist hypotheses. Petty explicitly stresses the importance of consumption on output in manuscripts 62 and 64 of The Petty Papers (Petty Reference Petty1927, vol. 1, pp. 214, 217). Then, he expresses his concerns about underconsumption that would result, ironically, from the “equal spreading of Wealth [which] would destroy all Splendor and Ornament” (Petty Reference Petty and Hull1691b, pp. 193–194).
Barbon propounds his underconsumptionist theory even more forcefully. In the following well-known passage from A Discourse of Trade, he writes that “Covetousness is a Vice, prejudicial both to Man & Trade; It starves the Man, and breaks the Trader; and by the same way the Covetous Man thinks he grows rich, he grows poor; for by not consuming the Goods that are provided for Man's Use, there ariseth a dead Stock, called Plenty …” (Barbon Reference Barbon1690, pp. 62–63). Then, in an unabashedly Veblenesque fashion, Barbon promotes conspicuous consumption as an important stimulus to consumption demand, and, ultimately, output and employment (Barbon Reference Barbon1690, pp. 65, 67, 69).
There are similarities and dissimilarities between Petty and Barbon's theories of the rate of interest. For example, they both compare interest to the rent of land. Petty observes: “As for Usury … [it] is the Rent of so much Land as the money will buy …” (Petty Reference Petty and Hull1662, p. 48). Barbon, in a similar vein, offers: “Interest is the Rent of Stock and is the same as the Rent of Land: The first is the Rent of the Wrought or Artificial Stock; the latter of the Unwrought or Natural Stock” (Barbon Reference Barbon1690, p. 31). Both economists seemed to think of interest as some type of income comparable to rent.
Their analyses diverge with respect to the interest rate. Petty, not surprisingly, considers the rate of interest to be governed by natural law. However, he slips into an incipient monetary theory of the rate of interest with the following: “But the natural fall of Interest, is the effect of the increase of mon[e]y” (Petty Reference Barbon1690, p. 304). Whereas Petty is lurching toward a monetary theory of the rate of interest, Barbon is groping toward a real theory of the rate of interest.Footnote 12 He notes that “[I]nterest is paid for Stock: for the Mon[e]y borrowed, is laid to buy Goods, or pay for them bought: No Man takes up Mon[e]y at Interest, to lay it by him, and lose the Interest of it” (Barbon Reference Barbon1690, pp. 31–32).
Petty and Barbon's theories of investment can both be termed interest-profit theories. To Petty, profit was the return to a merchant's stock (Petty Reference Petty and Hull1690, p. 307). This return on investment was calculated by subtracting the costs of the goods to the merchant, including interest costs, from the price at which merchandise would be sold. A higher rate of interest meant higher costs to the merchant. Thus, high rates of interest curtailed investment because the merchant would be less competitive, especially in international markets. Thus, Petty laments that “Interest in Ireland is 10 per Cent, which is a great hinderance to Trade; since the Interest must enflame the price of Irish Commodities, and consequently give to other Nations the means of underselling” (Petty Reference Petty and Hull1691b, p. 187; emphasis deleted).
Barbon's theory of investment is very similar to Petty's hypothesis. He, also, views profit as a return to a merchant's stock and perceives it to be restricted by the rate of interest. Accordingly, Barbon writes that “the Merchant expects by dealing to get more than Interest by his Goods … and therefore, reckons all he gets above Interest, is Gain; all under, Loss, if no more than Interest, neither Profit or Loss” (Barbon Reference Barbon1690, p. 32). Hence, both economists thought that investment in trade goods depended heavily on the rate of interest, which was in conflict with a merchant's profit.
William Petty and Nicholas Barbon have essentially identical hypotheses of international trade, which can best be described as theories based on absolute advantage. In this regard, Petty observes that one country can undersell others if it has natural and intrinsic advantages, by which he meant natural endowments and skilled workers (Petty Reference Petty and Hull1690, p. 258; Reference Petty1927, vol. 1, pp. 209–210). These natural and intrinsic advantages then translate into lower costs and increased market share. Barbon's theory of international trade stresses these same absolute advantages as being the determinants of the amount and type of commodities that a nation could expect to trade in international markets. He illustrates his proposition by identifying the staple commodities of the various European countries, which he believes are based on the absolute advantage they enjoy in the production of those goods (Barbon Reference Barbon1690, pp. 4–5).
Having described and compared Petty and Barbon's various macroeconomic theories; I can now categorize their respective discoveries as to whether or not they can rightly be considered examples of what I have named mini-multiples. In summary, William Petty had six theories. They are respectively his theory of non-neutral money, a theory of the velocity of money, a theory of underconsumption, a theory of the rate of interest, and theories of investment and international trade. Nicholas Barbon had economic laws regarding all of the above, except for a theory of the velocity of money.
Four of the respective macroeconomic discoveries Petty and Barbon independently formulated can rightly be classified as mini-multiples. These theories include their corresponding discoveries regarding the effect of money on the economy (non-neutral), consumption (underconsumptionest), investment (interest-profit theories), and international trade (absolute costs based on absolute advantage). Their respective discoveries in respect to the interest rate, while similar in some respects, are different in that Petty's analysis tended to be monetary in nature, while Barbon's theory can be regarded as a real analysis of the interest rate. To conclude, the fact that Petty and Barbon formulated four similar macroeconomic laws in their respective bodies of thought—principles which can accurately be described as mini-multiples—lends some credence to my new inevitability hypothesis.
Having compared and contrasted the individual economic laws of William Petty and Nicholas Barbon, I would like to offer an additional analysis of their economic writings in an effort to determine whether their writings do indeed represent independent, multiple discoveries. This interpretation will involve a stricter criterion for validation of multiple discoveries, a comparison of the main focus of both economists’ writings.
VII. DO THE “CENTRAL MESSAGES” OF PETTY AND BARBON REPRESENT MULTIPLES?
Don Patinkin, while considering the notion of multiple discoveries, states that “… a scientist should not be regarded as having made a discovery unless it is part of his “central message” (Patinkin Reference Patinkin1983, p. 306; emphasis added). Patinkin illustrates his concept of a central message in the following passage:
… in studying a man's writings we mush distinguish between that which was fully integrated into his conceptual framework and that which was not; between the systematic component of his thinking and the random component; between, if you wish, the “signal”— or what I have called the “central message”— the writer wished to convey and the “noise”
(Patinkin Reference Patinkin1982 p. 16; emphasis added).Footnote 13Having described the central message, Patinkin later addresses the problem of identifying such a message:
In general, however, the literature that we have been examing [the writings of Keynes, the Stockholm school, and Kalecki] does not provide a precise and unambiguous statement of its central message: of the major problem to which it addresses itself and the conclusions it reaches. And in the absence of such a statement I suggest identifying the central message in much the same way that we identify the theme of a movement in a classical symphony: by its being announced early in the movement and by repetition afterward—either exactly or by different combinations of instruments or in different tonal areas. So is the central message of a scientific work announced by its presentation early in the work (and frequently in its title) and by repetition, either verbatim or modified in accordance with the circumstances. Let me also emphasize that this announcement mush be read in … the context of the events in the real world then impinging on the writer
(Patinkin Reference Patinkin1982, pp. 82–83; emphasis added).Because William Petty and Nicholas Barbon wrote before the time of more formal treatises on the political economy, and, therefore, during a period of somewhat unsystematic theorizing, identifying their respective central messages may appear, at first glance, rather difficult. However, the criteria presented above by Don Patinkin for identifying a scientist's central message are unambiguous and should make it possible to discern the central messages of theses two late seventeenth-century economists. Consequently, a conclusion can be drawn as to whether or not the systematic components of Petty and Barbon's macroeconomic thought can be regarded as independent, multiple discoveries, as portrayed in Patinkin's notion of a central message.
The primary process in William Petty's macroeconomic world is trade, which he defines thusly: “Trade is the making [production], gathering [buying by wholesalers], dispensing [retailing], and exchanging of commodities [in markets]” (Petty Reference Petty1927, vol. 1, p. 210). Thus, Petty viewed trade as a continuous economic process from point of production, to the stage of sale to final purchasers, with all activities taking place in markets.
Petty makes his most explicit reference as to the importance of trading activity in the following passage from The Political Anatomy of Ireland:
Through Trade, properly speaking, be the Commutation of Commodities, that generally speaking, ‘tis the way whereby to Purchase Riches and Power, the Parents of Pleasure: Not only by getting commodities out of the Earth and Sea; by ploughing, fishing, Mines, Vecture, etc. [but] by getting away those Commodities from them [the non-trading artificers and laborers], who first got them out of the Earth and Sea, as aforesaid
(Petty Reference Petty and Hull1691b, p. 194).Real world events of seventeenth-century Europe led William Petty to conceive of unemployment as the main dilemma in his conceptualized reality.Footnote 14 The fundamental cause of unemployment was a lack of trade.
Petty's central message then flowed from his macroeconomic analyses and was embedded in his policy proposals. Specifically, if Petty's policies were adopted, the primary problems of lack of trade and unemployment would be lessened and the resultant increase in tax revenue would allow England, in the terminology of John Brewer, to emerge as a strong “fiscal-military state” (Brewer Reference Brewer1989). Petty is explicit in announcing his central message early in his first strictly economic pamphlet, A Treatise of Taxes and Contributions:
The Publick Charges of a State are, That of its Defence by Land and Sea, of its Peace at home and abroad, as also of its honourable vindication from the injuries of other States; all of which we may call the Charge of the Militia, which commonly is in ordinary [times] as great as any other Branch of the whole; but extraordinary, (that is, in time of War or fear of War) is much the greatest
(Petty Reference Petty and Hull1662, p. 18).Petty's proposals were essentially aimed at increasing trade as a way of establishing England as a strong fiscal-military state in relation to its European rivals. The goals were an adequate money supply, low interest rates, and free international trade, with some minor modifications. With regards to money, Petty euphorically recommends that “if we have too little money … [England] must erect a Bank … which shall furnish [money] Stock large enough to drive the Trade of the whole Commercial World” (Petty Reference Petty and Hull1695, p. 446). Petty, consistent with his low interest policy, further notes that “[w]here [b]anks are interest will be low” (Petty Reference Petty1927, vol. 1 p. 246).
Petty's belief in free trade was modified with slight exceptions. “As for the Prohibition of Importations,” Petty writes, “I say that it need not be, until they much exceed our Exportations” (Petty Reference Petty and Hull1662, p. 60). Also, consistent with his overriding concern about employment, Petty did recommend that “[c]ustoms upon imported Commodities … ready and ripe for Consumption may be made somewhat dearer [through higher customs] … whereas things not fully wrought and Manufactured … ought to be gently dealt with [in terms of customs duties] (Petty Reference Petty and Hull1662, pp. 55–56).
The main problem in Nicholas Barbon's conceptualized reality is a lack of trade, a process which he describes with the following: “Trade is the Making and Selling of one sort of Goods for another …” (Barbon Reference Barbon1690, p. 1). Barbon describes the effects of trade, or more to the point, the effects of its decay with the following:
… [s]o that by Trade, the Inhabitants are not only well Fed, Clothed and Lodged; but the Richer sort are Furnished with all the things to promote the Ease, Pleasure, & Pomp of Life: Whereas, in the same country where there's no Trade, the Land-Lords would have but coarse Diet, Coarser Clothes, and worse Lodgings; and nothing for the Rent of their Lands, but the Homage and Attendance of their Poor Bare-footed Tenants, For they have nothing else to give
(Barbon Reference Barbon1690, pp. 36–37).Nicholas Barbon's central message was then ensconced in his policy proposals, which as with Petty sprang from his macroeconomic analyses, and was meant to deal with insufficient trade and unemployment. Barbon believed that if his proposals were adopted, trade and employment would increase with a concomitant increase in tax revenue, and would establish England as a strong fiscal-military state. Barbon announces his central message in the Preface to his first purely economic tract, A Discourse of Trade:
Trade is now become as necessary to Preserve Governments, as it is useful to make them Rich. And not withstanding the great Influence, that Trade hath in the Support and Welfare of States and Kingdoms, yet there is nothing more unknown, or that Men differ more in their Sentiments, than about the True Causes that raise and promote Trade
(Barbon Reference Barbon1690, preface; emphasis deleted).Later in the Treatise, Barbon echoes this sentiment:
Trade increaseth the Revenue of the Government, by providing an Imploy for the People: For every Man that Works, pay[s] by those things which he Eats and Wears, som[e]thing to the Government. Thus the Excise and Custom's are raised, and the more every Man earns, the more he Consumes, and the King's Revenue is the more Increased
(Barbon Reference Barbon1690, p. 39).Hence, Barbon's policies were aimed at increasing trade as a means of building England into a robust fiscal-military state. The goals of policy were a sufficient money supply, low interest, and free international trade. In terms of an adequate money supply, Barbon writes that for countries that depend upon trade:
Money is the Measure of Commerce; And for a Nation to be without money, is the same thing, is the same thing as if it were without measures; and had neither Yards, Scales, nor Bushels in the Country; without some of which, no Bargain can be made. … [I]n England, where the great Body of the People depend upon Trade, and that by the Selling of such Goods, the greatest part of which People are under no great necessity of having, but may shift without; and have no way of feeding themselves but by the profit of such Bargains, they cannot live without money; and if there were no money, would starve …
(Barbon Reference Barbon1695, pp. 92–93; emphasis deleted).In proposing that the rate of interest in England be at least as low as in Holland—England's major economic competitor in the latter half of the seventeenth century—Barbon notes that “[i]nterest is higher in England than in Holland … [and, therefore] he concludes that the “English Merchant Trades with a Disadvantage, because he cannot sell the same sort of Goods … for the same Value as the Dutch Merchant” (Barbon Reference Barbon1690, pp. 79–80; emphasis deleted).
Nicholas Barbon's proposal for free trade is most clearly expressed below:
The Prohibition of [international] Trade, is the Cause of its Decay; for all Foreign Wares are brought in by the Exchange of the Native: So that the Prohibiting of any Foreign Commodity doth hinder the Makeing and Exportation of so much of the Native, as used to be Made and Exchanged for it. The Artificers and Merchants, that dealt in such Goods, los[t] their Trades; and the Profit that was gained by such Trades, and laid out amongst other Traders, is Lost
(Barbon Reference Barbon1690, p. 71; emphasis deleted).Barbon, like Petty, hesitated in a total advocacy of free trade if it depressed employment. Thus, Barbon notes that duties are acceptable “[i]f the bringing in of Foreign Goods, should hinder the making and consuming of the Native, which will very seldom happen …” (Barbon Reference Barbon1690, p. 78). An increase in unemployment would occur only if the majority of imports were manufactured goods “because nothing can be sent in Exchange that Imploys fewer Hands than [wrought goods] …” (Barbon Reference Barbon1690, p. 76).
Upon careful examination, William Petty and Nicholas Barbon's economic writings appear to exhibit identical central messages as defined by Patinkin. Both economists proposed similar expansionary economic policies based on their overall concern about a lack of trade and the accompanying problem of unemployment. This message occurs early in the writings of each pamphleteer and is echoed throughout their respective treatises, which qualifies their findings as multiple discoveries in the Patinkinian sense.
VIII. CONCLUSION
Robert Merton is the most well-known proponent of the theory that when certain existential factors arise in a society, discovery in the form of new knowledge within a discipline is inevitable. He cites as empirical evidence for this notion, simultaneous and independent discoveries of similar concepts, which he terms multiples. My research adds a postulate to the Mertonian theory. For discovery to be truly inevitable, or at least more likely, certain existential factors must exist and two or more scientists must share a similar conceptualized reality.
The conceptualized realities and concomitant macroeconomic thought of two late seventeenth-century economists, William Petty and Nicholas Barbon, have been examined and compared. This analysis first revealed that these two early economists did indeed share similar conceptualized realities. After establishing these sufficient conditions for the new inevitability theory, Petty and Barbon's economic thought were contrasted using two separate techniques in a search for the existence of multiples. First, using the aforementioned overview approach to independent, multiple discoveries, as innovated by Ogburn and Thomas and articulated by Merton and Niehans, an analysis of the macroeconomic writings of William Petty and Nicholas Barbon revealed four mini-multiples: These simultaneous, independent discoveries include non-neutral money, a theory of underconsumption, an interest-profit theory of investment, and a theory of absolute costs based on absolute advantage in international trade.
Secondly, the macroeconomic writings of Petty and Barbon were assessed to determine whether or not their thought met the more stringent criterion for independent, multiple discovery—a shared central message, as propounded by Don Patinkin. An interpretation of the economic theorizing of these two seventeenth-century political economists does reveal equivalent central messages. The central messages of Petty and Barbon were essentially the expansionary macroeconomic policies of adequate money, low interest, and free international trade, which they believed, if adopted, would increase trade and employment and, in so doing, help to establish England as the preeminent fiscal-military state in Europe.
